I've been getting into the FIRE movement over the past year but find it can be two competing forces when you're trying to save your stash for financial independence whilst also trying to get your side project off the ground.
Does anyone have a similar debacle? Any advice?
I believe the goals of both IndieHacking and FIRE are nicely aligned. Here are three reasons:
The core idea in both is to spend less and achieve more. As IndieHacker you should aim towards early profitability without heavy investing. This way you can generate some extra income and save faster. FIRE teaches you to spend less, which gives you an option to invest some saved money into your business.
I don't think FIRE requires you to earn a big stash of cash. Instead, I am focused on healthy cash flow that won't require me to sell my time anymore. This can be achieved with your own indie business even faster than in employment.
Why are you drawn to early retirement and what will you do with your time then? It is mostly about dissatisfaction at my job. I know I won't stop working after retiring. How about working on something you enjoy right away? Something that will make you stop thinking about retirement altogether. Even for less money.
I'm sold! Very well put Matt. Definetely shifted my perspective.
Love the point about not actually 'retiring'. It's more about the freedom you can achieve by controlling where you earn your money/spend your time. Both IH'ing and FIRE definitely reflect this.
I would say that to have a healthy cash flow through FIRE requires somewhat of a large pool of capital. It needs to be substantial so that the 4% withdrawal can support you. But definitely agree that controlling the areas this cash flow comes from (e.g. IH'ing) is crucial.
Happy to hear somebody else can relate to my reasoning 🙂You can also apply 4% rule the other way around. Every dollar of monthly recurring equals to $300 in your investment portfolio.
That's a great way to look at it!
I'm glad to see some discussion popping up around the overlap between FIRE and indie hacking. I think they compliment really well.
The way I see it, the FIRE movement seeks to minimize expenses. The "side hustle" movement seems to maximize revenue. I think there's a balance and doing both can be a great way to set yourself up for a really great future.
The way I manage things, I try to save a specific % of my net income and invest the rest. But with one caveat. I consider my indie hacking to be in the investment category. So if I need to put $1000 into my business bank account to purchase hosting, domain, SaaS products, courses, etc I don't consider that to be something I need to "budget for". To me it's no different than putting $1000 into stocks.
I've found that helped my mindset a lot. Before I would try to minimize everything, including business expenses, but the issue is then you need to sacrifice immense amounts of time.
Can I develop a landing page for free? Yes. Will it take a week? Probably. Or I can throw $10/month and an hour of setup at webflow and get that time back. Well worth it imo.
This is a fantastic approach. Similar to what @matt_jem mentioned above in how both movements complement each other (changed my perspective!).
I'm a fan of your approach to treating the side hustle as an investment. The only caveat I'd add to that is you are increasing your risk. Assuming average returns, the market is a fairly risk-averse move whilst a side project is a fairly risky move. Obviously, the payoff from the side project can be much higher and more rewarding than compounded monthly returns.
Either way, I think your approach is the most sensible way to tackle both FIRE and IH'ing. Ties back into what @noahflk mentioned on lifestyle design.
I follow the regret minimization framework.
" The idea is to project yourself into the future and look back on your decision from that perspective. For Jeff Bezos, he thought of when he would be 80 and if he would regret not trying to start this company."
For me I hated working for a large company and startups wouldn't give me a chance (i was a new dev, but i had skills)
I saved money quit my job and did some freelance. Clients are hard work so I quit that as well and started bootstrapping a SaaS.
If you take enough swings with SaaS and use them learnings you can earn more than a job plus it is more enjoyable (but the ups and downs are much larger).
In hindsight I would have looked into productised services but they weren't as big back then. Using the cashflow to fund the SaaS.
FIRE is great for employees not so much IHs. Spending your savings to pay for your life while bootstrapping seems to go against FIRE.
Love this and the framework. I agree that it is difficult territory for IHs. I guess that's the common thread here - that everyone has this drive to build/ship things. Not doing that will lead to regret.
FIRE is ultimately about being able to safely walk away from a job? I guess Indie Hacking (in most cases) is just another path leading to the same destination? Perhaps slightly riskier - but the potential for a greater payoff.
Pretty much. FIRE has a delay built-in to reduce risk.
Most IHs want to start today (or as soon as possible).
I guess it would be in between FIRE and VC funded startups (leaning more towards FIRE).
They are both the same goal.
I like to follow the motto of doing more with less. If I can make $100 for $15 and an hour of my time, I see it as a win. If I can build products that are evergreen and sell enough to cover a lunch or buy some new gear each month, that's supplementing my savings goals.
I'm about sustainable growth personally. I went from never making a dollar in my life with my side projects in my twenties to being able to launch products and make a few thousand bucks with work that I'm genuinely interested in doing and people are finding helpful.
Although I qualify for FIRE today, I have no need to retire. I'm young, I have a family I'd like to sustain my lifestyle with as we grow, and I have a career that makes me happy while doing side projects that I love. One day I will focus on a new venture, but for now I'll stay small and continue pushing value into the world.
Time is definitely the most important asset we have, but even if I had 40 hours back each week, I'm not sure I would use them productively right now nor gain the skills I am currently learning in Big Tech. These skills aren't something you can get from a course or book as it's learned through experience.
"stay small and continue pushing value into the world". I absolutely love this. Couldn't agree more that time is the most important asset.
I find the idea of FIRE intriguing. But I think that many people in the community take it way to way too extreme levels. Some absolutely overwork themselves and don't indulge in anything for 10-15 years just to retire early. That's not for me.
