2
3 Comments

IdeaFit — The concept

This will be the first post in a series in which I'll be trying to generate some ideas, understand what I want to build, and solidify my vision.

Basically, that's my way of thinking out loud while trying to build a feedback SaaS product called "IdeaFit" (https://ideafit.io/ — yes, I've already bought the domain 🦌).

So let's start with the concept.

In my head, IdeaFit is a vivid, colorful board, absolutely user-friendly and stupidly straightforward. There's a list of feedback messages, there's an "upvote" button and a form for adding feedback.

The board

There are 3 main categories of feedback I can think of: ideas, bugs, and questions.

Imgur

An idea is basically a feature request. The site owner can consider if that's something he wants to implement, and the vote counter helps him make that decision.

A bug is usually just a request to fix something on the website. I'm still not sure if bugs need to have a vote button, what do you think?

A question is the most interesting feedback form. Very often questions are feature requests in disguise ("Is there a way to import my data from a different website?") or bug reports ("Why can't I download the PDF file. It worked yesterday!"). I imagine people would want to post those privately.

Feedback form

The form has just three fields for now (type picker, title, and text/body). Trying to make it simple and intuitive.

Small UX interactions would include:

  • putting focus into the title field, so a user could start typing right away
  • setting the type picker default value according to what page the user came from
  • finally, this beautiful text transition effect I spent an hour today to implement 😋

Imgur

That'd be it for today fellow hackers, the next time we'll talk about themes, colors, fonts, and I will recommend you several great books. See ya!

on May 20, 2021
  1. 2

    Hey @yanis, happy to hear that you also want to take action on making feedback more vivid, simple and enjoyable. I had the same idea a few years ago and went extremely deep into the thought process. I literally spent 8 months simply on trying to get rid of fundamental issues of the basic concept. Everything that you have mentioned has pretty much been either implemented into my prototypes or plans but despite that there were these extremely critical burdens that made me put this idea on hold for now. Anyways, maybe check out the post where I explain my idea and where Indie Hackers give me feedback for it. This might be helpful to you:
    https://www.indiehackers.com/post/disrupt-my-business-idea-and-i-will-disrupt-yours-07fe3f4c33?utm_campaign=digest-daily&utm_medium=email&utm_source=indie-hackers-emails

  2. 2

    aren't there many alternatives to do just that? even daos (decentralized autonomous organizations) have similar voting procedures. not sure what your core user base will be here.

    1. 1

      Well, yes, there are tens if not hundreds similar products. Being able to differentiate is not easy, I know. But what you see now is just a starting point. There's a lot of ideas and a lot of work ahead, so we'll see how it goes.

      One thing that gives me hope is that our users on my other website are https://candlapp.com already started posting their ideas there.

      Thanks!