1
3 Comments

How do you budget and what do you like / not like about your solution?

Hi everyone – I’m in the process of developing a simple web-based budget application that’s focused on simplicity and promoting an understanding of your daily spend.

I would love to hear about everyone’s home-grown budgeting solutions or application solutions that they’re using, and I’d love to share some of my ideas as well.

I personally never found much success with apps like Mint or others where all of your expenses are automatically uploaded from your bank account and you just read off a report – I wanted to have a solution that made me responsible for every transaction I made and the ability tag and track certain incomes and expenses related to my side-hustles.

I’ve been using a homegrown Excel solution for the past few years and am now in the process of building a web-app that does even more.

I’m really interested in hearing about everyone’s experiences with budget solutions and would appreciate any perspective on the following questions:

  1. What budgeting solution are you currently using?
  2. What features are most important to you?
  3. What features do you wish your budget had
  4. What are some things you find difficult to do with your current budget?
  5. Do you have a side-hustle or another form of income and how are you currently tracking the income and associated expenses?
  6. Would you $2.99 a month for a web-based budget solution?

I’m excited to hear back from everyone and I’m going to try and get a landing page up in the short-term that will explain the idea in more detail and let you signup for updates.

I’ll respond to any comments or questions that come up!
Thanks – John

  1. 1

    Hey John.
    I am not your target audience, but more of a "competitor". I work on https://moneypin.io which will give you budgeting + a lot more. However I am willing to share knowledge.
    If you are interested, email me at skwee357 [at] gmail.com

  2. 1

    Saw zero replies and don’t want to discourage you. I think your idea is good if you pitch it as the anti-Mint.

    I currently use Mint. It has easy integration with my accounts, auto categorizing, budget notifications when going over, easy editing and costs me $0.

    If you pitch it as: we don’t sell your data, can always export/import your own spreadsheets and some weekly or monthly reporting features, a dashboard and notification functionality, I think those would be handy.

    Have you tried selling this to businesses looking to do expense reporting and tracking?

    1. 1

      Thanks for the great feedback - I'm not discouraged, I know that the idea of a budget could be thought of as kind of boring or lackluster, but money is on the forefront of everyone's mind and most people are incapable of properly reading a budget. I read an article just the other day that 60% of adults don't have a budget and another study that majority of American's can't come up with $1,000 for an emergency in two weeks time, which just blows my mind how on the edge everyone lives.

      Your pitch actually reads a lot like the "differentiators & features" that I came up with. Also, by maintaining the budget yourself you start to shift your mindset because you know have to go enter that transaction later, so hopefully it leads to a lifestyle spend shift for the user.

      At the moment I'm just focused on building out the core budget features that I have right now in my Excel file, and a little more functionality as well. Business may be down the road but it's not in my headlights at the moment.