May 30, 2018

Tell IH: 10 winners of the Productized Service challenge

Hey IH,

Last week I posted a fun challenge on Indie Hackers. I mentioned I would help 10 Indie Hackers launch their productized service and help them get to $1000 in revenue per month. Here is the original post: https://www.indiehackers.com/forum/tell-ih-i-am-going-to-help-10-indie-hackers-launch-their-productized-service-285e37977e

First of all, thanks a lot for all the submissions and for the time you have taken. I know you guys have poured a lot of energy into this.

I received a lot of submissions and this was hard to really pick them, all applications were really good honestly.

Here are the winners!

  • @Chrisgozd -- Who wants to create a Mobile-apps-as-a-service

  • @thrawn -- Who wants to create Sales-copywriting-as-a-service

  • @quentin_gilon -- Who wants to create an Excel-financial-dashboards-as-a-service

  • @parakeet -- Who wants to create a PR-as-a-service

  • @benforeva -- Who wants to create a Naming-as-a-service

  • @francopetra -- Who wants to create a Peer-group-as-a-service

  • @jhberk -- Who wants to create a Linkedin-Automation-as-a-service

  • @iaup -- Who wants to create a Fitness-advice-as-a-service

  • @jdams -- Who wants to create a Copywriting-as-a-service

  • @tyrelj13 - Who wants to create a Content-as-a-service

Some of the winners need help on developing a clear and unique value proposition, knowing exactly who their customers would be, and even set up a MVP. They will do all of this transparently, in public. Support them and reach out to them!

Next steps:

  1. All winners of the first batch will receive an invite to a FB group tomorrow before 10pm Pacific Time. The FB group will be a place to discuss their ideas, show their work in progress, and so on.

  2. I will talk to 5 founders on Saturday evening, and 5 founders on Sunday evening. I will discuss with them their productized service idea/business model, answer their questions, and set up with them clear action points and deliverables and will hold them accountable on it. I will also take time each week to help them.

  3. Next week Friday (8th of June), the winners will give their first update on IH: They will introduce you their service and business model, their progress, their current revenues (if any), their obstacles. They will share everything transparently with you.

All the other applicants: Thanks for applying and go for it! Tag along and ship your productized service. Feel free to email me (I will reply to all emails within a few days) if you have questions about productized services (robin at manypixels DOT co)


  1. 6

    Ah man, this feels like my big break!

    So excited to be picked and to get started. 🤠

    Thanks 🙌 @Vinrob and congrats 👏 @Chrisgozd @thrawn @quentin_gilon @parakeet @benforeva @francopetra @iaup @jdams and @tyrelj13 -

    Excited to be building with you all. 🛠️

    See you in the private group.

    1. 2

      Thanks @Vinrob!!

      This is great! Really excited to meet all of you, and se how your projects evolve!

  2. 3

    Congrats to all winners. Even I'm not in, I know your progress here on IH well help us.

  3. 3

    Oh wow! Looking forward to working with you Robin.

  4. 2

    Any news guys?

    1. 3

      Hey Pasquale! Will post the update today :)

      1. 1

        Thanks, I can't wait :)

      2. 1

        This comment was deleted 3 months ago.

  5. 2

    Congratulation to all the winners :)

  6. 2

    Glad to hear the news! Super excited to be working with @Vinrob and everyone in this group!

    Big thanks once again to Robin for doing this and I can't wait to discuss our projects with you all!

  7. 2

    Couldn’t be more excited! Getting ready for the challenge and knowledge sharing opportunity.

    See you soon 😄!

  8. 1

    Out of the ten winners who has turned their idea into a business, is anyone making a good ROI yet.

  9. 1

    @vinrob sorry for radio silence, I have been pretty busy. Also have not been active on Facebook for a couple of years. Not sure what that means for us. Just followed you on Twitter. Thanks.

    1. 1

      Hey @parakeet can you send me a message there? Then I will follow you :)

  10. 1

    Cool initiative Robin! Congrats to the winners!

  11. 1

    Yes!! So excited, this is a fantastic opportunity for all of us selected. Thank you @Vinrob .

    Congrats @Chrisgozd @thrawn @quentin_gilon @parakeet @benforeva @francopetra @jhberk @iaup @tyrelj13

    Guys - my initial write-up was about wanting to be involved in books/text, so I threw around some ideas about publishing, ghostwriting, and editing, but my winning selection was summarized by @Vinrob as a copywriting as a service. Since there are three of us in that space already, should I shift to straight up "Editing as a Service" to keep things different and interesting for us? I'm thinking maybe the 10 of us on 10 different paths will lead to more interesting results and opportunities for us to use each other's services, too.

