7
26 Comments

Asking for feedback, but no one replies

I'm trying to get some feedback from users in the last two months, I have sent about two dozens requests, but no one replied to my message... How many replies should I expect? One out of 10 users, or out of 100? So frustrating. I'm wondering if I missed something, or my product doesn't worth a comment.

  1. 7

    Here's some things to try:

    1. Make it easy, an original piece of feedback without any questions to prompt it is difficult to write. instead, craft 2-3 specific questions that will give you the best bang for buck. The shorter and more specific you make it, the more people that will complete. Make the questions easy to answer - the hardest part of writing feedback is thinking of what to say
    2. Make it fun - Typeform all the way baby
    3. Offer an incentive. A discount or bonus. Anything to get someone on the edge of considering committing their time to you to see a tangible 'trade' of some kind
    1. 2

      J.D. is right on with this one. I would add a prompt with specific questions on your site.

      Something to the tune of:

      1. As they sign up ask them:
        “What made you want to try X product?”
        Give them some multiple choice answers and an “other” option with a text prompt.
      2. After they try a feature:
        “Did you like using X feature?”
      3. As they stop their subscription:
        “We’d hate to see you go. What about your experience has made you want to cancel?”

      I think giving them options they can pick plus the “other” text field would encourage more feed back because there is less friction to begin giving feedback. People hate backing out of something once they’ve started.

      1. 1

        +1 for the idea about multiple choice. I've given feedback to a couple software companies, but rarely finish the process if I have to write more than a couple sentences. If you keep the form short and focused, you can brag that it only takes 1-2 minutes to complete when you send it out

  2. 4

    What does your product do? How active are your users? How crucial is your product to their lives? Mind sharing what your feedback request looks like?

    Also, consider asking them for feedback at the moment they buy or sign up, or at the moment they leave. That's when your product is top of mind and an email from you won't just be a distraction.

    1. 1

      I'm building a CRM like app for individuals or small businesses. Not crucial to the users, there are many well built alternatives, and the users are not active.
      My request is quite simple. First thank them for trying my app. Then asking if there is anything to improve or feature missing, and tell them their feedback is quite important to us. Just three or four sentences.
      I will check how they used my app before sending my request, usually send it two or three days after the sign up, or even later. They may already left!

      1. 3

        Try not using email - a lot of people, especially in the small business world, are a lot less likely to reply to an email than they are something on-site.

        1. 1

          Thanks. I will see what I can do.

      2. 1

        Have you tried picking up the phone? Or going through a training session? Or can you generate feedback before they buy (what features they want)?

        1. 1

          No, all I have is an email address. Will try if I can get more information about the user.

          1. 1

            Maybe from the moment they sign up request this information?

            I would also add that inside the system add a button to request help, report a bug, or request a feature so you can see what people need

            During your demos go through a checklist of their expectations compared to your competitors, or ideal version of your product

    2. 1

      This.

      Plus, what kind of feedback are you asking for? A quick NPS or a lengthy essay?

      Are your users opening the email and then not clicking through to give feedback? Or is the problem earlier/later?

      Are you phrasing the feedback request as an obvious bonus/value add for the user? Or just as more work?

      1. 1

        I didn't expecting a lengthy one. Maybe just a few words, something like 'sorry, I want this, but your app doesn't have it' is enough for me. Maybe no reply is the reply. My phrasing does sound like more work to the user...
        I haven't tracked the opening, will do it next time.

  3. 2

    Building off of @jdlindsay 's great response--make it simple, make it fun, offer an incentive--I've followed those three principles and have gotten a roughly 10-20% feedback response rate (from emailing users directly), with the following added tactics:

    1. Not only make the questions short and direct (e.g. 1 short sentence per question), but the also entire email itself short (e.g. basically around 3 more short sentences aside from the questions).

    2. Make it personal. Use your [yourname]@ email, not "team@" or something. Personalize the email e.g. use their name in the subject, mention something about the user themselves (e.g. that they're a high usage user) in the email. Use the word "I" not "we", and show your voice, and your gratitude.

    This article was helpful to me in understanding the principles behind crafting effective customer feedback requests: https://www.kayako.com/blog/the-proper-way-to-ask-for-customer-feedback/

    An example email I wrote to ask for feedback from my users that got about a 20% response rate (for a product that, after user feedback, I decided to turn into just a newsletter for now https://www.cryptomintclub.com/):

    Hi there!
    
    My name’s Troy, and I’m the founder of CryptoMint. I noticed that you’ve been reading my emails (thank you!), and wanted to reach out to ask you some questions!
    
    I was wondering if I could ask you two quick questions:
    
    1. What do you like about CryptoMint?
    2. What do you wish CryptoMint could do for you?
    
    Your feedback is insanely valuable because I’m still very much developing CryptoMint as a product! Your ideas could very well get implemented, and you could be a part of shaping CryptoMint's future.
    
    Also, use me as a resource, now’s your chance to pick my brain :) You can reply to this email to respond. Thank you so much for your time!
    
    Talk soon,
    Troy
    
    1. 1

      Love the email you've come up with. Being personal is a great point in all of this.

      I just signed up for your newsletter, but did have a moment of pause before I did so. You'll have a higher rate of conversion if you include some examples of the resources you share.

      Best of luck to you!

  4. 2

    In my previous life, when we ask for customer feedback, we get pretty low feedback. when they have feedback, it's often not relevant at all...

  5. 2

    I know that feeling :(

  6. 1

    There is some great feedback here, but I think one key tip that folks have been missing is the follow up. I guess it may not work as well when you're contacting hundreds or thousands of folks. Sometimes even if your email is super easy to respond to, but the person checks it while they're in the middle of something, they may simply forget to respond.

    This is on the top of my ind because I contacted ~6 people to do some idea validation two weeks ago, and none of them responded. This week actually two of them replied to a follow up email I sent, and another replied back on his own.

  7. 1

    Hey, yes, as most mentioned, look at giving back some incentive and communicating about it!
    We built Feedier for that! You might want to check out feedier.com - we are also looking for feedback :)

  8. 1

    Thanks you guys, I wasn't aware of these tips.

  9. 1

    Try offering an incentive. Like a $25 Amazon coupon.

    1. 1

      Hmm I suspect people would then type a bit useless off-topic feedback, just to get the reward? But if you instead offer $25 to spend on the SaaS you're building — then those who give feedback, will be more motivated to give actually useful feedback?

  10. 1

    I can give feedback if you want

  11. 1

    Need a bit more context for the community to be helpful. In addition to Courtland's questions:

    1. How are you soliciting feedback? (in app, email, etc)
    2. What are you asking for?

    It's very important to be specific about what you're asking of your users. Just like a marketing email has a call to action, your feedback request should make it easy for the user to take an action. Examples: "How likely would you be to recommend the product?" or "Do you find the product valuable?", or some other hypothesis you're testing with quantitative responses (1-5, thumbs up/down) are good places to start.

    You can use an NPS type service (like Delighted.com) which will prompt for qualitative response once the number is chosen, or simply embed a google form in an email with 2 questions (quantitative and qualitative).

    1. 1

      Thanks. I'm using email to send request, just for some feedback on possible improvements or problems. Don't know what NPS stands for, but will check it.

  12. 1

    This comment was deleted 7 years ago

  13. 1

    This comment was deleted 8 years ago