Could I get a high paying software developer job at a large company, climb the ranks, save 75% of my income and retire in 10-15 years? Probably.
However, I'd be pretty miserable. I don't want to spend some of the most formative years of my life (20s and early 30s) working towards that one goal while depriving myself of almost everything else. I also want to enjoy the journey.
So what is my plan? I build my ideal lifestyle now and do what I need to to make it sustainable. Currently that's freelancing for a reduced number of hours. This gives me flexible working hours, location independence and the opportunity to take longer breaks for travel. Even more importantly, it gives me time for indie hacking.
So in short, I try to build a life for myself where I can be happy from the get go. That way, there's no need for me to retire at 40 because I will hopefully still love what I do then.
I still invest some money every month and will hopefully become financially independent at some point. Probably not as early as a software engineer earning 500k. But maybe I do because I launch an indie business that takes off. Who knows.
I have not articulated my life's financial strategy, but this is it. It's neat to see someone else get it down on "paper". The future isn't promised, so you have to make sure you enjoy the journey. All the better if the present that you enjoy is building towards an awesome future.
I absolutely love this approach. I think there is a subset of FIRE called Coast-FIRE which reflects something along these lines.
But I think your point about prioritising the need to build a sustainable lifestyle now is crucial. Use that as your foundation and then seek FI from there.
Being an Indie Hacker is a huge advantage if you’re trying to achieve Financial Independence. It means that you don’t have to reach a high enough net worth to cover all your expenses, you only have to reach a high enough net worth to cover the difference between your expenses and your side project income. That means you can quit your day job a lot earlier.
And vice versa: being close to Financial Independence is a huge advantage if you’re trying to be a full-time Indie Hacker. It means that your Indie Hacker income can be much lower and you can still afford to quit your day job.
Anyone out there who’s both an Indie Hacker and into FIRE, I’d love to talk to you for The Quit Work Podcast! Let me know!
I was on the FIRE path for about 10 years before becoming an indie hacker. This has allowed me to not need employment very much and can focus on my project. As a parent I've tried doing projects on the side before, but there's just not enough time for it without quickly burning out. I need to be able to focus full time. Having a large stash (and a working wife) takes most of the financial stress out of the process.
That said, if you're inclined to be an indie hacker I'm not sure I'd recommend working a job you don't like for 10 years before doing it. When you're young you have so much time and energy to spend it's crazy, so there's some truth to the advice to do a startup/business right out of college.
Super interesting. It's become clearer that FIRE and IH'ing are two different vehicles that can ultimately get us to the same end goal. IH'ing perhaps being the more risky path with a greater payoff.
Great to hear that advice on going while you're coming out of college. It's such a difficult choice to make.
I've been saving/investing towards FIRE for a few years now and managed to achieve 25% of my goal number.
But recently I realized that many FIRE people are aiming towards doing nothing after retirement which isn't my goal at all. My goals are to work on my personal projects and do things I love.
So I decided to take a leap of faith of starting an early-early retirement. I'm going to spend the next few years making products and trying to make them profitable.
I have a big chunk of my money invested but I still have a lot of cash so I'll use it for paying bills for the upcoming years.
I will for sure decrease my net worth at first. But if I manage to achieve ramen profitability I will no longer care about achieving FIRE number.
This is amazing! I totally agree. I definitely don't plan to 'retire' either so the idea of working on side projects is a winner!
Thank you, i didn't know about the FIRE movement, interesting
I see FIRE in the next ways:
You can fully work on the project for a few years, grow it to say $20k MRR and then sell for half a million. This way you can invest those money into stocks or alternative assets to get "passive income".
Build your own portfolio of micro-SaaS and then sell a few to reinvest money into stocks, alternative assets or your next SaaS.
In both ways you should have some income flow to pay for your Indie Hacking journey.
Love that! I'd say that's the dream situation. However, not all projects are that successful so there is a trade-off if you go all-in for your project as opposed to investing in an ETF.
This comment was deleted 3 years ago.
I've also been sceptical of it at times too. However, I think the FIRE movement is fairly clear in its assumption that reliance on the market is based on historical data. This is that the market (on average) adjusted for inflation (on average) can return 5%. So while it is true that the market might crash in the short term, in the long term (based on the assumptions) you can expect it to level out.
I'd like the say that being a successful Indie Hacker removes that dependence on the market. However, success as an IH is also a combination of skill + work + random variables. A ton of which are out of our control. So i'd say there is still a fair bit of dependence there too.
A lot to ponder on!
Two others points here are that a crash is usually temporary in the grand scheme of things, so if you adjust your withdrawal rate and expenses you can(hopefully) ride it out and stay independent. Look at sequenced return risk, I think, plenty of studies.
Also, let’s not forget not all FIRE is stocks, you can invest in real estate and live off that cash flow. Even if the value of the homes drop, as long as you don’t pick a horrible location your rent should keep coming (YMMV).
Tons of overlap, personally my goal is for side business income to be put into cash flowing real estate. I much prefer the idea of conservatively leveraged real estate as compared to just buying stocks.
Great add. I often fall into the trap of assuming FIRE is just stocks/bonds (maybe crypto now). Real estate is certainly another option.
And yes, any crashes generally level out. So if you're happy to be in it for the long game I think the assumptions that underpin FIRE are generally safe assumptions.
This comment was deleted 3 years ago.
Very good points. I agree the two do differ in how independence is defined.