Ideas and Validation November 9, 2020

I will review for Free your MVP with a first-impression video

Marco Gurnari @MarcoGurnari

Hi Indie Hackers,
I am Marco, an Italian Growth Hacker with a great passion for MVPs. I am also the author of StartupMate, one of the most appreciated directories of tools to make and improve MVPs 💪

In the last weeks, I've enjoyed this community and now it is time to give something back.
For this reason, I've decided to give you suggestions and feedback to improve your MVP or create one if you have not it yet... totally for Free 😉

How to receive your Free Feedback?

  1. Insert the link and the idea into this Typeform
  2. Comment this post with the name of your Startup, MVP, site or something related to what you submitted in the form
  3. Optional You could upvote this post to rank it higher and allow me to help more indie hackers and follow me on my Twitter @MarcoGurnari

First Edit: I am receiving many requests than you could wait a little bit for your video feedback 😊

  1. 3 - Collaborate with marketers and affiliates to grow your business


  2. 3

    Thank you very much! Have a good day.

    Video Market provides affordable and competitive video content for small businesses - (landing page) and (product itself)

    1. 1

      Check your email man, your review is ready 🔥

      1. 1

        Thank you very much, it's really helpful!

    2. 1

      You are the first comment and I will come back to you with the free video review in a couple of hours 😉

    1. 2

      Hi man, sorry for the replay... Podcast Ping seems an amazing product and this is my honest review

      1. 1

        Thanks for the feedback, great advice.

        Just finished the MVP, so no real users yet, but will definitely add the testimonials and usage stats as soon as I can.

  3. 2 — I hope you'll switch from Typeform to Formito next time after your review ;)

    1. 1

      Hi Hossein, Formito is really cool and finally, there is a good competitor to Landbot in the Market. Anyway, your review is completed and you can check it in your inbox 🔥

      1. 1

        Thank you so much. I noted a few of your suggestions to apply for the next iteration.

        P.S. I thought you'll review the product, not the landing page as you mentioned you'll review MVP. Maybe my bad, I should have linked to the app at instead of my landing page.

  4. 1 - Airbnb + Tripadvisor for marina booking (boat parking)

  5. 1

    Https:// - GoogleTrends on steroids, include demographics

  6. 1

    Hi Marco, thanks for doing this, I submitted - find and compare the best providers for your VMs, DBs and Saas services for your company.

  7. 1

    Thanks for doing this! Just submitted 🙂

  8. 1 - Curated learning resources from internet around Tech, Programming, Startups and Productivity


  9. 1

    Marco, thank you so much! It would be great to get your feedback on - it's a platform to connect with others to read books on personal growth, finance,and philosophy together.

  10. 1

    This is a bit late. But submitted the form for Yournote. Hope to see some feedback. Thank you!

  11. 1

    We make painting projects as simple as shopping online. MVP not ready, looking for feedback on our static designs (in Figma) before we start dev.

  12. 1

    Hi, I submit a request to VisitMind

  13. 1

    Newny is a Q&A platform to help event organisers get better Q&A engagement and to help them learn from and about their most engaged participants.

    Looking forward to it Marco!

  14. 1


    I have filled out the form -

    Thank you

  15. 1 Express yourself in another language

    Polygloss is an image guessing game where you can write creatively and expand your active vocabulary. Unlike most solutions out there who focus on beginners, Polygloss is ideal for intermediate speakers stuck on the "I can understand but can't communicate" phase. The Android game has been played in 40+ languages and I'm now preparing to launch the beta for iOS and starting to think on how to monetize it.

    Submitted the form too, thanks 😊

    1. 1

      Sorry, I can't test mobile apps , but it seems a cool idea 😊

  16. 1

    Launched my new tool 5 minutes ago. This is the first time posting about it. Submitted the TypeForm... hit me up if you want access to the paid product portion and I'll get you access. Thanks Marco!

  17. 1 a local review platform that helps smb owners with their online reputation.

  18. 1

    I made The Beaver App, a mobile-first productivity system for iOS. Check it out!

    1. 1

      Sorry I can't test iOS apps

  19. 1 - Dœsign, an all-in-one design tool directory for UX/UI/graphic designers to find the suite of tools that best meet your needs and budget, in just a few seconds.

    Submitted my project. Thank you so much for doing this @MarcoGurnari! Looking forward to hearing your suggestions on Doesign.

    Looking for design product/service. If you are a founder or a team member of a product/service for UX/UI/graphic designers, please complete this Form - Click Here and your product will be automatically added to Dœsign's database. Thanks for reading.

    1. 2

      Hi "Musa", cool project and this is my video review

      1. 1

        Thank you for sharing your suggestions with me, Marco!

  20. 1 - Track your stocks portfolio performance

    1. 1

      Hi man, I can't do a full video because your landing page contains little information. Some suggestions to improve it:

      • Improve the subheadline
      • Add something near the button, like "no credit card required"
      • Add a section describing the most relevant features
      • Add testimonial with some number about how much money your users are doing in this moment
      1. 1

        Thanks a lot for the suggestions !

