24
23 Comments

How to Become an Idea Generation Machine

We are masters of self-loathing: I’m not creative enough. I can’t think of anything new. Most of what I think is already being implemented. Am I doomed for life?

It’s counterintuitive, but we do generate a lot of creative ideas daily. In fact, more than 6,000 thoughts cross our minds per day (study). We’re full of it, just like the Lego box.

The problem is not generating ideas but generating novel ideas. At least 90% of the ideas are either average or don’t strike a chord.

Here’s the relief: the 10% ideas you get in your mind every day are the golden nuggets. And you don’t have to be extraordinary to generate these novel ideas. That’s not where most fail. Most of us fail because we don’t even allow ideas to be born and raised. And if we do allow them, we fail to capture them.

David Allen says the brain is to generate ideas, not to store them. Instead of making our mind a thinker in chief, we treat it like a store owner. And leave every idea in the hands of mother memory — which eventually makes the idea orphan.

THE PROBLEM: Why is it Hard to Generate Ideas?

  1. Overloading the Mind: Our mind has numerous background tasks to perform. Injecting another idea and trying to remember it is like opening the 10th tab in Chrome. Your mind will crash.

  2. Analysis Paralysis: When you hit the ‘aha moment,’ you get a rush of dopamine to execute it — something that your mind dearly dislikes immediately. So it puts it off by analyzing it and concluding it’s not good enough. And as soon as you finish the shower and go back to the room, the idea becomes a faint memory.

So, how can we generate, capture, and nurture ideas that are novel and inspiring? The answer is in developing a system — DDS.

THE SOLUTION: Dump, Dive, Search

Creative legends have one thing in common; they are utterly disciplined. Think Charles Bukowski, Hans Zimmer, Christopher Nolan, or Ryan Holiday. They don’t have an extra brain to delegate idea generation tasks. Instead, they have a system that works like a factory of ideas. And it starts with…

1. Brain Dump: The Idea Vomit

Creativity occurs spontaneously — almost like a spurt. Remember that last time you had an amazing idea? Chances are you were driving, showering, or cuddling with your dog. And not brainstorming in front of a laptop.
The truth is creative ideas occur when we least expect them. It’s counterintuitive actually; when you force yourself to be more creative, you produce garbage.

The workaround to capturing the momentary creative insights is a brain dump. Whenever an idea, insight, or thought occurs, dump it off your mind on a medium. Jot it on a notepad with a pencil or a to-do app on your phone. The rule is to dump it without a second thought — even if it’s as weird as building a dog kennel made of glass. No matter, vomit it out.

2. Dive in the Dump

Don’t start executing your ideas just yet. Remember, most of them would be boring, repetitive, or copied. In this step, you have to look at ideas from eagles’ eyes. Ideas that create a spark in mind aren’t just random outbursts of energy. They have a meaning and purpose to them — which we can’t understand with just the mind itself.

Diving in the idea dump is a way to find that meaning between ideas and form a connection. Scroll through your to-do list, flip the pages of your notebook, and try to connect them backward. An idea you got 10 days back might be another piece of the puzzle you thought about today. Now, what if you haven’t recorded the older idea? You’d have missed out on a great creative burst.

3. Search for the Nuggets

Now that you’ve connected the puzzles trim the borders. Yes, out of these ideas, even a fraction would be the most novel. Search for the golden nuggets. When you resurface after diving in the dump, you’d be in a Eureka state. We often forget that innovations are the product of self-awareness.

After you find the nuggets, zero in on them, Hemingway said, “the only writing is rewriting.” Expand this philosophy to other domains. Naval once said, “Learn from times iterated over time spent.” You won’t get a groundbreaking idea on day one.

Intellectual improvements follow a nonlinear curve. Iterate on your nuggets, fail, find what works, then exploit it. That’s how you become an idea generation machine.

Lastly, share your ideas and build a circle of learners.

If you enjoyed this perhaps like or retweet the thread on Twitter. I try to reverse engineer how great mindset, ideas, and people work and share it in concise tweets.

posted to Icon for group Content Creators
Content Creators
on July 11, 2021
  1. 3

    I had been thinking about a best mans speech I need to write for over a year with no clues. One night, just as I was dozing off, it walked in to my head fully formed. I wrote it there and then. Woke up the next day and forced myself to try and remember it.

    I could not, I had no clue at all what I wrote.

    Grabbed my phone, read it back, it’s awesome.

    Moral of the story. Write your ideas down when you get them like OP says

    1. 2

      Aah! That happens to me too Simon. Thanks for sharing it. Turns out we're too judgemental of our ideas and discard them at once if they don't look promising. But it's the small insignificant ideas that paint the entire picture.

  2. 3

    If you look for ideas, maybe take a look at problems first. I manage a newsletter where I share hand-picked real problems people and businesses have from Olwi - subscribe here

    1. 3

      Subscribed. Do you have any plans to expand its search beyond reddit?

      1. 2

        Not now at least. Reddit is the biggest source of information. Other websites don't provide the least amount of it so as to make integrations with them.

