November 15, 2019

#8 on Product Hunt + 222 new Subscribers


On Wednesday this week I launched on Product Hunt, reaching #8 and gaining 222 new email subscribers.

This is a deep dive analysis of what happened......


I finished building the MVP on 27 October 2019 and did about as much QA as I could. But eventually you can’t see the forest for the trees so had to open up to a handful of alpha testers.

I had well over 100 early subscribers on my invite list, so thinking the most recent to sign up would be the most eager, I invited 10 people. Then I got carried away and invited another 10.

That’s when I received multiple emails saying that users couldn’t log in. This is why we do alpha testing. It turned out that the mailchimp list I had used to invite early subscribers, was the same list I had used to integrate with my membership software, so although the users were on the list, they couldn’t confirm their account.

So top tip if you’re launching. Use a different mailchimp list for early subscribers, to the one integrated with your membership software.


I was reasonably confident that I’d resolved the on-boarding issue, so I sent an email to the remaining subscribers on my list, to access the site to help with beta testing.

Unfortunately I’m an idiot, and had not checked the on-boarding issue had been completely resolved, so I started getting more emails saying people couldn’t get in.

That’s pretty embarrassing. So I decided, rather than firefight dozens and dozens of individual emails, I sent an immediate “I screwed up” email with a solution. With everything running smoothly, it was ready to launch on Product Hunt.


Here is a breakdown of my launch day:

(The PH post was set up in advance, scheduled to go live at 9am UK time, which is 0100 PST)

0615 - Woke up and checked the website and the PH draft post. Reviewed the products that had ended at the top of the list the previous day.

0630 - Decided I needed to reword the tagline, to include the word "free" to catch peoples attention.

0645 - Made a few changes to the PH post wording, and checked the website again.

0700 - Normal morning routine (Breakfast, few errands, walk).

0825 - Started work and cleared inbox. Checked PH and saw a dozen posts that had already launched. I still had 35 mins until mine was scheduled. I saw the most popular item had 14 up votes so far, and I became worried that those posts would get an early advantage lead, so decided to push my post live immediately.

0826 - Pushed live, and posted a tweet from my personal account, which I then retweeted with the helloremote twitter account.

0827 - Took a screenshot of the original tweet and posted it to my ~800 followers on Instagram

0828 - Checked PH to see if I could see my post. Nothing yet.

0830 - And again. Still nothing.

0832 - It's live with one upvote (an automated upvote from me). Checked it again a few more times, to see if it appears in the main feed. Pretty much do this constantly for the next 20 mins.

0852 - Just realised I'm up against Facebook pay. They're on 22 votes already. I'm on 1 vote, which is mine.

0859 - Tried to upvote my post anonymously to get it off the 1 vote mark. Didn't work, you need an account. Just seen the top post is now for an app that counts calories just by taking a picture of the food.

0904 - Remind myself that this is going to last for another 23 hours, so I just need to settle into the day, and treat it like normal. Whatever happens, happens. Tomorrow is day 1 of the next phase.... growth.

0926 - Checked progress again. Still no upvotes.

1043 - Checked again and I've still had no upvotes. Starting to think about ways to promote this, so I at least get on the radar later in the day. I need to re-read the PH best practices around promotion.

1137 - I checked again and saw that I had 6 upvotes, so it's starting to kick in. I noticed that another image had been added to the post, of my homepage, which I most definitely did not add to the post. I think the helpful folks at PH reviewed my images and optimised them for me, which is really nice.

1146 - Got a twitter DM from somebody who didn't receive their double opt in confirmation email. FFS here we go again.

1149 - Got a follow up DM from the same person saying it just took a few minutes to come through, into the spam folder. I suspect this is the same issue I had before, and the autoresponder is the email the user is getting. But the person did say they were really excited to get started. Do I need to tweak my on boarding process, to help deliver value quicker?

1207 - PH give you a dashboard that gives you an overview of your launch which is really interesting. Currently 17th position with 8 votes with 19 hours and 51 mins to go.

1315 - Currently 16th position with 16 votes. USA is just waking up now.

1447 - Currently 13th position with 32 votes. 17 hours left to go.

1534 - Currently 10th position with 53 votes. 16 hours left to go. Apple have just announced the new macbook 16" laptop, which has gone straight to #3.

1730 - Currently 9th position with 90 votes. Basecamp has released a free service for freelancers and it's gone straight to #1. Github has released a mobile tool, and that's gone to #2.

1854 - Currently 8th position with 114 votes. Could I get in the top 5?

2118 - Currently 6th position with 170 votes. Start getting tweets and emails from people saying what a great idea it is.

2313 - Currently 7th position with 187 votes. Going to bed.

0700 - I ended up at 8th position for the day, with a total of 312 upvotes and an additional 222 users signed up for HelloRemote.


PH encourages you to post a tweet to your PH post on launch day. If you have a large, engaged following on twitter, this can have a massive impact on the number of upvotes you get. Getting near the top of the list early, creates a fly wheel effect, as more people see you.

Loading comments...
Today's Top Milestones
  • $40k ARR: Optimizations as a company of one
    Sharing another financial milestone with Lunch Money paired with a blog post! This time I've written about my optimizations as a company of one which
  • First profitable month!
    When I posted my last update in the beginning of May, I had just gotten my first monthly subscriber and netted around $500 in one–time sales. I’m happ
  • Added IG & Pinterest to free image generation API
    ...after my first paying customer requested it. use the OG IMPACT API to generate Open Graph images for each user's profile page,
  • We launched a new direction of our service
    Hi everybody! Today we've launched the English version of our new direction: The Fastest Website Builder It's the pursuit of o
  • Jott is in private beta!
    A while ago I came across a tweet where someone explained their note-taking system. Super simple - take notes in Notepad & save them dropbox. It looke
  • This is not going as well as I hoped
    It's 7 days from launching a new website and I haven't worked on it at all. Okay that's a lie. It's all planned out. I've put it hours of sketching an
  • First Referral
    We started offering a significant discount ($75) for referrals (for kids taking our live online LEGO engineering classes (
  • An Episode Gets 200 Downloads
    For the first time an episode gets 200 downloads. The episode is Dogs and Web Development. The episode came out in April of 2019. The episode is testi
  • An Episode Gets 200 Downloads
    For the first time an episode gets 200 downloads. The episode is Dogs and Web Development. The episode came out in April of 2019. The episode is testi
  • First Issue sent!
    We sent our first issue to around 70 subscribers! The first issue was on a painting by Vincent van Gogh. The goal here is to start to get feedback on