  21. 1 - No code solution to build interactive charts and export it on your website

    1. 1

      Compliments for the project man, but I think you have a developer approach and in these cases you should use probably a more marketer side. Just try to create a classic landing page remembering that your goal is not allowing the people to use your tool, but to have them in your mailing list to sell them something in the future 😉

  22. 1 - Compare versions of engineering documentation with ease - 2D/3D


      1. 1

        Thank you Marco! I have to say I was expecting less useful information, but your insights were pretty spot on! Thanks for taking the time!!
        (btw.: the play button is behaving badly, but it should be playing a gif :) )

    1. 1

      FYI your page's <title> says ChadCheck

      1. 1

        Thanks for noticing, will fix it asap!

    1. 2

      I randomly picked yours here from the list because of the name. My first impression, what is it? It looks like
      I couldn't find any explanation, something that tells me what the site is about.

      1. 1

        Thanks, I should add something about it.
        BTW. the name catch your attention? :) What do you think about this domain?

        1. 2

          First came to mind I can get some kind of goodie
          And it seems to be a site where there is a big bunch of goodies because it's called
          goodilla which is godzilla + goodie

          what was your idea for the name?

          1. 1

            Idea was good+godzilla=good monster (in logo)

  23. 1

    Https:// - Add a CTA overlay to every link you share.

    Submitted the form. Thanks buddy!

    1. 2

      An amazing Idea man, I will definitely use it in the future.. This is my review

      1. 1

        Thanks for taking the time and recording a review! Much appreciated.
        I agree with most of the points you mentioned.

    1. 1

      Hi andrew, compliments for your service: it's really interesting. This is my review..Loom allows me only 5 mins videos but I think that they are enought

      1. 1

        @MarcoGurnari Thank you so much for your thoughtful breakdown! I agreed with nearly all of your suggestions and know what I'm working on today :)

  24. 1

    I just submitted Flowoid and followed you on Twitter. Thank you very much for doing this.

    1. 2

      Thanks for following me ... This is my

      1. 1

        Thank you very much for the awesome review.

    1. 1

      Hi man, I would definitely suggest inserting more information about your product before asking for the location of the users. Try to make a "full landing page", because many people will not give you their permission otherwise.
      I don't provide the video in this case because there are not info at all in the landing page :)

  25. 1

    Hey! Would appreciate a review of (signup via https://get Let me know if there is anything I can do in return! Cheers

    1. 1

      Hi Harry, the landing page design looks amazing. I can not test the product inside, but I think that you can improve something considering my video review

      1. 1

        Thanks so much that’s super helpful!

  26. 1

    Awesome initiative! I've submitted the request for and upvoted so you get a little bit more exposure with this awesome idea 👍🏻

    1. 1

      Interesting tool...This is my review for the landing page

  27. 1

    Thanks man! Waiting to see what you think about Listnr


    1. 2

      Hi man, compliments for your product. This is the loom video with all the suggestions!

  28. 1

    Hi, this is great ...checkout warned It requires google or facebook email / password signup/sigin...

    1. 1

      Sorry man I can not signup to all the sites required than I can not review your entire product. Anyway, I would suggest you these three things:

      • Insert at least one testimonial
      • Use a widget like Trust to add a popup to increase your Social Proof
      • Use bold for the words "Start your page" and "Share your link" in the 2 step list to make it easier to read
      1. 1

        trust widget do you mean trustbox...
        this is great feedback ....and you didn't even use the site...

        Thank you

  29. 1

    I have filled in the form for
    Thanks in advance.

    1. 1

      Hi man, here you can find all my feedbacks for Woodoo

    1. 1

      Hi man, your product seems a great idea, but if I should add all the feedbacks in a video, it will be too long. I suggest you re-make your entire landing page, using some template in order to be sure to have a great design.
      Obviously, it is only my point of view and you are free to accept or not. Good luck with woodoo ;)

    2. 1

      This comment was deleted 3 months ago.

  30. 1

    Hi Marco,

    Thanks for doing this! I would really appreciate a review and feedback of NullBox

    Thanks in advance!

    1. 1

      Hi Chris, this is my honest review about Nullbox

  31. 1 - Thanks man, appreciate it!

    1. 1

      Hi Man, compliments for your product, it seems very cool.. This is the video with my feedbacks

      1. 1

        Hey Marco,
        Thanks a lot for your video and time, I appreciate it a lot.
        Loved your feedback and I agree, I should definitely work on social proof and do some AB testing for the headlines.

  32. 1 - taking as much feedback as possible, after I've soft-launched 2 days ago. Thanks a lot for the effort Marco!

    1. 1

      Hi eyk, compliments for your project. It is so cool and it would be a pleasure being one of your early users... On the while I've completed your review, just check your inbox 🔥

      1. 1

        Thanks for the great feedback and the time you took for me! I definitely enjoyed the video & I actually have nothing to criticise about it. The criticism you have given me is very reasonable and clear. I will fix these issues soon.

        It would be very cool to have you among my first users :) I will notify you when the early access phase has started!

    1. 1

      Hi Karan,
      your review is completed. Check your inbox 🔥

    1. 2

      Hi Jordan, I will send you the review in a couple of hours 😉

  33. 1

    This comment was deleted 2 months ago.

  34. 1

    This comment was deleted 4 months ago.

Recommended Posts