        But somewhen I plan to. If you have a suggestion regarding what website/source to consider, please let me know! And thanks for taking a look.

        1. 2

          If you find some websites you like but find it's inconvenient to locate/parse the info you're looking for, you could check whether they offer rss feeds. That's actually how I discovered this post, via this indiehackers feed: https://feed.indiehackers.world/posts.rss .

          https://needgap.com/ doesn't to my knowledge have an api or rss feed but does have a focus on discussing problems

          1. 1

            RSS feeds are saviors in such cases, yes. Thanks for the suggestion!

    2. 2

      I agree that identifying problems prompts ideas

      I've also had some success with recording how I spent my time and how much I liked it, to help me to later reflect on problems and generate ideas

      If that sounds interesting, you might be interested in https://github.com/mathjeff/ActivityRecommender . Feedback is welcome!

    3. 1

      Vercel 504: GATEWAY_TIMEOUT

      1. 1

        Thanks for noticing. Should be working now.

    4. 1

      Spot-on mate! Loved the insight. Going to check Olwi for sure :)

  3. 2

    I started listing my ideas in a notebook and in workflow.com . It's a cool list app that allows you to have infinite levels within each item. I need to invest some time in organizing it. It's an effective way to list future projects and blog posts.

  4. 2

    The problem isn't just getting a good idea, it's refining an idea enough to a point where it can be either a minimum viable product that you can learn if there's a market or not - or a minimum marketable product that actually works and functions. Your idea might be a social media channel, or a 'competitor to uber' or a niche variation - but growing it to the point where it's no longer just a pipe dream is by far the hardest part for me.

  5. 2

    Awesome post, it reminds me of Tyler Tringas's article on the meat grinder approach to validating startup ideas: https://tylertringas.com/business-ideas-meat-grinder/

    Once you give yourself permission to come up with ideas without immediately shutting them down, you'll start having tons of ideas flow through.

    1. 1

      Thanks a lot! I'm not familiar with Tyler's idea, but it looks promising. Thanks for sharing the article, I'll read it today.

  6. 2

    That is basically my exact process. I get an idea and if it really seizes me I dump it onto a legal pad and it comes out to about a page or two. I write down the date and time on it and give it some kind of lame name that 99% of the time gets tossed. Then I let it cool off and I rewrite it to share it with my dev partner. Some of them die right on the paper after I cool down but about half of them survive. If I am motivated enough to write it down it already survived my first pass at dismissing it.

    The follow-on post to this should be "How to decide if you can even execute this idea and if anyone would use it" but you shouldn't ever apply those tests till after a couple of days.

    1. 1

      Thanks for sharing your experience, Dean! Yes, I agree that we should apply tests only after some time. I also noted your suggestion on the follow-on post, thanks again.

  7. 2

    Hey thanks for sharing! I agree that writing ideas down makes it much easier to remember and iterate on them.

    Another behavior that helps me organize my ideas is occasionally reordering them so that ideas that are easier or more important to iterate on show up more often and others show up less often.

    I look at two ideas at a time, and I
    I try to iterate on one of them if I can; if not, I compare the two ideas and move the idea that I like less so it shows up less often.

    I've also had some success with browsing my ideas in this way for a short while in the morning and/or evening when my brain is in a different state from the last time I browsed them. Today I'm up to 318 of these ideas for me to continue to iterate on.

    If this sounds interesting, it can be found as one of the features inside ActivityRecommender! https://github.com/mathjeff/ActivityRecommender

    In ActivityRecommender these ideas are called Protoactivities (under the Activities menu) because they're expected to eventually turn into actionable Activities. Feedback is welcome!

    1. 2

      Thanks mathjeff. I loved how you select ideas worth executing on. Your system to pick up novel ideas is worth stealing! PS: ActivityRecommeder looks promising. I'm definitely gonna check it out.

      1. 1

        Thanks Vibh_Dixit!

        Let me know if you have any ideas about changes to either the process or the interface - I'm super happy to make improvements!

  8. 2

    6,000 thoughts per day? That's 6 thoughts per minute. I guess most people have a much better CPU than me.

    1. 2

      Isn't that fascinating and shocking at the same time? So many thoughts yet how little awareness we have for them. That's why our brain crashes, just like PCs.

      The study is here, if you wish to check: https://www.queensu.ca/gazette/stories/discovery-thought-worms-opens-window-mind

      1. 2

        Thank you for sharing

Trending on Indie Hackers
I'm a lawyer who launched an AI contract tool on Product Hunt today — here's what building it as a non-technical founder actually felt like User Avatar 150 comments A simple way to keep AI automations from making bad decisions User Avatar 65 comments Never hire an SEO Agency for your Saas Startup User Avatar 58 comments “This contract looked normal - but could cost millions” User Avatar 54 comments 👉 The most expensive contract mistakes don’t feel risky User Avatar 41 comments I spent weeks building a food decision tool instead of something useful User Avatar 28 comments