Feedback on the idea and landing page
Hey guys, I would love your feedback on the landing page for, Collabnow- we are trying to validate the idea by talking to as many people as possible, current target= 30 people . So if you would love to chat about the idea, please reach out :)
Trending on Indie Hackers
Wow! Some negativity here, sorry to hear.
I disagree that collaborating on projects is over done. Granted I've never looked for project collaboration, I've not seen other solutions before now. So either it's not over done or the marketing isn't being done right. At the beginning of this year I put a bunch of work into volunteering IT/dev/DB for non-profits and had no luck. So clearly there is still an unmet need.
I like your landing page. Being a data nerd, I prefer numbered lists that clearly state what the workflow/dataflow is going to be and what I can expect.
I've not signed up as I have a few things on the go but will give it some thought. Good job.
Hey there! We really appreciate your feedback so thank you. We are currently still at validating the idea and changing the landing page as we listen to more feedback. Would love to chat with you more in depth about it - will reach out to you :)
"Devil's Advocate" is different than baseless negativity. Saying "nice idea and nice landing page" is worthless. Saying "overdone idea" can save years.
Maybe you are not qualified to disagreeing if you haven't even looked? Not trying to sound negative or anything :)
Good luck in life with that attitude.
Dude... This is a feedback forum, the point is to provide critique. The milestones forum is for patting on the back. Also maybe notice the smiley after the second part, i was laughing out aloud and teasing you, so don't be too serious about it...
The landing page looks nice enough, but it doesn't matter because:
.. The idea "let's collaborate on project" is extremely overdone.
.. Worse, your variant of the overdone idea is completely generic; most target for example programming projects, game projects or student projects, but you target just "projects".
.. And you don't have faintest attempt in any other unique selling point either.
. Bonus: out of all of the currently trending overdone ideas, this one has chicken egg problem so it is 10x harder to execute than for example equally overdone "website feedback" idea.
.. Finally, 30 signups for waiting list is completely useless "validation" for this type of service.
Sorry that i cannot be more positive. I'd recommend you watch this video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DOtCl5PU8F0
Hey! Thank you for your feedback.