44
19 Comments

Growing to $5k/mo by Filling a Technology Gap in the Fitness Industry

Hello! What's your background, and what are you working on?

I'm Eran Galperin, a software developer and tech entrepreneur. I've been developing web applications for over 14 years now. I started working in the industry while studying for physics degree back in 2004.

During college I co-founded a web development shop that focused on SaaS development. After accumulating experience and some capital, one of my co-founders and I started Binpress, a marketplace for open-source code. During our time with Binpress, we went through the 500Startups accelerator program and raised an institutional seed round.

We ended up selling our company at the end of 2015, mainly to pay back investors (read a full post-mortem here). Following that, I started Martial Arts on Rails, which provides online management to gyms and martial arts schools. It's now generating almost $5k in monthly recurring revenue.

Home page

What motivated you to get started with Martial Arts on Rails?

I've been training in Brazilian Jiu-Jitsu for close to a decade. After selling my previous company, I was looking for ideas for my next project and I knew that I wanted to combine my passion for Jiu-Jitsu with my SaaS expertise.

I started interviewing the people who manage the gyms I trained in, and identified a pain point with the software they use — it's generally bloated and outdated and feels like Windows 3.1 software. With my background in software development and user-experience design, I figured I could do much better and began working on an early prototype. To get more data points, I also tried asking on reddit — and overall the response was positive, though some people thought I was getting in over my head.

Start a business in a market you're deeply familiar with to increase your chances of success.

I had a lot of experience building SaaS products, so I knew that I could get something up and running by myself in the timeframe of a couple of months. I had a designer friend come up with the basic concept and style, and took it from there to create all of the flows in the app. During development, I kept showing my work-in-progress to gym managers in the area to make sure I was on the right path.

During this time I wasn't working or generating other income, just living frugally off of savings. I didn't have much of a budget for advertising or marketing, so I was doing everything myself. The goal was to bootstrap this project into profitability without taking outside money.

What went into building the initial product?

The whole development process from concept to launch was about three months. During that time, I had weekly meetings with different gym managers to go over the software they were currently using and discuss their pain points. I would then go back and start brainstorming how to address these pain points, and build my ideas into the prototype. When it launched in February 2016, it had all the basic features I had in mind from discussions with gym managers, though the product I have today has evolved significantly.

Despite the name, MAonRails is actually built on a LEMP stack (Linux, Nginx, MySQL, PHP), and not Ruby on Rails. The backend is built on a heavily extended Zend Framework installation that I built over many years through doing other projects. The front end uses basic web technologies with a heavy dose of jQuery. All the flows are fully optimized for mobile and tablets.

How have you attracted users and grown Martial Arts on Rails?

Since I didn't have a major budget for marketing, my focus was initially on the organic and social channels. I tried generating some press for the launch but it was difficult. I did get it featured on Product Hunt, though it wasn't exactly the target audience.

I created content targeted for gym managers on the company blog, focusing on the digital aspects of running a gym — how to run marketing, do local SEO for gyms, generate funnels to attract gym members, running referral programs and so forth. I contacted many online publications in the fitness and martial arts verticals, and did some guest blogging to generate traffic and links back to my site.

At the same time, I ran a very active Twitter account that was sharing general fitness and martial-arts related content. To gain awareness of the account, I used a Twitter automation tool that is no longer available due to changes to the Twitter API. I was also very active on several subreddits where many gym owners and managers participate (specifically /r/bjj), and did a soft sell here and there without being too aggressive. I had been a longtime part of the community so I knew the right way to approach it without upsetting people. Now whenever someone posts there about gym management software, people usually refer them my way.

Blog

I contacted all the gym owners I'd been working with to develop the initial software and got them to try it out as an actual replacement to what they had. Those were my first real customers. It's a very tight community, so over time they referred others my way. Surprisingly, merchant account sellers have also been a source of referrals. After connecting with one through one of my customers, we started a cross-referral collaboration, and they referred quite a few new customers my way over time.

I tried AdWords for a little while with a small budget, but couldn't get good results there since it requires deep knowledge of competitive keywords. After a couple of months I started running ads on Capterra, a search engine for business software, where I am now ranked first in searches for "martial arts gym software". This has become my strongest source for conversions. I was initially spending around $180 a month on Capterra, and it's now closer to $400 a month. Currently, Capterra and organic search results are the main acquisitions sources for my business.

Month Customers
Jan '16 10
Jun '16 70
Oct '16 194
Feb '17 293
Jun '17 393
Oct '17 504
Feb '18 643

What's your business model, and how have you grown your revenue?

The service is a freemium subscription based SaaS. Paying users are either charged on a monthly basis at one of five different pricing plans, or on custom plans. I provide a 30-day free trial with all the features included, after which it is downgraded to a limited free version if the account is not upgraded.

