Hey JP - congrats on overcoming procrastination and getting this project out into the wild!
I like the idea in general and it's a problem that all makers will face. Getting feedback from users is the best gut check out there to make sure what I'm building (www.tribefive.me for reference) is valuable.
With that said, here are two questions I have:
Who are the people who will be reviewing the product? You've called them "experts" but what defines an expert?
What is the incentive for someone to give feedback using your product? Are they getting paid?
I ask because I've found that while getting feedback is important, not all feedback is equal.
Cheers!
Jonathan
1
Hey Jonathan. Thanks for your kind words.
Nowadays I'm working on a page in order to regular users become an expert. For now, the "experts" are people with senior level that I met during the lasts years in different works & projects. I'm trying to have different profiles (programmers, designers, architects, CTO's, marketing experts, etc.)
If all of this works well, my next move is to provide an incentive for experts and let people choose "which kind of expert" they prefer.
Keep in mind that I started this project on 30th August (still a looot of WIP).
2
It sounds great! : )
2
I like the idea, I rather leave my comments on your platform ; )
Thanks Sebastian! Nice, I have planned many improvements and new features, so stay tuned :)
2
Looks nice, haven't read the whole thing. But you misspelled "perfomrenance" on your landing page :p
Like the design, but you should look into making it more mobile friendly. I have an iPhone 7 and the text in the roast button didn't fit, and the scrolling text was misaligned on mobile.
Otherwise really nice!
2
Ops! Solving both things, thanks!
2
Damn. I've decided to build a 'feedback service out of good will to help designers' two weeks ago and since then two 'FAAS' have been launched :D I literally have everything coded but waiting to do some details and launch. Now I have second thoughts - should I scrap it and charge for it?
Nice page by the way. I have one question though - will you let me roast your 'let me roast website' website? 😂
2
I think you should launch it :) then see if you want to take the time and effort to grow it, if you stop each time someone else has beat you too it you will most likely never launch anything :)
2
Hi Martin and thanks. It happens to me too, once starting one project, lots of similar products 'appear'. Look at the bright side: you had a good idea.
Hey JP - congrats on overcoming procrastination and getting this project out into the wild!
I like the idea in general and it's a problem that all makers will face. Getting feedback from users is the best gut check out there to make sure what I'm building (www.tribefive.me for reference) is valuable.
With that said, here are two questions I have:
Who are the people who will be reviewing the product? You've called them "experts" but what defines an expert?
What is the incentive for someone to give feedback using your product? Are they getting paid?
I ask because I've found that while getting feedback is important, not all feedback is equal.
Cheers!
Jonathan
Hey Jonathan. Thanks for your kind words.
Nowadays I'm working on a page in order to
regularusers become an expert. For now, the "experts" are people with senior level that I met during the lasts years in different works & projects. I'm trying to have different profiles (programmers, designers, architects, CTO's, marketing experts, etc.)If all of this works well, my next move is to provide an incentive for experts and let people choose "which kind of expert" they prefer.
Keep in mind that I started this project on 30th August (still a looot of WIP).
It sounds great! : )
I like the idea, I rather leave my comments on your platform ; )
Thanks! You can write your feedback on https://roastme.xyz/roast/roastme I will look forward your comment!
Love the idea and process you followed for it!
Going to be keeping an eye on it.
Thanks Sebastian! Nice, I have planned many improvements and new features, so stay tuned :)
Looks nice, haven't read the whole thing. But you misspelled "perfomrenance" on your landing page :p
Like the design, but you should look into making it more mobile friendly. I have an iPhone 7 and the text in the roast button didn't fit, and the scrolling text was misaligned on mobile.
Otherwise really nice!
Ops! Solving both things, thanks!
Damn. I've decided to build a 'feedback service out of good will to help designers' two weeks ago and since then two 'FAAS' have been launched :D I literally have everything coded but waiting to do some details and launch. Now I have second thoughts - should I scrap it and charge for it?
Nice page by the way. I have one question though - will you let me roast your 'let me roast website' website? 😂
I think you should launch it :) then see if you want to take the time and effort to grow it, if you stop each time someone else has beat you too it you will most likely never launch anything :)
Hi Martin and thanks. It happens to me too, once starting one project, lots of similar products 'appear'. Look at the bright side: you had a good idea.
Of course you can roast your website! ;)