20
138 Comments

I'll roast your website

🚫 THREAD CLOSED: Please submit your website at Roasti 🚫

Share your website link, and I'll provide you with 10 5 brutally honest comments on Markup to help you in improving your design. Courtesy of Designfly

on May 22, 2023
  1. 4

    Please feel free to provide your most honest feedback. Thank you in advance for your time and insights!

    https://www.masteryourinterview.com

  2. 3

    Here it goes - thanks if you take a look! https://www.ratepunk.com

    1. 2

      The lovely visual of the site. I like everything from the colors to the fonts :)

    2. 2

      Looks awesome to me! :)

      1. 2

        That's so nice to hear, thanks!

        1. 1

          Incredible press logos. How did you get all that? Do you just have an impressive PR person?

  3. 2

    sounds painful, but we'll go ahead with it. Here you go: cubiloon(dot)co

  4. 2

    Hi Bradley, just signed up for indiehackers and saw your awesome post! Waiting for your roast on our website https://napps.io
    We are Shopify Mobile App Builder for Shopify and WooCommerce

  5. 2

    Hi friends
    My name is Aliya Khan I am a new member of this forum site
    Thank you so much

  6. 2

    I'll get back to roasting more sites in the AM, keep dropping those links.

  7. 2

    Lol. Not finished. But app is live. Prepared to be roasted into oblivion!

    https://formulashq.com/

  8. 2

    Up for being roasted. 😄

    Qwurty

  9. 2

    Thanks for the offer, Bradley! I appreciate it.

    Here's my product website - EarlyBird, I am eager to hear your professional advice on it!

  10. 1

    Just staring out on blogging - theaieffect .co
    Im not allowed to post a link unfortunately

  11. 1

    Serpple is an advanced free SEO tool that provides accurate keyword rank tracking along with unique additional features.

  12. 1

    Would appreciate any feedback: www.referhub DOT org

    It's a job referral matching web app. Just finished the landing page!

  13. 1

    Remove scroll overflow in your .p timeline as it displays scroll bars in the browser :)

    1. 1

      What OS and Browser are you using?

      1. 1

        Vivaldi (chromium) on Windows. The problem does not occur on mobile but it appears also on firefox on windows.
        .p.timeline {
        overflow: scroll;
        }
        shows scroll on default.

  14. 1

    I would appreciate your feedbacks on my website LogoMakerr.AI (https://logomakerr.ai/).

    It's an AI-powered logo design maker platform that creates logos and brand kits so any comments regarding the design would be a big help.

    Thanks!

  15. 1

    Yes, I would like you to share your genuine review. What things do you think need to be improved on our website Churnfree?

  16. 1

    There are some problems in your own website @bradkins, would you like me to offer you a light roast?

    1. 2

      I would greatly appreciate that. Don’t be shy

      1. 1

        So, I'm looking at your website, https://designfly.io/ and the first obvious issue I see is that the website is painfully slow. Google's PageSpeed tool gives it a performance rating of 39 out of 100. That is so slow, that Google is going to penalize you with its search results.

        In regards of UX, I don't really understand the logo at the top of the landing page. When I move the mouse cursor over it, it starts to spin and if I click it, it will simply reload the page. There is no use in any of that.

        You are using a rather light gray font color over a dark background that has light gray horizontal and vertical lines on it. This is not idea for legibility, I would suggest using a lighter font.

        Visually, the word "Startup" and "Go unlimited" are rather similar. This is problematic, because users might not realize that one is a clickable button, one is a text effect. I would suggest making the CTA button more clearly a clickable button. Also, I'm not sure if I love the "Go unlimited" text for your main CTA button. It's a bit odd choice of words. "Let's start" or anything along those lines would make it much more clearly a CTA.

        The above issue is also within the next visual elements, all the "Submit your request" etc boxes look exactly like buttons, but they are not.

        In the portfolio screenshots section, I would prefer to see actual screenshots that I could click to enlarge to see your previous work, instead of these automatically scrolling non-clickable images.

        The UX of the FAQ box is also a bit odd. Some parts of the question boxes are clickable, some are not. They should be fully clickable, i.e. the answer should be shown no matter where within the box user clicks. Also, these boxes look visually identical to the earlier "submit your request" etc boxes, which were not clickable.

