3
12 Comments

Community === Forum?

Hey there! I'm building a tool for creating forums - Symposify. It's not ready yet, but just curious about how many % of communities need a forum? Or they want, but afraid of complexity?
Or maybe I'm missing something?

Do your community have a forum?
  1. Yes, I have
  2. No, but I want
  3. No, Slack/Telegram/etc is enough
  4. Want to build community *with* forum
  5. Want to build community *without* forum
Vote
posted to Icon for group Community Building
Community Building
on October 20, 2020
  1. 1

    Most communities want a forum, but few launch one because setup, moderation, and engagement feel overwhelming. Many start on Discord or FB Groups and only switch when they need structure and searchability. If Symposify removes the friction, there’s real demand.

  2. 1

    Nice here the things to be happen more.

  3. 1

    This healed my cracked lips in one night! The berry scent is amazing. The Christmas sale price of $ 20 with free shipping is unbelievable! Shop 👉 Mimic Makeup

  4. 1

    That’s a great project idea! From what I’ve seen, the need for a forum-style space depends on two things:

    Community size & depth – Smaller groups often do fine with chat tools or social feeds. But once a community grows past a few hundred active members, threads and structured discussions become valuable to prevent ideas from getting lost.

    Content longevity – If the community needs searchable, evergreen knowledge (guides, FAQs, debates), forums shine. For quick banter, real-time chat works better.

    Many communities want forums but hesitate because:

    They fear moderation overhead.

    They think setup and maintenance will be too complex.

    Members are already comfortable in Discord, Slack, or FB Groups.

    Where you could stand out with Symposify is by reducing that complexity — making forums feel as easy as chat, while still giving the structure that communities eventually outgrow their chat apps to find.

    It’s like studying with qurantajweedteacher.com: at first, learners may resist because it feels structured and more formal, but once they see the clarity and order it brings, they appreciate the system. Communities often go through the same journey with forums.

  5. 2

    We're more and more tempted to stop using Discourse as it's competing directly with our online video rendezvous but our situation is singular.

  6. 2

    There seems to be a big split in community software nowadays; it's either chat-based (Slack), a traditional forum or a group on Facebook. All have their pro's and cons I guess but forums seem to work really well for bigger communities where repetitive questions and such become a big problem.

    Out of curiosity: What specific problems have you seen around with existing forums that you want to solve?

    1. 1

      So, if I will target for big enough slack communities, maybe they will consider my solution?
      About problems with existing forums: classical forums are outdated, and any decent community project that I saw(including IH) developed their own software

      1. 2

        To be honest I think Slack is not well-suited for most communities at all. But the simple fact that people are used to it for work helps a lot. It's just very low-friction.

        Of course, there are clear issues such as important content fading away, hard to discover the most interesting discussions, etc.

        1. 1

          Yes, same for Telegram. But I think chats and forum can co-exists, serius topics will be discussed on forum, and more casual talk - on chats

  7. 2

    I think there is today a community, forum or group. They are usually the same only with a little different architecture. I think whatever you do you should approach it more Slack style or just much better. Something that I do not like about Telegram or the Facebook and WhatsApp groups is that they are very chaotic. However, that small change from slack or any of its imitations, allows you to have chaos on the right side, while on the left side you have order. The truth is that I am not a guru either, but I think a real opinion could help you more than a click on any of the options. Greetings.

    1. 1

      Thanks for the reply!
      Yeah, I agree, chaos in all that chats and groups is the main reason why I came up with this idea

Trending on Indie Hackers
I'm a lawyer who launched an AI contract tool on Product Hunt today — here's what building it as a non-technical founder actually felt like User Avatar 151 comments Never hire an SEO Agency for your Saas Startup User Avatar 81 comments A simple way to keep AI automations from making bad decisions User Avatar 65 comments “This contract looked normal - but could cost millions” User Avatar 54 comments 👉 The most expensive contract mistakes don’t feel risky User Avatar 41 comments We automated our business vetting with OpenClaw User Avatar 34 comments