I launched my first iPhone app and I’m stuck at 13 downloads. Roast my positioning.
I launched my first iPhone app and I’m stuck at 13 downloads. I’d really appreciate honest feedback from people who have launched products before.
The app is called MealRadar. It helps people figure out what to cook from groceries they already have at home.
The core problem:
You open the fridge, there is food inside, but you still don’t know what to make.
What the app does:
- add pantry/fridge items
- generate recipe ideas
- generate 1, 3, or 5-day meal plans
- help use food before it expires
What I’ve tried so far:
- Instagram Reels
- LinkedIn posts and DMs
- Telegram/Facebook groups
- direct messages
- App Store screenshot improvements
Problem:
I’m getting almost no real users.
I’m not asking for fake reviews or fake downloads. I want blunt feedback:
- Is the idea too weak?
- Is the positioning unclear?
- Is “AI cooking assistant” the wrong framing?
- Where would you find the first 50 real users for this?
- Would you position this around saving money, reducing food waste, or solving the “what should I cook tonight?” problem?
App Store link: [https://apps.apple.com/us/app/mealradar/id6782612975]
I’m open to criticism. I just want to understand what I’m missing.
Trending on Indie Hackers
the idea's fine, the framing is what's costing you. "AI cooking assistant" is a category label, not a reason to download. your best line is the one you buried: you open the fridge, food's right there, and you still don't know what to make. lead with exactly that.
and i'd push the wedge toward waste. "use food before it expires" is really "stop throwing away groceries you already paid for," which is money plus guilt, both stronger than "generate recipe ideas" (every app claims that one). it's also closer to how people actually search: "what can i make with chicken and whatever's left," not "AI cooking assistant."
on distribution: 13 downloads after reels + LinkedIn + IH says the hook is the problem, not the volume. and LinkedIn/IH are founder channels. your real user is someone tired at 6pm staring into a fridge, and they're on TikTok or Pinterest searching "dinner with what i have," not reading build-in-public posts. match the channel to that person.
fastest test: rewrite your App Store subtitle as that fridge sentence and watch if installs move before you change anything else.
13 downloads after launch usually means positioning isn’t landing where buyers already complain — not that the app is bad.
Curious: are you looking for those complaints in Reddit / communities, or still iterating the App Store listing only?
I run a small tool that scores fresh pain threads for indie apps. If useful, I can show a quick mapping on a short call — or send a sample if you drop your one-liner + target subs.
That’s fair. I’m trying to do both, but I think the smarter next step is finding the places where people already complain in their own words instead of only polishing the App Store listing.
My current one-liner is:
“MealRadar helps you decide what to cook tonight from groceries you already have, so you don’t end up ordering takeout again.”
I’m thinking the target complaints are probably around phrases like:
If your tool can map fresh pain threads around that kind of language, I’d genuinely be interested in seeing a sample.
Also, if you’re open to it, could you try the app once and tell me if the first-use experience matches that pain or feels too generic? Not asking for a review — just honest feedback.
App Store link: [https://apps.apple.com/us/app/mealradar/id6782612975]
Fair trade, I'll try MealRadar and send you one honest first-use note, no review theatre.
On the sample: I'll scan for threads where people use exactly that language — "ordered DoorDash again," "too tired to decide what to eat," "bought groceries and still ordered food," "wasted groceries again." Each thread gets a 1–10 score + one line on why it matched, so you see the reasoning.
Quick thing I need back: your target subs. r/mealprep, r/EatCheapAndHealthy, r/Frugal, r/Cooking come to mind — but tell me which ones your buyer actually sits in. I'll run it and drop the feed link.
When you get it: pick 2–3 threads, tell me "yes I'd reply" or "no, not my buyer." That's the signal I'm after.
Fair trade — really appreciate it.
My best guess on buyer/user is not “foodie who loves cooking.” It’s more like:
So I’d probably start with:
The phrases I care about most are probably:
What I’m trying to learn is whether the buyer is really:
A) the person trying to save money,
B) the person trying to decide dinner faster,
or
C) the person trying to stop wasting groceries.
If you send a few threads, I’ll mark them honestly as “yes I’d reply” or “no, not my buyer.” And thank you for trying the app — one honest first-use note is genuinely more useful to me than a fake review.
Sample ready — used your subs + the extra phrases (DoorDash / wasted groceries / stop eating out):
https://threadscout-theta.vercel.app/feed/8868d216-853f-4541-b81e-1e0fb01d2e87
Each card: score + why matched.
Manual flags (not in UI):
Pick 2–3 and say “yes I’d reply” or “no, not my buyer.” I’ll also try MealRadar and send short first-use notes after.
I'd separate the product from the buying trigger. "What should I cook tonight?" is a daily frustration, while saving money and reducing food waste are reasons people justify changing their behavior. Understanding which one actually gets someone to install the app is the bigger positioning question.
This is a really useful distinction. I think you’re right — “what should I cook tonight?” is the daily frustration, while saving money and reducing waste are the justifications people use after the frustration is already there.
So the positioning probably needs to lead with the trigger:
“I have groceries, but deciding what to cook feels like work.”
Then the benefits become:
I’m trying to understand whether the install trigger is strong enough from the first screen/onboarding.
If you’re open to it, could you test the app once and tell me honestly whether it matches that trigger or if it still feels like a generic recipe app? No review needed — just blunt feedback would help a lot.
App Store link: [https://apps.apple.com/us/app/mealradar/id6782612975]
I appreciate the invitation.
I haven't tried the app yet, so I don't want to pretend otherwise. My comments so far have been based on the positioning and the way you've described the problem.
I do have a few thoughts about the trigger you described, but I'd rather explain them properly than leave scattered comments in the thread.
If you're open to it, what's the best email to reach you on?