4
1 Comment

I tried running ads everywhere and here's what I learned

Most of my week was spent running ads. I tried them on Facebook, Reddit, Google, YouTube, and Quora. I got wildly different cost per clicks for each ad platform, which was something I very much didn't expect.

Just to drop some quick stats I spent anywhere between $20 to $50 on each platform, and here are the Cost Per Clicks I got:
Facebook - $0.05
Reddit - $0.75 (I don’t understand reddit)
Google - $3.50 (I dive into this later)
YouTube - $0.20
Quora - $0.03

There are a few major takeaways from my experiments if you’re just getting started with paid advertising:

  1. I've heard very varying testimonials on Reddit ads. I'm not a regular Reddit user, so the community is foreign to me, but because the platform hates self-promotion my ad went poorly. It was a simple banner ad on the top of r/entrepreneur and r/sweatystartup, and all it said was "I experiment with entrepreneurship, live. :)" - I got 1 downvote, one nasty comment, one sassy comment, and a very expensive CPC ($0.75). Maybe my ad was too self-promotional? I've heard CPC can go under $0.05, if you do it right, but clearly I didn't.

Overall - you have to understand Reddit if you’re going to run ads there. It’s a picky community.

  1. Google Search ads will suck you dry if you're not careful. I haven't been able to find a way to set a CPC spend limit, and that's where it gets scary. Whatever your spend is set to, just like every other ads manager, it will spend it all. However, it won't optimize that, because if your search terms are even remotely niche, you're not going to have a lot of clicks simply because the traffic is low. On other platforms, most of the time, traffic isn't an issue - traffic is saturated. But when I ran ads on my Twitch account for people searching terms like "learn entrepreneurship" and "how to become an entrepreneur" the traffic was super limited - but Google still spent the entire budget.

I was running similar ads for a client, and they wanted to really max out conversions, so they copied a prior campaign and pumped 5x the money into it. We were unaware that Google Search ads don't limit spend, so it still spent all of that cash on the limited amount of engagement, and our CPC was triple that of the previous, and practically identical, campaign.

This makes things a little weird if you're targeting niche keywords (And I would assume most marketers are). It seems like the right approach, so you don't get screwed, is to start with a super low spend on your campaign, then slowly increase it until you max out on engagement. If the CPC starts rising at any point, drop spend back down, otherwise, you're spending more money for no added benefit. When I ran my campaign on a few super niche keywords, at a budget of $10 per day, my CPC was almost $3.50. Compare that to the $0.03 CPC I got on Quora, and you see the problem.

Overall, this was a really basic first test, but running ads on different platforms is not hard, and it's a great skill to have. If you put $5 into the Facebook ads manager, just to test and experiment, you've officially learned how to run ads on every single other platform. Twitter, LinkedIn, Quora - they all have almost the exact same structure, and for me, Quora worked out unexpectedly well.

P.S. If this is interesting at all, I conduct experiments like this every week, on live streams - let me know if you have any questions - here are the live stream highlights:

https://www.entreprenerd.blog/live-streams/marketing-month-week-2

posted to Icon for group Growth
Growth
on July 22, 2020
  1. 1

    great breakdown. the part about not knowing WHY something worked is the real killer -- you can't repeat what you don't understand.

    been building Clarik to solve exactly that -- watches your campaigns and explains what's happening in plain english. if you're still testing channels would love your feedback: https://getclarik.vercel.app

Trending on Indie Hackers
I'm a lawyer who launched an AI contract tool on Product Hunt today — here's what building it as a non-technical founder actually felt like User Avatar 150 comments A simple way to keep AI automations from making bad decisions User Avatar 62 comments “This contract looked normal - but could cost millions” User Avatar 54 comments Never hire an SEO Agency for your Saas Startup User Avatar 48 comments 👉 The most expensive contract mistakes don’t feel risky User Avatar 41 comments I spent weeks building a food decision tool instead of something useful User Avatar 28 comments