Sign inJoin
1
1 Comment

I cold-messaged 3 SaaS founders about failed payments today — here's what I found

by heze

Today I did something uncomfortable: I left comments on 3 indie hackers' product pages asking them directly how they handle failed Stripe payments.

The 3 founders I reached out to:

  • Rybbit ($7.6k MRR, open-source analytics with a hosted tier)
  • Pirsch Analytics ($17k MRR, privacy-friendly analytics, 553 subscribers)
  • Hirevire ($14k MRR, screening automation SaaS)

My question to each: "How do you currently handle payment failures on the subscription side?"

Here's the uncomfortable truth I've learned building RecoverKit (tryrecoverkit.com/connect):

Most SaaS founders at $5k-$50k MRR have never audited their failed payment flow.

The math: at $17k MRR with 553 subscribers, you're statistically seeing 5-10 failed payments every month. Those customers don't cancel. They just disappear when Stripe's retry logic gives up — usually after 3-4 attempts over 1-2 weeks. With no dunning emails, that's $500-$1,500/month in silent churn.

A Day1/Day3/Day7 dunning sequence (3 emails, each with a different angle: "update your card," "your account is about to pause," "last chance before cancellation") recovers 40-60% of those before they churn.

I built RecoverKit to automate this. Connect your Stripe account in 30 seconds and it handles everything: tryrecoverkit.com/connect

If you have a Stripe subscription product and have never set up a dunning sequence — what's stopping you? (Genuinely curious — is it time? Not knowing where to start? Thinking Stripe's built-in retries are enough?)

heze's avatarheze
on March 11, 2026
Say something nice to heze…
Post Comment
  1. 1

    Useful split. One thing I would separate before installing any dunning tool: first post-trial invoice failures vs normal renewal failures.

    Stripe can retry both, but the first paid invoice after a trial is easy to lose in the wrong metric bucket. You can think you have a trial-conversion problem when the real issue is a recoverable payment failure, or you can think retries are working while app access stays out of sync.

    For a quick audit, I would ask for:

    • trial starts / trial length / first-month price
    • first post-trial invoice attempts
    • decline-code counts
    • retry count and recovered_at / paid_at
    • what the app does to access after invoice.payment_failed

    I packaged this exact narrow check as a small Trial-to-Paid Leak Audit. IH will not let this account post links yet, but the safe first pass does not need unrestricted Stripe login; redacted exports/screenshots are enough to classify the leak.

    If anyone here runs card-upfront trials and wants the intake checklist, reply and I can share it.

    dibolo's avatar dibolo
    ·
    3 months ago
    ·
    Reply