24
16 Comments

Is the Indie Hackers Newsletter perfect yet? If not, help me change that.

tl;dr: I'm trying to turn the Indie Hackers Newsletter into the best free resource for early-stage founders. And I need your help.

The newsletter is now one of our top priorities. So I'm pivoting it into a more "mature" publication aimed at delivering a lot of valuable news and advice regardless of your stage of entrepreneurship. (Check out my latest Featured Posts to see what I'm talking about.)

Help me out? I'd love answers to any of the following questions:

  • What do you dislike about the current newsletter?
  • Is it actionably helpful? If not, what kind of information would be valuable to you?
  • What other newsletters, if any, are you subscribed to? Why? (Especially curious to hear answers from people who aren't subscribed to the IH Newsletter.)
  • If you're a subscriber: Do you tend to read the emails all the way through? Put another way: do you enjoy reading them?
  1. 6

    What do you dislike about the current newsletter?. In the summary near the beginning of an issue, it's not clear which items are covered in some depth and which are just links to stories elsewhere.

    This is a minor issue though, not a reason for disliking the newsletter. Which I don't have.

    Is it actionably helpful? If not, what kind of information would be actionably valuable to you?. For someone starting out completely from scratch, the advice given seems unreachable, unrelatable, and not applicable because it refers to wildly successful creators, outliers. I'd appreciate more coverage of underdogs.

    What other newsletters, if any, are you subscribed to? Why?
    See the list of the newsletters I subscribe to. What they have in common is they have some practical, actionable, geeky value. I avoid the newsletters that are more philosophical or cover vague or abstract stuff.

    If you're a subscriber: Do you tend to read the emails all the way through?
    Yes, I always read it all the way through, as all the newsletters I subscribe to. If I'm not sure I can do that, I don't subscribe to a newsletter.

    1. 2

      hot damn. thanks.

      For someone starting out completely from scratch, the advice given seems unreachable, unrelatable, and not applicable because it refers to wildly successful creators, outliers. I'd appreciate more coverage of underdogs.

      great points! noted. outside of success stories, do you find either of the following formats useful as someone just getting started?

      • market trend writeups (e.g. forecasts of products or industries that are gaining in popularity)
      • business or product idea writeups
      1. 2

        Yes, I find both formats useful for creators who are just getting started, especially the product idea writeups. Here's an example of a product idea resource I find useful.

  2. 4

    I just wanted to drop in and mention that I've really enjoyed the new format recently. It's one of the few newsletters I get that I actually full read through.

    So definitely don't change it too much!

  3. 2

    Is it actionably helpful?

    I'm trying to get my first ~100 users for my app. I want to see more about failures (or things people decided not to do after testing hypothesis).

    1. 1

      good to know — most readers are probably in a similar position. thanks for the feedback. 👍

  4. 2

    The thing that really strikes me about the IH newsletter is that it's very "inside baseball" for the indiehackers.com community. You need to know quite a lot before you can really understand everything in the newsletter. I think that's fine for a community newsletter, but if it's going to be a more mature resource, it's worth considering what level of familiarity you want the reader to have.

    6 months ago, I would not have known the following from the newsletter if someone forwarded me this:

    • Who "Courtland" is, and what insight he might have about Y Combinator. Although further down, you do hint that he has something to do with a podcast, but it's not clear whether he runs the podcast was a guest
    • Who "Pieter Levels" is, and why a new PHP release has anything to do with him
    • Who "Sam Parr" is, and why it might be useful to see how he does marketing
    • What "Css Scan" is and why it's interesting that it has a new release. TBH, I still don't know... anything not self-contained in the newsletter isn't something I read

    In comparison, I don't know who Harry Dry is, but you called him a marketing expert, so that was enough to just accept the advice on its face

    1. 2

      The thing that really strikes me about the IH newsletter is that it's very "inside baseball" for the indiehackers.com community. You need to know quite a lot before you can really understand everything in the newsletter.

      totally. plan is to reduce the curse of knowledge as i incorporate a referral program and promote the newsletter a bit more widely.

  5. 2

    Basically i don't sub or read newsletters (since i don't use email much).
    So my suggestion would be to post pieces of content, that normall goes to newsletter, somewhere on IH.
    I don't know if news will go to newsletter by You only (or will be there other authors)
    so having all posts in one place would be great.

  6. 1

    What do you dislike about the current newsletter?

    I am totally OK with the current newsletter but I would like to see more news that you see and think that are important

    Is it actionably helpful? If not, what kind of information would be valuable to you?
    Seeing more news would make the newsletter way more valuable for me

    What other newsletters, if any, are you subscribed to? Why? (Especially curious to hear answers from people who aren't subscribed to the IH Newsletter.)
    I am subscribed to the IH newsletter and I am also subscribed to other tech newsletters like tldr

    If you're a subscriber: Do you tend to read the emails all the way through? Put another way: do you enjoy reading them?
    Yes I read the entire email and I also enjoy reading them

    Also I want to ask you something too Allen, where can I contact you?

    1. 1

      hm, it works for me. how's it broken on your end?

      1. 1

        "Everything you need to know as an indie hacker, 100% free. Enter your email address below."

        It's a box with that in it
        And nothing else

        If I could add an image to this comment, I would show you

        1. 1

          It seems to be an issue on Firefox or my Firefox to be specific.
          I tried it on Edge and it works.

          1. 1

            ah, good to know. thanks.

  7. 2

    This comment was deleted 3 years ago.

Trending on Indie Hackers
I talked to 8 SaaS founders, these are the most common SaaS tools they use 20 comments What are your cold outreach conversion rates? Top 3 Metrics And Benchmarks To Track 19 comments How I Sourced 60% of Customers From Linkedin, Organically 13 comments Hero Section Copywriting Framework that Converts 3x 12 comments Promptzone - first-of-its-kind social media platform dedicated to all things AI. 8 comments How to create a rating system with Tailwind CSS and Alpinejs 7 comments