4
20 Comments

Getting a lot of hits on ads, but no conversions

I've been advertising on Twitter, with a 4% CTR (I'd say that's decently high). But every time I drive lots of traffic to my site, very few if any hit the "Get Started" CTA. We're talking like %5-10. Not even signup, just hitting the signup CTA.

I'm wondering if there's something grievously wrong about my landing page that I'm just not seeing. It's a product to help other makers validate their ideas/graphics/assumptions about the market.

Please help! Any feedback is really appreciated :) https://scoops.io/

#landing-page-feedback

, Founder of Icon for Scoops
Scoops
on May 31, 2019
  1. 3

    Hey @Chkrlee,

    Here's some candid feedback.

    There's too much info and it's disconnected. It's hard to figure out what the core value is.

    In the hero, the message is about knowing your customers by doing customer research.

    In the "How it Works" section, you're talking about finding early adopters and gaining traction.

    I know those things are related, but the current copy isn't connecting everything.

    The design elements in the hero are distracting. The text "No problem by they way..." looks too much like the rest of the copy. Adding the arrow, I thought I was supposed to click on it. It also looks like it's part of the Intercom integration.

    In the hero, you may be pushing people away from your site by linking them off to your Medium post on "Why Research could Make or Break your Business". Have you checked the stats on how many people are clicking that link?

    Your tone in that article is how I think you should approach your landing page.

    Your current headline - "Make things people want" requires a lot of explanation to get people engaged. Currently it's nice and short but it doesn't connect with the customer.

    Put your customer into their emotional experience.

    Using your article (and the assumption that customer research is the goal) try something like this:

    "Scratching your head because you can't figure out why you aren't getting new customers?"

    Imagine your customer sitting at their monitor and seeing that they have no new customers, yet again. What are they going to do? Are they going to slump down in their chair because they still have no new customers? Are they going to heavy sigh and say "what the f#$k"?

    Paint that picture and make that connection as soon as you can.

    The "How it Works" section is well designed but it's still just a lot to consume. Pare it back a bit.

    The following 1 & 2 sections came out of nowhere. Nothing set up a bulleted list. That section feels like somebody liked it and really just wanted to use it, somewhere.

    The "Peek Inside" section could easily replace the previous two sections with a little bit of messaging.

    Finally, your CTA's are inconsistent. You have "Get Started For Free" and "Create a Question for Free".

    I think it's a lot of information that needs some cohesion and paring back.

    The design is nice and the service is necessary. If you haven't already, use something like Hotjar to watch how people interact with your site. Check how many people are clicking off to your linked Medium article.

    1. 1

      awesome! really appreciate the help!

      1. 1

        No problem. Hope it helps. Good Luck!

  2. 3

    Can you tell if they're even scrolling down? How long are they staying on the page? Or they just land and bounce?

    Also, allot a few % (or maybe more) to click fraud. Unfortunately, that's the reality of our times.

    Re: Landing page, not an expert but some comments

    1. The left and right border images on your header seem distracting.
    2. On How it Works section, those light gray text are too light, almost invisible. Also, I didn't realize they're even clickable!
    3. Overall, I think it's too much text displayed. (Even though some of the text are just part of the graphics.)

    Maybe on the graphics, just represent these text as colored bars?

    1. 1

      Nope, most not even scrolling down. It's on twitter though.. wouldn't they have ways to prevent ad fraud? Thanks for the feedback though much appreciated!

      1. 2

        Click fraud can come from either competitors or publishers.

        From competitors: They cause you to quickly exhaust your daily budget, preventing legitimate users from seeing your ad. They click on your ad with no intention of buying, just driving up your cost.

        From publishers: They display the ads on their site, have an army of bots/real users clicking on ads displayed on their own network so they get the commission.

        I have no experience with Twitter Ads though. But with FB and Google, these kind of activities can be rampant. I think Google ads are the worst when it comes to click fraud.

  3. 2

    Hi Chris, you should look into integrating FullStory.com on your website (I have no affiliation with them). I've integrated it on my bootstrap project at Yumfog.com They have a free tier which lets you see users interacting with your website. You might be able to get some clues on what's wrong.

