44
35 Comments

Don't Publish On Medium

https://brianbalfour.com/quick-takes/dont-publish-on-medium
submitted this linkon June 25, 2020
  1. 14

    i was 2 years ahead of him!

    👇🏼

    ABANDON MEDIUM: https://john.do/abandon-medium/

    👆🏼

    i have thousands of posts on that platform... that they are monetizing until the end of time... and i don't see a penny. they also have some really shitty seo. i mean, terrible.

    1. 2

      Of course you were. I am not surprised about that! 🤣

      1. 1

        lol. i wish i had stopped earlier... i have thought about deleting all the content but they don't have a mass-delete function... it would take a long time... ugh.

    2. 5

      This comment was deleted 6 years ago

      1. 3

        you are a champion!!

  2. 10

    the greatest marketing trick of the century was Medium convincing writers to publish on it

  3. 9

    I'll play Devil's advocate here...

    I've been cross-posting my articles from my Wordpress site there for almost 3 years now.

    I get 30+ newsletter subscribers directly from Medium every day.

    Over the past 9 months, I've averaged over $10,000/mo from the Medium Partner Program.

    All Medium articles can be set so that the canonical link refers back to your externally hosted article, which means you still get the SEO benefit and traffic going to your own site.

    I've made several very good friends through Medium, which have also turned into really valuable partners.

    I know my experience isn't necessarily representative, but I think more people should consider using Medium as an easy adjunct to a self-hosted platform for blogging.

    Happy to chat more about this if people have questions!

    1. 1

      You just convinced me to try Medium. I have a local product in Brazil and we are growing in traffic with our articles, why not post on medium if I can set the canonical link to my own blog? I don't really see a downside.

    2. 1

      Well done! $10k/m is impressive. My partner checks look a LOT smaller lol.

      You've encouraged me to give cross-posting another shot though. Thanks for the contrarian view :)

    3. 1

      Hey Nick, congrats on your success on Medium. That's a helluva side income! Your name sounds familiar. Pretty sure I've read some of your articles before. Do you know Ayodeji Awosika? I've been following him for a couple of years and he's doing $10k+/month on Medium too. I really like his Youtube content too. Just waiting see his channel explode.

      I'm going to start posting on Medium soon. Doing the cross-posting, import stories technique you mention above. What are the rules on linking out from Medium? Is it okay to link to a landing page or any page on your own website to get mailing list subscribers?

      1. 2

        You can link whatever you want within your posts. Most put self-promotion links at the bottom of their post (Nick links to back to his website).

        1. 1

          That's good to know, thanks James.

  4. 5

    Medium paywall pushed a few great things way. For example, distribution is not available if the paywall is disabled.

    Imagine a new blogger use Medium, they don't have any followers to "clap" for their content. Which not triggering the detector for great content and make it hard for them to gain followers

    Besides, most of the popular content provides only a surface of the information, since that is what the crow needed. Posts with deeper knowledge are getting buried.

    1. 3

      That paywall was more than just the nail in the coffin...it was all of the nails possible.

  5. 4

    Its funny how well received Medium was upon launch. Critics praised it for its phenomenal UI.
    https://teehanlax.com/story/medium/

    Now its dogshit.

    1. 1

      that was a long time ago...

  6. 4

    I couldn't agree more, Medium is dead, paywall everywhere lol
    Substack would be really great if we can set up a custom domain tho

    1. 1

      +1 to substack!

  7. 2

    I'm building imprint.to to address all the points in this article!

    1. 1

      Been loving Imprint!

  8. 2

    How's exactly the way Substack works ? Can you create some free contents and then ask for others to be behind a payment ? Any other interesting (and valuable, for the readers) platforms out there ?

    1. 1

      yes. exactly. you can use it free or create premium / paid content. it's easy.

  9. 2

    Totally agree. Medium isn't really good as a distribution channel anyway when you just begin creating content (personally or as a startup). You still have to do a lot of work to bring people there, but there is little you can do to engage and retain them aside from getting more people to share your content.

    1. 1

      it wasn't a bad distro channel.. for a time. but now, it's trash.

  10. 2

    Just when I thought of starting it on Medium.

    I should think again.

    1. 2

      @8bit @XCS - Recently, I published 2 articles there because couple of years back, it was a great source for traffic. But now, i don't know, it doesn't seem so.

      I mean, One of my article there still has 0 views, literally. I am confused how is that. I can agree with @hieunc that "Posts with deeper knowledge are getting buried."

    2. 2

      glad to save you the time!

    3. 2

      Why did you consider starting on Medium? I personally never saw the benefit of posting my content on some platform I don't control. Do they bring a lot of interal traffic?

      1. 1

        they used to have some decent signals and sharing... but, now... nothing.

  11. 1

    Well, if you are tired of medium, here's a little humble writing platform I'm building: https://midnight.pub.

  12. 1

    I don't like Medium.
    I don't like their comments system - very annoying to make so many clicks just to see a response.
    I don't like their monetization system.
    But I can't agree with "You Are Building Medium's Brand, Not Your Own" - it's simply not true. When you create an article, you mention your business and it's how you are building your own brand. If your article has been noticed you can get much from it for your brand.

  13. 1

    I’m pretty new to all these.

    Didn’t realize that medium was this bad. I only just started writing and found medium easy. I click editor and type. No need to fiddle with formatting and it seems professional.

    It seems substack is the recommended alternative from the comments — the initial pop up to readers seems a tadbit spammy though.

    Are there other options? I’ve tried Wordpress. It’s a lot of headache plus gets expensive fast. Then netlify but wasn’t happy with all the tweaking, css needed for the template I chose.

    At this stage I’m not really looking to have any subscribers. I simply want to focus on the writing, do light sharing and pump out articles until I get to about 50. Then next focus on marketing more. And medium made that easy.

    Are there any recommendations for free alternatives to medium. Free because my writing journey is a long term game so I’m hoping to keep monthly cost close to zero for the first year.

    1. 1

      This comment was deleted 6 years ago

  14. 1

    I advise my clients to be careful with using Medium instead of their own blog, but that said I have personally found Medium to be valuable for audience building. I've been pulling in $30-$100 a month from it which is nice considering I barely use it.

    Substack is great for some uses but just like Medium I advise people to consider you won't get any SEO benefit and cannot use/benefit from your domain with it.

  15. 1

    For now, We are using Medium just to cross-post and linking the articles back to Substack which is where we are building the audience.

    I guess if you are sharing the free resources or content, then it doesn't hurt cross-posting on Medium.

  16. 3

    This comment was deleted 3 years ago

    1. 1

      nothing. nothing. nothing. +1