Feedback for simple budget app

Hey, here are my thoughts:

• I think the decision to include automatic uploads or not, comes down to who you are building this for. When I was rocking a minimum wage paycheck and every cent counted - manual was really important for me to keep our household finances in order and to force myself to be aware of every dollar spent (as you mentioned above). But now that I've worked my way up to a decent salary, have a kid, a side hustle, and other hobbies and responsibilities I don't have the time to manually manage every transaction and unfortunately I will immediately reject a budgeting app that requires manual input. This is just my experience though, your mileage may vary.

• Adjacent to the above point, are you trying to make money off of this? If you're going the ad route, then that's fine, but if you're going to charge you're going to really need to answer the who question above. Let's say for a second my experience above is representative of your audience - in the days I was manually managing my budget I was using excel/google sheets because I didn't have the disposable income to pay for a budgeting app. Now I have the disposable income if I so choose to, but I have no interest in manual transaction uploads. I could be the minority here though, just something to dig into.

• What makes you distinct from Mint, YNAB, etc? These are well known companies that offer free or paid services, and do a great job. Niche down and niche down again. A good example of this is Tiller (https://www.tillerhq.com/) - they standout with a unique value add.

• One personal thought, and maybe an idea for you on that value-add. I want a budgeting app that challenges the norm of a month-based budget. Income these days is fluid, especially in family households where you have multiple incomes that may vary in amount month to month and potentially include side gigs/hustles that also vary on when and how much get paid out. I'm not sure what that looks like, but it would be unique.