I recently subscribed to the newsletter and their messaging is one of a kind.
The messaging is around the secret theme. It is consistent across all the touch points from the landing page to the welcome email.
Here is a breakdown of how they do it:
If you are running a newsletter and want to improve your landing page experience. Good news, each week I help 5 creators improve their landing pages for free at LandingPagesFeedback. The door is open for you.