What do you think about Code-Review-as-a-Service?

What do you think about Code-Review-as-a-Service?

on January 6, 2019

Say something nice to v8ever…

1

Is it a competitor for Atlassian stack?

Selling this as a service to dev companies from my opinion is not a great idea because you cannot do it significantly better than well-known products in industry.

But, considering this as a platform for knowledge sharing between developers probably can work. For example, I have experience in Java but at the same time total newbie in Rust. So I definitely want to get help from experienced Rust guy in my first coding steps in this new language and can share my Java dev experience for smbd else

evkarage

·
8 years ago
·
Reply
1. 1
  
  I haven't heard about such Atlassian service. There exist some solutions, but they're poor.
  
  Selling this as a service to dev companies from my opinion is not a great idea because you cannot do it significantly better than well-known products in industry
  
  Can you please share those products that do it?
  
  Serhii
  
  ·
  8 years ago
  ·
  Reply
  1. 1
    
    I'm talking about this one: https://atlassian.com/software/crucible
    
    evkarage
    
    ·
    8 years ago
    ·
    Reply
    1. 1
      
      Atlassian's Bitbucket has this feature to see code diffs and write comments. Thus making a code review. I don't get how their Crucible differs from that
      
      Anyway, stackoverflow and similar sites provide a "please review my code" option, so maybe it's really no need in such a service
      
      Serhii
      
      ·
      8 years ago
      ·
      Reply