October 1, 2020

We've reached $100 MRR

Ashley Rich @A5hleyRich

Over 18 months ago, I launched ReplyBox, and we've finally reached $100 MRR. It's been a long journey, so it's time for a breakdown as to what held us back for so long.

🏃‍♂️ It's a marathon, not a sprint. You haven't reached the finish line once you launch a product. In reality, the race is just beginning.

I spent 6-8 weeks building the first version of ReplyBox. During that time, I spent countless hours in the evenings and on weekends to push out the MVP. I was burning the candle at both ends. But as soon as I launched, I did very little on the product, and there were months where I did nothing to push ReplyBox forward. I had burned myself out. Take breaks, stay healthy, and enjoy the process. Otherwise, you'll begin to resent the product and time you spend working on it.

🛠 Don't over-optimize too early.

Most of us have done it. We visualize our product launch, akin to opening the flood gates. Droves of customers will come rushing through the doors and throw wads of cash at us. Therefore, we have to be ready. We have to have the infrastructure in place to deal with the masses of customers, which means servers—lots of them. Don't do it! Scale when you need to scale to keep costs down.

Likewise, don't try to automate everything from the get-go. It's OK to handle repetitive, menial tasks manually. For example, we still manually email ReplyBox users about monthly overages. Eventually, we'll automate the process but not until it becomes a time sink.

💵 Freemium is hard.

The biggest mistake I made with ReplyBox was to give too much functionality away for free. But deciding what features should be premium, especially in the early days, can be difficult. By definition, an MVP is going to be light on features. Therefore, you're unlikely to have much of an incentive for users to become paying customers unless you severely restrict the free plan. In hindsight, ReplyBox should have been paid-only from day one because we didn't have enough premium-only features.

ReplyBox followed the freemium model for 16 months. We had 1.1k users, but only 2 paying customers. We dropped the free plan two months ago, and we're now at 10 paying customers. We did this without improving the product whatsoever. We may revisit the freemium model in the future, but our MRR will have to look really healthy before we go down that route again.

Thanks to everyone on IH for sharing their stories. Reading them has been a huge inspiration and helped push ReplyBox forward to become a profitable product. We have many new features in the pipeline, and we're excited to see where we can take ReplyBox.

  1. 1

    Love the demo. Not sure though, why don't you add 'reply' buttons for each comment, so when users press it, they get redirected to a 'log in to reply' screen? Same thing for a 'like' button.

    I've seen many founders struggle with the 'freemium' thing, and they all seem to come to the same conclusion. Start with premium later on in order to get better validation.

    Keep up the good work!

    1. 1

      Thanks @zerotousers! That's a really great point. It's funny because we just fixed an issue yesterday where the spacing felt wierd for guest users when the "reply" button is hidden. Your suggested approach seems much more logical in highsight.

Today's Top Milestones
  • Hit $6K MRR and got featured in TechCrunch
    Plausible Analytics just hit $6,050 MRR from 974 paying subscribers! Thank you all for your trust and support! We also got a nice surprise: a mention
  • $1K ARR
    This week Siteoly reached $1K ARR https://siteoly.com - The fastest way to build websites from Google sheets. I know its only ARR but not MRR but it's
  • 25 People Signed Up!
    Actually, it's over 30 now, but 25 was the milestone for me. A quarter of a hundred people! So I posted the project to Hacker News yesterday and even
  • Donated 50 trees
    I've reached the milestone of donating 50 trees from my Gumroad earnings of my E-book Start With A Side-Project, each tree was gifted to a buyer, so t
  • Trending #1 on ProductHunt
    https://www.producthunt.com/posts/icebreakers-by-kaapi How did we accomplish this? Not really sure? I guess this is one of those times when the hard w
  • Milestone: Helped 20.000 visitors ❤️
    Boei has helped more than 20.000 visitors, which I think is awesome! The product is aimed to get more and better conversations with customers so it is
  • Added video chatting into our mobile app.
    I had an awful time with Sinch customer service and had to email everyone in their entire company including C-level guys with my fancy marketing tools
  • Launched MVP
    Built a UI experience plus backend on Heroku at https://flowhook.herokuapp.com which is now free to use, launched a Grafana community plugin PR. Opene
  • Added demo on landing page
    Recently I was thinking that it's kind of a bummer that you have to register to get a first view of your timeline. This is why I added, right on the l
  • Preparing to shut down the product
    I learnt that Trainer's Joy solves a problem that seems to be too rare. A trainer will not redesign their trainings often enough that this product wil