600 cold emails, 0 customers — honest update on my SEO SaaS
I built SEO Spark (seospark.net) — an AI blog writer for local businesses. Launched 2 weeks ago.
The numbers so far:
Emails sent: ~1,300
Replies: 2
Paying customers: 0
Cold email works like this: 60% of my blind guess emails actually land. Then nobody reads them. Then nobody replies. Then you sit there wondering if anyone even saw your name.
What I learned:
-
"I'll write blog posts for you" is not a pitch. Nobody wakes up thinking "I need blog posts." They wake up thinking "I need more customers."
-
The people who need SEO tools are already using something. The people who don't — they're not going to buy from a cold email.
-
Free tools actually work better than cold outreach. My free SEO checker gets more engagement than any cold email I've sent.
I'm not shutting down. Just recalibrating. Going to focus on Reddit, Indie Hackers, and organic content instead of blasting more inboxes.
If you've sold to small business owners before — what actually worked?
This is a really honest post, and the cold email numbers track with what I've seen too. 1,300 sends for 2 replies isn't a you problem, it's a channel problem at this stage.
A few thoughts, mostly from getting a similar gut punch myself:
The pitch issue is the real one. You nailed it already. "I'll write blog posts for you" describes the feature, not the outcome. Small business owners don't buy blog posts, they buy "more calls from Google." If your subject line or opener doesn't say that in plain words, it gets skipped even if it lands in the inbox.
Cold email to strangers rarely works before you have proof. Not because cold email is dead, but because a stranger with zero signal has no reason to trust a claim from someone they've never heard of. What tends to work better this early is replying to people who are already saying the pain out loud. A local business owner complaining about Google rankings on Reddit or a Facebook group is already halfway sold, a cold inbox is not.
Your free SEO checker getting more engagement is the actual signal here, not a consolation prize. That's your channel. People trust a tool that shows them something true about their own site more than they trust a sales pitch. I'd double down hard on that specifically, use it to start real conversations instead of chasing more cold volume.
On Reddit and IH, agree with the pivot, but go narrow. Find threads where someone is already asking "how do I get more customers" or complaining about their blog not ranking, and reply there with something useful before ever mentioning the product.
Rooting for you on this one, the honesty in this post alone probably gets you further than the 1,300 emails did.
(Working through a similar problem myself with a sales tool for early stage SaaS founders, gnxsales.com if it's ever useful to compare notes.)
The 2 replies from 1,300 emails suggest the biggest issue may be targeting and positioning, not just deliverability. “AI blog writer” describes the product, but “help local businesses get found and win more customers” describes the outcome. I’d test a much narrower niche and message before giving up on outreach completely.
I appreciate that you didn't conclude the problem was simply "send more emails."
The shift from selling blog posts to thinking about the outcome customers actually want feels like the more interesting lesson here. I'll be curious which conversations or experiments end up changing your understanding of the problem next.