How do you decide between freelancers vs agencies when hiring remotely?
I’m curious how other founders approach this, especially early stage.
When you need help (marketing, dev, ops), how do you decide between hiring a freelancer vs going with an agency?
Do you base it on budget, risk, speed, or something else?
Would love to hear what’s actually worked (or failed) for you.
Trending on Indie Hackers
Building is easy. Deciding what not to build is harder.
https://www.navaitools.com/
Navaitools is a comprehensive directory of AI solutions that updates cutting-edge artificial intelligence tools daily. Covering popular fields such as writing, productivity, image generation, marketing, and programming development, it builds a convenient bridge for individuals and businesses to explore and use AI tools.
I choose an agency because they do it for me: they find the people and get the work done. I don’t want to manage freelancers. One team, one responsible.
That makes total sense. A lot of founders don’t actually want “outsourcing,” they want relief from management. Agencies work really well when accountability and coordination are the main pain points. One team, one owner, fewer decisions. I’ve seen freelancers shine when someone has the time (or enjoys) managing, but if not, agencies are often the calmer option even if they cost more upfront.
Great question - this decision has bitten me before.
My rule of thumb: freelancers for defined tasks, agencies for ongoing systems.
Freelancers work well when you can clearly scope the work ("build this landing page," "write 10 blog posts"). You get direct communication, often lower cost, and can find specialists who've done exactly what you need.
Agencies make more sense when you need a team working together or when the work requires multiple skill sets operating in parallel (like a full rebrand + website + launch campaign). The markup pays for coordination you'd otherwise do yourself.
The trap I fell into early: hiring agencies for tasks a single good freelancer could handle. Paid 3x for project management overhead I didn't need.
What type of work are you looking to hire for? That context would help narrow down which makes sense for your situation.
This resonates a lot especially the part about paying 3x for coordination you didn’t actually need. I’ve noticed agencies shine when multiple skills truly need to move in parallel, but for single-threaded work, a strong freelancer often delivers the same outcome with less friction. The real trap seems to be outsourcing decision-making instead of execution. Once that’s clear, the choice usually becomes obvious.
Exactly - "outsourcing decision-making instead of execution" is probably the clearest diagnostic. If you still need to be involved in every call, you're not buying leverage, you're buying expensive messengers.
The flip side: when you do need parallel execution across disciplines (design + dev + content all moving at once), that coordination overhead becomes valuable. It's just important to recognize when you're buying that vs when you're paying for it unnecessarily.
For me it usually comes down to scope and uncertainty.
If the work is well-defined and short-term (landing page, small feature, marketing experiment), I prefer freelancers. It’s faster and easier to adjust.
If the scope is unclear or long-term, agencies can help with structure, but they also add overhead and cost.
Early stage, I try to keep things lightweight and only bring in agencies once the process is already proven.
Curious — have you ever switched from a freelancer to an agency mid-project?
You're right on this one, the freelancers are more affordable than having an agnecy, the only thing is freelancers don't always live up to the expectations, they can always fake it with reviews & portfolio, while agencies don't false promise and actual delivers results. And you I have switched from a freelancer to an agency mid-project costing me thrice the money and time.
If I need to hire someone, I would use either Upwork or Deel. Upwork gives you flexibility, but it would cost more, while a $49/month Deel lets you hire a workforce super affordably from developing countries.
In my now failed consulting company I hired a marketing agency. Learned the hard way that if you can't "sell it" yourself then you won't be able to explain how to an agency as well. I've reverted to using AI to get my head straight on what needs to happen, try it myself or get help doing it myself.
That’s a tough lesson, but a very real one. If you can’t articulate the value or the process yourself, agencies are basically guessing and guessing gets expensive fast.
Using AI (or doing it yourself first) to clarify the message before bringing anyone in feels like a much healthier sequence. At least then you’re outsourcing execution, not thinking.