One of the main things that helped with growth was setting up an online chat on the site (I use Olark). By talking to potential customers on a daily basis, I was able to learn a lot about what is needed to get them on board. I also set up an email drip campaign for new sign-ups that starts with a personal welcome email, and then sends several follow ups that try to engage users to avoid churn. One of the emails is sent 10 days before the trial period is over, and asks the user if they would like an extension of the trial — many users respond to this one, and it has helped keep more users than any other feature.

Always be talking to your customers — that's the only way to really understand how people interact with your product.

In the beginning, the conversion rate of sign ups to paying customers was around 5%. Four months after launch, I got my first two paying customers. They were a couple of the gym managers I knew personally, but it still took me several months to get them to switch to the paid plan. Now conversion is a bit over 8%, an improvement I attribute mostly to feature additions that address some common use-cases, and the email drip cycle mentioned above.

As a career software developer, I never did much in the way of customer service because generally I had co-founders or employees to handle most of the customer interactions. As a solo operation, however, it quickly became apparent that getting good at providing customer service was paramount. Talking to customers really exposed me to all the weak parts of the application — problems with the user experience, missing documentation, confusing features, and more. This focus on customer service has helped me establish personal relationships with many of my paid customers. Over time, many of them have referred additional paying users, not just based on the quality of the product, but because of how happy they were with the customer service I was providing.

The main takeaway is to always be talking to your customers — that's the only way to really understand how people interact with your product.

Month Revenue
Jan 2016 0
Jun 2016 180
Oct 2016 1050
Feb 2017 1630
Jun 2017 2110
Oct 2017 3240
Feb 2018 4280

What are your goals for the future?

2017 was mostly about listening to customer feedback and improving the product incrementally. I now feel that the product is in a good place to start increasing marketing efforts and spending, though I'm currently on pace to double revenue without any additional marketing. My overarching goal for 2018 is to quadruple revenue.

As revenue is ramping up, I'm looking to invest more of it back into growth. Some of my goals for 2018 include:

  • Setting up an ROI positive AdWords campaign and slowly ramp up spend
  • Hiring an outbound sales person
  • Establishing more cross-referral collaborations with merchant account resellers
  • Starting an affiliate program to incentivize users to refer us
Pricing

The biggest challenge will be getting the outbound sales effort started. The main problem with hiring salespeople is that they're usually good at selling themselves at interviews and it would likely take a few attempts until I find the right person.

What are the biggest challenges you've faced and obstacles you've overcome? If you had to start over, what would you do differently?

Getting the word out there was difficult initially. I had to do a lot of leg work just to get a few articles published, and for a few months I was getting zero traction, which was a bit discouraging. If I had wanted to grow more aggressively, getting an outbound sales operation going early would have probably been a good idea.

Other than that, the process went about as I expected from having previously started multiple similar companies.

Have you found anything particularly helpful or advantageous?

Starting a business in an industry I've been involved in as a consumer for many years has really helped me understand the market and build the product accordingly. I also had existing connections I could use to get feedback and gain early customers.

I see a lot of entrepreneurs try to tackle lucrative markets that they don't know much about because they see an opportunity. While that can work, I'd recommend you start a business in a market you're deeply familiar with to increase your chances of success.

Getting good at providing customer service was paramount.

On the more operational side, a few things I'd recommend:

  • Set up a live chat — either Olark or Intercom
  • Setting up an Email drip campaign. I built my own system using Mailgun's API, but Mailchimp and others have pre-built systems you can use. Also, check out Patrick McKenzie's course on drip campaigns
  • If you have a B2B product, consider Capterra for running ads
  • Engage your customers on a daily basis. Talk to them, understand how they're using your product and what their pain points are. Talk to people who churn out or pick a competitor — understand what's missing for them.

What's your advice for indie hackers who are just starting out?

If you don't have all the skills needed to build, launch, and market a product by yourself, strongly consider finding a co-founder to do it with you. It's hard to get everything right the first time, and sharing responsibilities can be a big help.

I'll repeat this one more time: talk to your customers. Many technical founders that I meet base all of their decisions on analytics and technical metrics. There's value in that as well (I track a bunch of parameters), but true understanding only comes from actually talking to your target audience. Engage them in chat, send them emails, get them on the phone, meet them in person — do everything you can to understand them better.

  1. 1

    Fantastic tool. I remember seeing that post on /r/bjj reddit btw :)

  2. 1

    How important was the drip email system to your overall success? And how did you find mailgun to integrate / work with?

    1. 1

      It definitely saved me some sales. The most important Email in the sequence is the one I send 10 days before the end of the trial, asking the user if they need more time. A lot of people respond that they didn't have the time to go over it in detail yet and would love another month. Also an opportunity for me to start talking to them.

