Feedback wanted! Concept: Wirecutter for knowledge

My initial impression is that I would not find it useful.

It feels too generic. The questions that it purports to address are too general, and I'm not at all confident that the linked resources will have answers that will be useful - indeed, even if some of the resources may turn out to be helpful, I will have to spend an inordinate amount of time hunting for a useful tidbit hidden among lots of irrelevant chatter.

It's a bit like going to a library to research how to prune tomato plants, and the most that the librarian can offer is to point you in the general direction of a dozen shelves of books about growing all sorts of vegetables and tell you that the answers to your questions must be somewhere in that section, so have fun finding what you're seeking.

Say something nice to EG…

1

My initial impression is that I would not find it useful.

It feels too generic. The questions that it purports to address are too general, and I'm not at all confident that the linked resources will have answers that will be useful - indeed, even if some of the resources may turn out to be helpful, I will have to spend an inordinate amount of time hunting for a useful tidbit hidden among lots of irrelevant chatter.

It's a bit like going to a library to research how to prune tomato plants, and the most that the librarian can offer is to point you in the general direction of a dozen shelves of books about growing all sorts of vegetables and tell you that the answers to your questions must be somewhere in that section, so have fun finding what you're seeking.

radiator

·
4 years ago
·