4
5 Comments

Why did I get rejected...

I, like of 1000's of entrepreneurs like me, applied to YC earlier this year. And like 1000's of others, got the unfortunate message, that I was not accepted into the program. And looking back, my application and venture, was not ready for YC. But why? And will we ever be?

I think (or I hope) that I am not the only one, who is left with an empty feeling. Was it because of the answers we gave in the application? Was it the team? The idea? Did we not show our potential well enough?

The following are my thoughts on why we were rejected, and a few concerns which still slumber in the back of my mind:
I believe that 3 main issues caused our application to be firmly placed in the rejected pile. I do not believe that it was a close call.

The number 1 reason: Team.
Originally, I had the idea for my startup 5 years ago, and since then I have moved continent, started a family, gotten jobs, left jobs, and struggled to launch my startup. I guess, one of the side-effects of moving country is your network goes from level 80, to level 0. I tried some cofounder dating, and actually found a great CTO to join me, but after 2 months of working together, he was asked to become the new Vice Minister of Technology for the country, and therefore had to quit the startup. Thereafter, I "convince" a technical and strategic partner to join my company, even though we lived 7 timezones apart, we believed that we could manage (spoiler alert, we couldn't). The project was not moving ahead at the pace we wanted it. And finally, my new CTO quit, after being offered a senior position at AWS. Alone again... I am now working with a former co-worker, and friend, but he has been clear from the beginning, that is not interested in the CTO position. He wishes to continue his employment for the coming 5 years or so. In the same period, I found a CMO to join the team, but that didn't work out either, as I felt he was not invested in the project.

The second reason: Traction.
As you may understand from the above timeline, we have not yet launched. Or, we have launched something, but we didn't validate what we should have validated. In other words, we have no traction that shows 1) that we can grow a business, or 2) that our hypothesis is correct about the users and market.

The final nail in the coffin: Timing.
Our venture is in Travel Tech, which is not the most promising industry to be in 2020. We believe that this represents an opportunity, but others may disagree. And I believe, from the viewpoint of YC, that with 2 red flags already identified, the 3rd one can only be identified as a negative too.

Now I ask myself, as a serial failed entrepreneur, with some OK experiences under his belt, and a serious imposter complex: "Will I ever be accepted?" Should I perhaps hang up the hat and try with another project? Or try to correct the above errs and try again? I can fix the 2 issue, and I am trying to fix that now. But I doubt I can fix the 1st, and biggest issue. Should I then just hope that me, and my passion will shine through? Or should I apply with another startup? Another idea, which I might be less passionate about, but that might have a bigger chance, because of Team, Traction and Timing?
And I continue thinking: "Does it even matter if I ever get accepted into YC?" Should it matter? Is it the recognition I am looking for? The applause? The validation? Or perhaps it is a Napoleon complex which is driving me towards YC...
Anyways, I am left with mildly damaged self-esteem, but I'll continue doing the only thing I think I can do at this time, keep moving forward...

Thank you for reading, any feedback will be appreciated

  1. 1

    It takes great courage to actually stand up and acknowledge such a situation @MKBSP. I appreciate the candid way of you accepting that the startup was just not ready at that point.

    From I have learnt while building ruttl, I can tell you that there will always be different ups and downs in the journey. But that's what entrepreneurship entails. It is always way harder than people glorify it but more than the success, it's about a way of life.

    Your journey in the post was quite interesting to read. Just shrug off the feeling by going out or hanging out with your close ones. I am sure great things are on your way so just keep hustling the way you have been! (99% of the people fail at it. If you've reached till here, you are among the 1%, so pat yourself on that achievement haha!)

    Cheers!

    1. 1

      your signup page is amazing. Did you make the video yourself?

      1. 1

        Thank you so much @mikal_cookie!

        Haha, yes created the video along with the design team in my agency, Brucira.

    2. 1

      THANKS! Gotta keep the hustle going!

Trending on Indie Hackers
After 10M+ Views, 13k+ Upvotes: The Reddit Strategy That Worked for Me! 42 comments Getting first 908 Paid Signups by Spending $353 ONLY. 24 comments 🔥Roast my one-man design agency website 21 comments I talked to 8 SaaS founders, these are the most common SaaS tools they use 19 comments What are your cold outreach conversion rates? Top 3 Metrics And Benchmarks To Track 19 comments Hero Section Copywriting Framework that Converts 3x 12 comments