1
5 Comments

How do you deal with self-promotion hate?

Hey guys,

As a redditor and indiehacker it's natural for me to promote my products on fitting reddit communities. Problem is, most communities have specific anti-promotion rules and sometimes they get pretty angry about it. I should note that I always try to provide value when creating promotional content on reddit.

What do you guys do about such situations, where you know exactly where your audience is but rules are blocking you?

I also notice this on other channels as well so I wanted to get your opinions and outlook on this.

posted to Icon for group Growth
Growth
on May 24, 2021
  1. 2

    This kind of drives me nuts. Yeah nobody wants to go to a Reddit forum and it's a series of endless text ads but where is the harm in saying, just once, hey I made this and it's in your wheelhouse, take a look I built it for the benefit of this subreddit and their interests. How is that a just cause to get you booted? Meanwhile, someone else sees your thing and says "Hey I saw this new thing, check it out" and that's no problem. If you were to ask the members of some subreddit if they think they are really tuned in and maybe early adopters, semi experts, etc. they would all say yes because WTH they are spending time gathered together with their like-minded pals to share and help and learn right? They discuss apps and products a high percentage of the time so why is it taboo to announce something new....

    1. 1

      Yeah, I always liked to see people on reddit built stuff and showcasing them, even before I started building products myself because you can always find something cool out there.

      I don't see the harm in posting once either. After all, people who don't build stuff greatly outnumber people who build stuff so it could never be spammy.

  2. 1

    Posting on a self-promoting-friendly platform doesn't bring any attention to your project either since everyone on there'd be focusing on spamming rather than reading your ads anyways. You can try on Openland, it's a self-promoting friendly community for entrepreneurs and you'll understand what I mean.

    1. 1

      Hey openland seems cool!

  3. 1

    Even if you are providing value, self-promotion should be done so very sparingly.

    If you think about it, if you don't provide any value, it's legit spam. So, anyone who recognizes that is going to cloak their self-promotion in some other somewhat helpful content.

    You have to ask yourself this -- Is your sole purpose for responding to a discussion to find a way to pitch your product in some way? If so, it's spam. So, if you get a little hate, then you just have to deal with it.

    IH is a lot more liberal about self-promotion, so it's not the best community to use as an example. Most communities hate self-promotional posts.

    As for ways around it:

    • If you are trying to plug your products, then you should plug other comparable/competitor products first, and list yours last
    • Never link to your website -- people can Google you
    • For every 1 time you plug your product (thoughtfully), make sure you are contributing 5-10 replies on that community when you are not plugging your products at all. When people look at your community activity, if they see that you are contributing more than you are being self-promotional, they may be more forgiving
    • Find others on the community who are interested in your product/service category, give them free versions of your stuff, and ask for their support in the community by mentioning your products from time to time, when/where applicable. Have them become your ambassador.
Trending on Indie Hackers
I built an AI that turns an idea into a live business in under 10 minutes. Here’s what 1,000 launches taught me User Avatar 77 comments I built a web-based vector editor from scratch and integrated an AI Agent. Need just ONE beta tester! User Avatar 70 comments Building Noodle, a keyboard-first REST client for the terminal User Avatar 31 comments "Looks Good to Me" Is Quietly Killing Your Feedback Loop User Avatar 28 comments Launched 580 landing pages in 1 week. Solo. No team. User Avatar 18 comments I built a competitor monitor for indie founders User Avatar 14 comments