8
3 Comments

How much risk am I putting myself in by using designs coming into the public domain?

I want to use the Rider-Waite tarot deck designs in some of my own products that I would be selling. If you scroll down to the "Copyright status" section you'll see what I'm worried about. The designs were made in 1909, and should fall into the public domain. However, the company U.S. Games Systems is trying to claim they actaully own the copyright until 2021, claiming 70 years after the authors death even though that should not apply. Here is another article on the subject.

It sounds to me like the company may just be potentially overly litigious to protect their golden goose. I'm curious if someone more seasoned than me could explain if there is actually a lot of risk here. Is it likely that a company could try to take me to court for using their clearly outdated copyright? Would they have a leg to stand on? Would it be worth just waiting until 2021? I'm just trying to get my ducks in a row before making any potentially risky moves.

  1. 1

    It is a mess. I assume that the deck is in public domain already (I assume, but I don't know for sure - we need a court decision for that), but I would wait until 2021.
    Let's say that you are right and that the deck is in the public domain. However, the "copyright holder" in this case take you to court. They may get an order to take your products out of the market during the trial, will incur lawyer fees on your side, and will cause you tons of stress.
    They are big and it is not fair. But, with 2021 just behond the corner, why not wait a little bit?

    1. 1

      That was basically my thoughts. Might as well just wait. Even if they know they wouldn’t win they could still just sue for the sake of it and I couldn’t beat them with time or money so they could win like that. Although I guess they could still try that after 2021? But then I’d have even more on my side.

      1. 1

        "they could still just sue for the sake of it and I couldn’t beat them with time or money so they could win like that"

        This is what I think they do. I would just wait and follow what they do in public about the deck.

Trending on Indie Hackers
💯 users 💯 days 26 comments Can you give me some feedback? 12 comments Launch went well. Traffic is falling. Now what? 10 comments How I made $10k teaching vim online in one month 9 comments How to fight back against Google FLoC 6 comments Building in Public for the first time!😲 2 comments