1
2 Comments

Ask IH: Writing a better version of Discourse forum engine. Worth it? 🤔

Hi to all indie hackers and entrepreneurs!

I'm developing my project called Confab. It's a better version of the Discourse community forum engine. Here's how it looks with the default theme: http://imgur.com/a/cgCxp

There is a lot of preparation involved so my friend suggested I should ask people about the project before spending too much time to a product nobody wants.

  1. The design is highly influenced by https://inbound.org/top - I think it's more suitable for a community and easily readable than a default Discourse theme. Just check out the link above to see how Inbound community looks like and feels like.

  2. Support several types of content: Questions, Articles, Links.

  3. Super simple and fast navigation with sidebar and categorization with channels and subchannels.

  4. Posts with cover images and color labels to visually distinguish content.

  5. Standalone version: highly efficient with server-side rendering which is perfect for search engines.
    Written in JS (node.js, React) and Golang for API. Only 2 commands to start without any configuration files because everything is automatic: database migrations, upgrades, etc.
    It only requires minimal VPS like DigitalOceans' $5 node for a start.

  6. Hosted solution with custom domains and free data migrations from any forum and community engines. Free for small communities.

  7. Potentially: all features of Discourse.

Is it worth to continue developing it? I'd like to hear your thoughts.

  1. 1

    Indie Hackers forum could use a ton of upgrades. Courtland + Channing have a long To-Do list, but I'm sure they'd much rather buy an off-the-shelf product that integrated properly with their branding and supported all the features they want.

    Talk to them.

  2. 1

    I'd say that if the main benefit of your alternative to Discourse is a better UX/UI, then you should verify that there is a significant number of folks that feel the same way as you do. Discourse has already beaten you in terms of "getting there first," so think of it in terms of what might compel an existing Discourse customer to switch.

    FWIW I agree that the Discourse UI is confusing.