      Mailgun is very easy to work with, I had already integrated with it in my previous company so I didn't have much work to do there.

      1. 1

        Thanks. Also, can I just say, good job! It's really encouraging to see someone build something for a defined audience and put the customer first - and see these great results!

  3. 1

    Thumb up for insisting on staying in touch with customers daily. And many other useful tips. Thanks.

  4. 1

    For the initial pain points that you uncovered, did you build them all into your MVP? What where those? What were things that you added later and how long did it take you to build your app to its current state?

    1. 1

      Yes, I felt that in order for the software to be able to replace existing solutions at a gym, it needs to answer all the major use-cases. That included member sign-up and waivers, payment processing and memberships and attendance tracking. I think perhaps the website feature was not necessary since most existing software solution do not provide it, but I want to differentiate there and it was part of my growth strategy.

      Some features that were added include a POS (Point of sale) feature (for selling equipment at the gym), rank and sport management, a document management feature, a revamped membership features, additional payment processors and many more. Those updates all happened incrementally since I launched it and it still goes on today (2 years later).

  5. 1

    Nice work Eran, hey your customer are only from brazil or around the globe? if so, how you manage the bills/invoices with the localizations for each specific country?

    Very inspiring indeed.

    1. 1

      Actually, I don't think I have a single user from Brazil :)

      Though it's called "Brazilian Jiu Jitsu", it's actual a global sport right now - and I cater to every martial art regardless (as well as yoga studios and fitness gyms). Most of customers are US based, but I have some from Europe and South America. The UI is only in English right now (might consider localization later). Payments are handled by payment processors such as Stripe and Authorize.net, so as long at your country is supported you'll be able to process payments through my software.

  6. 1

    Congrats on your success Eran!
    Did you include the digital members sign in from MVP, or was this feature added at a later stage? (For example instructors manually input the info later)
    It must have been hard to explain how to use the software to early users.

    1. 1

      The instructors use the same UI as the members to input the details, so it was baked in from the start. That was a critical element of the software in my opinion.

      I tried making the software as user friendly as possible, and feel that I did a good job in that respect since most users have no difficulty using it with minimal to no input from me. Of course, I continuously improved on some pain points that I saw people asking about a lot. User feedback is very important for that reason also

  7. 1

    Damn. Capterra. Yeah... Didn't even think about that one. Love this community. Great choice on learning BJJ and providing value to that community.

  8. 1

    Eran, congratulations! As a young software developer/amateur entrepreneur myself, I find this kind of post just amazing.

    Specially after Binpress, seeing you succeed warms my heart. I hope that someday I can be just like you :)

    You said you track some technical parameters. Do you mind elaborating on that?

    Cheers,
    Bruno

    1. 1

      I was to referring to common conversion metrics, such as clickthrough-rate, time on page, conversion rate to trial, conversion rate to paying customer, churn rate, segmentation by channel, etc

      Those are useful to track but don't tell the whole story

  9. 1

    You have a great business model on your hands, Eran! Just allow me to make few suggestions:
    -your price page needs re-doing - colours, plan names, pricing, offer... I assume this is causing you some loss of revenue
    -your website design does not seem to be gym oriented, but more SAAS oriented. Gym crowd likes explosive, energetic things, not corporate and neutral...
    -if its hard to spell it, change it. Your domain might be cool for IT guys, not for gym folk, dont you think? If it would be "Man Rails" - ok'ish, but "Mano Rails" is harder to remember, pronounce and I bet it will get lost in minds of busy people.

    1. 1

      Hi Bart! Thank you for the kind words :)

      I agree about the pricing page not being ideal, When I get the chance I would definitely love to redesign it.

      Regrading the overall design of the website - It's geared towards gym managers / owners, not gym goers. The goal was to convey a clean, professional feel, and I feel it's doing that while having some martial arts influences.

      Regarding the name, you got it a bit wrong - it's MA on Rails. MA stands for Martial Arts - anyone who trains should not have a problem with that. It's actually a good conversation starter - a lot of people have heard of Ruby on Rails (yes, even gym managers) and ask if that's where it comes from.

      Appreciate the feedback!

      1. 1

        Right, I have misread the domain name. Sorry about that.
        I still think gym owners/managers are more lenient to energetic designs rather than corporate. I understand that this is focused on top-tier people, but since they work there and probably use the facilities, they live in the world of Proteins and Gym Gear with all their hyped ads. This is why I think your website styling can be a bit too neutral and calm.

        1. 1

          Martial arts gyms have a different vibe than what you are talking about :) For fitness gyms, I definitely agree though

          1. 1

            Yep, I agree with you, and I think your approach is correct. A martial arts gym and a fitness gym are two very different places.