    1. 1

      Already done :) I was wondering about ad fraud specifically because 95% of people don't scroll down at all or take any action on the page!

  4. 2

    As others have suggested, there's a lot of text there. That's especially true for a landing page to an ad. And even more so if the ad is from something like Twitter and not a search ad.

    So instead of linking the ads to your actual site, I would try simply presenting one key value prop on a traditional landing page. So no elements or other items to distract from the pitch.

    Have a clear CTA that is repeated on the page. (Side note: your page has buttons that are styled like your CTA buttons, but which aren't really buttons. "Interview a Respondent" for example. That's confusing.)

    I would make the text + value + CTA on the landing page correspond with the CTA in the ad. I would also try variants of the CTAs on the landing page. Is "get started for free" the best CTA for this traffic? How does it perform versus e.g. "get real people to validate your idea" or something?

    I would also consider a lighter-weight CTA like getting their email in exchange for something they can use right now.

    The other thing I would look at is whether the traffic sources/CTAs are bringing you the right traffic. If you get the wrong traffic, it won't convert at this stage or a later stage in any case. So make sure you're attracting the right audience!

    Good luck!

  5. 2

    It's not clear to me how the interviewees are being matched to my survey. Am I bringing them? Are you finding the right people for me?

    1. 1

      I'm sourcing them for you, but yes that's not clear. Will change!

      1. 2

        That's a totally different reaction from me than if I'm bringing my own people. That big change is enough to turn me from, "I'd never use this," to, "I'll give this a shot."

        1. 1

          :) Great to hear. I've got my marketing work cut out for me, clearly. If you do give it a shot let me know, you can get started for free (1 question to 50 people) if you're looking just to get your feet wet!

  6. 1

    Hey Chris, could you share some screenshots of your ad(s)? A bit hard to give any advice without seeing the ads.

  7. 1

    This is something I've been experiencing with my product. The only difference is I'm using Adword :(

    1. 1

      Share your landing page and ad copy if you want us to take a look. May help to specify your targeting settings too.

        1. 1

          My first impressions without seeing how you set up your ads:

          • I'm having a hard time figuring out who the audience would be for this tool - what do they do, how much disposable income do they have, why are they having trouble saving? Are you asking people to deposit money into a stranger's account, pay fees (to stripe, and to you), and then be able to withdraw their own cash? I don't want to be rude, but who would use this type of service? Perhaps you know of use cases I can't think of, but if I had to guess why nobody is signing up it would be because there's no product market fit. This aside, let me point out anything else that sticks out.
          • Not clear this is for UK only
          • Not sure what this tool does, the message just doesn't come across clearly. It sounds like you lock up your own funds so you don't spend them?
          • Pain not stressed, who is this for? Why do they really need this?
          • It sounds like you want me to send money to an account - this is an INSANE ask that would require an insane amount of trust. I had a problem trusting TransferWise and they are backed by a billionaire... Why should anyone trust your website / your company? Do you employ bank grade security? Who is backing you? How many people are behind your organization, will my money disappear? I mean.. who the hell are you? I don't say this in a rude way, just making a point that you are asking for something so big and giving me so little to go on.
          • Again, fees seem insane - stripe fee, your 1% fee, plus some amount, just so I can lock away some money for savings?!
          • zero trust - no testimonials, no backers / investor info, no social proof of any kind, no about, no company name, no contact info, no phone number, you are a ghost.

          I will stop here. I think you see the pattern and where I am going with this. For a website that deals with money, you're going to have to 10x the trust factor. See any of the online banking apps, money transfer services.

          1. 1

            Hi,
            Thanks for the feedback.

            • My target audience is people who have hard time-saving money. The tools are there to help you save money.
            • I'm starting from UK but I hope to expand to other currency.
            • Yes, that's correct. What part confuses you? Perhaps this is the issue.
            • For people who want to save money fast to fulfill a goal.
            • Ah OK, I agree here. Someone who is just starting would definitely to do something.
        2. 1

          And ad copy / targetting preferences/ audiences?