9
20 Comments

Charging monthly vs. yearly

I'm going to launch my product in a few weeks and given the nature of my product, having a yearly-only plan seems to be the way to go. Has anyone tried this approach? Do you find customers are more/less willing to sign up if there's no monthly plan?

Would love some insights or thoughts!

on May 28, 2020
  1. 2

    I started monthly but have switched to yearly payments. (For now... will see how it goes)

    Here’s why: I read or watched a video on this topic (can’t remember which) but basically if you’re charging monthly and if your project grows fast, you won’t have enough cash to manage the project

    For example
    50 customers that pay you $5 p/mo will get you $250 but you still need to handle that 50 customers (with support in that month)
    But 50 customers that pay you yearly $60 gives you $3000 for that same month, giving you much more room to breathe and provide better support.

    Now of course it’s much harder to get customers that can pay upfront ...

    1. 1

      Appreciate your insights, thanks!

  2. 2

    Hi Lukas. We only offer annual.

    We started off monthly, but soon found a tight correlation between people who bought annual and the quality and depth of their feedback. They felt they had a strong affinity with the product and so were super motivated to provide constant feedback.

    So we switched to annual only. At this point, and we are definitely profitable, we value feedback rather than bigger numbers. As it's sub £100 is still acceptable to those who have the burning problem we're intent on solving.

    We will certainly introduce monthly at some point to catch the users who want to try for a month etc, but obviously at a higher price point than the annual (when divided by the 12 months). We're in no rush to grow income, but rather a solid product. And to do that the feedback we get is invaluable.

    Plus the often overlooked bonus is we get the cash upfront, rather than getting a little every month. Which goes right back into development and advertising.

    1. 1

      Plus the often overlooked bonus is we get the cash upfront, rather than getting a little every month. Which goes right back into development and advertising.

      Great point @rugy. Upfront cash is great for scaling, more customers, more revenue and so on. If your product proves to be useful, you will have people staying after a year. Monthly can be cancelled anytime, i think yearly will still have higher average CLV (....depending on the product)

    2. 1

      Super interesting @rugy, didn't even think that yearly customers could be more dedicated to the product! And cash upfront is a perk for sure, especially at the beginning!

  3. 2

    Hi Lukas -

    I think this highly depends on your target buyer and the target price range.

    To give some contrast. I run a startup and I NEVER purchase annual, even if i know it'll save me 20% - 30% over time. I like having the cash on hand and the flexibility to change if a new/better service arrives.

    On the flip side, the target customer we sell to works on annual budgets and through procurement teams/departments. For them, they have a set annual budgets, change is hard, and they hate procurement, so they almost always opt for annual plans.

    Focus on your target customer and how they make purchase decisions, what their cash flow position is, and how change happens in the org.

    The other factor is price point. If we are talking $9/mo vs $79/year, I'd probably purchase annual, because it's such a nominal price point. At least for me, the point where it's starts to hurt is around that $20/mo $200/year range.

    1. 1

      Thanks for the thoughtful response, @johnny_am! The idea of figuring out how the customer makes purchase decisions is really one I haven't thought of sufficiently. Appreciate your candor on your "pain" threshold!

      1. 1

        One last vector to think about. Is the purchase being made personally (my personal CC), or on a company credit card.

        I definitely have subscription fatigue on personal CC, but that just doesn't happen on company CC given the different use case. Hadn't considered that until now.

        So you'll probably want to consider that data point as well.

        1. 1

          Considering I'm targeting solo makers and freelancers, this is definitely something to keep mind (there are so many services out there that subscription fatigue is really a thing). Thanks again @johnny_am

  4. 1

    Given nature of product annual only seems fine. Can revise later if needed but just an added complication at this point.

    1. 1

      Agreed, keep it simple!

  5. 1

    What is the price point @lukasf ?

    1. 1

      Not terribly expensive, probably hovering somewhere between $25 - $40 annually if charged yearly, otherwise $3 - $4 monthly...

      1. 1

        I would say, go for an annual plan then. Your customer acquisition costs are going to be definitely more than $4 no matter how bootstrapped you are. At $40 per customer, you are more likely to turn a profit on them, than if you were to charge them monthly.

        Besides, I don't think it makes sense to target any customer who cannot afford even $25-$40 for a product.

        Edit: I'm relaunching one of my free apps with a paid tier, and I plan to charge $50/year.

        1. 2

          That's for sure! Also, given what my product does (storing instructions for a relative in case of death/injury), it's something users will need for more than a few months.

          Just followed you, looking forward to keeping up with your updates!

  6. 1

    Hi @lukasf , I don't have experience offering monthly or yearly plans but I would just like to say as a customer I prefer monthly to be able to leave if I'm not happy with the service in the month. I understand the business may need to lock customers into a yearly plan but as a customer, it may be too much of a commitment to a service I may forget about.

    1. 1

      You wouldn't think of it as "ugh, another monthly subscription"? I don't know why but sometimes I have the feeling people have subscription fatigue...

      1. 1

        I do have subscription fatigue, but I also don't want to feel like I've been "got". Some people offer yearly subscriptions and 1,000 hoops the customer has to jump through to cancel it.

        Mostly, I don't like subscription offerings for things I think should be a one-time payment.

        In my perfect world, I have no problem with a 14-day free trial, and an upsell to a monthly subscription. If I love your product I'll move to a yearly commitment. Trust me if your product/service is very useful to me and the yearly subscription is lower in cost I will happily subscribe for a year of savings.

        1. 1

          Totally makes sense @BurrowX, I really appreciate your thoughts!

          1. 1

            Thanks looking forward to your success!