Best forum software

I'd like to add a forum to www.bitcompare.net

The reason is I'd like it to become more of a community where people can share tips and ideas around DeFi and crypto wealth management.

Does anyone have recommendations to build the forum. Full custom, or is there an off-the-shelf solution that could be good?


  1. 6

    I spent a whole lot of time trying to find the best solution for community building. Here's the progression:

    Started with https://discourse.org/
    Moved to https://community.nodebb.org/
    Moved back to https://discourse.org/
    Tried https://spectrum.chat/ (great potential)
    Tried https://flarum.org/
    Found https://www.mightynetworks.com/ and stayed there. Mighty Networks was free, but I upgraded. It's the best community building platform out there.

    Here is the end result: https://hq.citizenhealth.io/

    1. 1

      It would be great to understand why you abandoned Spectrum and Flarum?

      1. 2

        Flarum was too new. While I liked it, I wasn't going to stake the future of a community on an open source project that was just getting started. For context, this was about 3 years ago.

        Spectrum is awesome, but I wanted to map a subdomain to the installation. Since that wasn't possible with Spectrum, I went with Mighty Networks.

  2. 3

    I remember Flarum being all the rage: https://flarum.org/

    Still seems to be in beta though

    1. 1

      Hmm... I wonder which is better out of Flarum and Discourse?

      1. 2

        I used Flarum when trying to get a community set up for my product (ended up abandoning it to revisit when we have a larger customer base). It worked fairly well and I enjoyed it but it's definitely beta and unless you're fairly tech savvy it's not quite worth the setup / maintenance. Lots of config changes, crashes, huge issues with plugins, and some features missing. I'd suggest looking more into Discourse or something heavier like MyBB - but as mentioned below, Reddit would be a really good choice, especially if your users are already on it.

    2. 1

      This is pretty cool, will look into it, thanks Jerry!

  3. 2

    If you don’t mind paying the most powerful and my personal favourite is https://XenForo.com constant updates and an overall great product with a good community marketplace!

  4. 2

    Discourse is the only one that I've found that I would feel comfortable using.

    I would love to hear of other options.

  5. 2

    A suggestion: start with reddit?

    1. 1

      Yes, good suggestion.

      I would, however, still like to know what good software options there are should I want to go down that route in the future...

  6. 1

    A basic forum with replies, and replies to replies is a pretty simple recipe. That's how I'd roll it. You'll have 100% control with the freedom and flexibility to iterate without constraint. This assumes you're on Rails.

    has_many :replies, class_name:'TopicReply', dependent: :destroy

    belongs_to :topic
    belongs_to :parent, class_name: 'TopicReply'
    has_many :replies, class_name: 'TopicReply', foreign_key: :parent_id, dependent: :destroy

  7. 1

    Surely vBulletin is up there?

  8. 1

    I used Vanilla (https://vanillaforums.com/en/features/forums) a lonnnng time ago and was very pleased. Discourse looks cool as well. I had never heard of them before today...

  9. 5

    This comment was deleted 2 years ago.

    1. 1

      This looks great! Have you used this before?

      1. 1

        This comment was deleted 2 years ago.

Trending on Indie Hackers
What you are currently working on? 116 comments IH invite system is broken 28 comments How this Reddit marketing tool used itself to grow to $5k/MRR 24 comments Roast my 3D landing page! 13 comments plugmebot: Increase engagement on your twitter profile by creating real-time dp and banner 4 comments I don't know what to do on indie hackers anymore. 2 comments