    What are your thoughts?

    1. 1

      I think it all comes down to what you're feeling up for.

      Go the direction you feel you can provide the best service, in the best way and to the best/right customers. Pretty sure @Vinrob will give you good guidance during your call too.

      The whole idea of using each other's services is super interesting - looking forward to seeing how that plays out. :)

      1. 3

        Doing the "best service, in the best way, and to the best/right customers" is great advice from @jhberk.

        I've bounced around several ideas that I'm passionate about but eventually stuck to sales copywriting/articles/proofreading as a service because it was my lowest hanging fruit due to my experience and my thinking that I could fit it well into the business model of productized services.

        It'll definitely be interesting to see how we can complement each other by partnering in the future (maybe through referring our clients or working together on a larger project)

        1. 1

          Thanks @thrawn and @jhberk . Did you guys get setup in a group chat yet? It would be good to get us all on the same platform so we can communicate with each other.

          I have Telegram, Discord, Twitter, and WeChat already. I can download and use anything, really, just waiting to get an update on what we're doing.

          1. 1

            @jdams yeah we are. it's as closed FB group.

            @vinrob posted this somewhere else in the thread: "Please add me on FB or follow me on Twitter so that I can give you access to the group :)"

            1. 1

              My bad, I sent my request to join the group now :) Should be in soon.

  12. 1

    Hey guys,

    @Chrisgozd

    @thrawn

    @quentin_gilon

    @parakeet

    @benforeva

    @francopetra

    @jhberk

    @iaup

    @jdams

    @tyrelj13

    Please add me on FB or follow me on Twitter so that I can give you access to the group :)

    1. 1

      For the ones that aren't in the group yet. Look up for Productized Service Challenge Batch #1 on FB.

    2. 1

      Working on it, will send notice when sent!

      1. 1

        Sounds good. If you can't join FB / don't want to you can also add me on Telegram, just send me your account via DM :)

        1. 1

          Hiya, tried to join the group via the twitter link your sent yesterday but it doesn't seem to have added me to the group yet. Have also sent you DMs on Twitter and FB. I'll try to contact you via Telegram.

        2. 1

          Found that I couldn't DM you on Twitter. (@_jdams). Did we get a group going yet? We could use Telegram, I signed up for it earlier today, but if 1 on 1 and group chat is easier with another app (WeChat, Twitter, Slack, etc.) we can look for alternatives. You're in charge so you can decide :)

  13. 1

    Congrats on this. Will be looking forward to reading about it. Anyway.. just going to point it out.. anyone going to do a "Productized Service advice" as a Service (just for the meta :))

    1. 1

      I may very well be wrong but I think that's the direction @Vinrob is looking to go into.

      1. 1

        Yup though right now as a small disclaimer: I do it strictly for the sake of helping others and I still need to be quite focused on Manypixels, but yes I think it's an interesting market to explore, there are not a lot of information on it, and I might want to do something later in that niche :) But for now: Just for fun!

  14. 1

    Awesome! I'm so excited to start the journey with everyone. Thanks again for doing this!

  15. 1

    It's a pleasure to be part of this group. I'm looking forward to working with you all. June is going to be full of hard work and massive growth!

  16. 1

    Congrats guys!!

    Looking forward to the updates on IH :)

    Are there any particular rules/ strategy for the content shared?

  17. 1

    Hello @Vinrob

    Can you explain what were the things lacking in my and other productized services which didn't get chosen?

    Like who havn't got selected does that means they have chosen wrong service to productize them?

    1. 4

      Hey Biku,

      1. I am not an expert on productized service. I have had a moderate success with my current project (and also ran a previous service where I ran an online relocation agency for international students) so I cannot say your idea is good or bad.

      2. Honestly, a lot of applications were good. I mentioned before I had no strict formula (or no formula at all) to pick the winners.

      3. As regard to your productized service: Do not get discouraged! -- Reach out to me and I'll certainly be able to see how I can help / answer some of your questions.

      Finally -- To make this concept work I had to pick out winners so I could offer personalised advices. That said, I do intend to open source all our learnings at some point and you'll benefit from transparency reports from the team.

      1. 2

        will sure do that @Vinrob

        still thanks!

  18. -3

    This comment has been voted down. Click to show.