        Overall, I think this is a pretty good looking website, its main UX problem is that it's not always clear what elements are clickable. For better usability, I would use a lighter font color and conversion wise, I would tell the story about who you are and why should I buy designs from you instead of other nameless and faceless people online.

  17. 1

    Can't post a link yet but if you can tradeschoolsnearme dot co don't be too brutal

  18. 1

    Love it!

    Pretty new on IH so I cannot post url :(
    --> dataaxy

  19. 1

    Agradecido por tus comentarios en esta Web que lanzo la semana que viene
    Vendemos motos usadas.
    abcmotor. app

  20. 1

    Ok, fine. But its super early alpha release, Bradley. Have at it. https://bitcoinlaunches.com/

  21. 1

    codeform .it - React Native Templates

  22. 1

    Go on!

    https://o2pay.co

    OxygenPay, Global, secure and irreversible crypto payment gateway

  23. 1

    Thanks, Man. Here you go:- https://aitools.fyi/

    Love to hear feedback from anyone.

  24. 1

    https://obeatow.com - visual bug and feedback software

  25. 1

    https://leadgen.tools
    B2B AI Lead Generation SaaS + Training

    1. 3

      Hi, it looks like you configured your Google Sign in incorrectly. Let me know if you need any help as I have been dealing with their sign in api for nearly 4 years

      1. 1

        Yes I'd like some help please! I just tried through a friends google account, wasn't able to see the issue

          1. 1

            You were right, thank you so much! I've fixed the issue now. I added both domains, https://www.codelessapi.io and https://codelessapi.io and it seemed to do the trick!

            Could you try again please? Also, let me know if there's anything I can do for you! :)

  26. 1

    Hey there, I doubt anyone roast it ! It helps travelers/nomads explore new places, find activities and things to do in +35k cities !

    Download Android: https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.linked4.app.social

    Download iPhone: https://apps.apple.com/us/app/viby/id1222353770?ls=1

  27. 1

    Got time for two? :P

    https://duckist.com - Share password between your coworkers, clients, freelancers easy and securely!
    https://toolel.com - Share developer notes, tools, and ask questions without any ads making it super simple :)

  28. 1

    Thanks for your time Bradley, here is something to roast: https://omnisome.com

  29. 1

    Well I assume you're overloaded with requests already ;)

    If not, feel free to take a look at https://webtoapp.design

    I've been thinking of reworking the landing page recently (once again...)

  30. 1

    @bradkins linkedcamp.com
    cloud based LinkedIn Automation Tool.

  31. 1

    go ahead Bardley! Will be waiting for your roast - duonut[dot]c[o]m

  32. 1

    Here it is..Have a look at: Textdrip

  33. 1

    Please review my app's Launch Soon page: https:/[/]team-sight.c[o]m. Sorry had to write the URL like this because currently not allowed to paste links :(

  34. 1

    Kindly or unkindly roast our forms backend https://fabform.io

    1. 1

      Looks great! One suggestion from me:
      The text like "No credit card required. It's free to try!" is hard to read over the gradient color. Maybe try tweaking the gradient color a bit :)

  35. 1

    🔺🔺🔺🔺 Please search for "Victrays" on Google and click on the first link that is related to AI tools.

  36. 1

    I just signed for indiehackers because I saw this post :)

    https://clous.app

  37. 1

    Were do you all make your websites
    ?

    1. 1

      Next.js framework

    1. 1

      Sorry for the delay, but your roast is ready! 🔥
      Here's the link to your Markup file: https://app.markup.io/invite/accept/uCZ-_8wt

    1. 1

      Sorry for the delay, but your roast is ready! 🔥
      Here's the link to your Markup file: https://app.markup.io/invite/accept/TUX67LVd

    1. 2

      Sorry for the delay, but your roast is ready! 🔥
      Here's the link to your Markup file: https://app.markup.io/invite/accept/RNoqsjs4

    2. 1

      Hi Frida,

      I'm a fan of your service and think you have a great idea for effortlessly creating web pages and channels. I like how you make it easy for anyone to create a page without any technical skills or sign-up required.

      However, I also think there are some areas where you can improve your website and your service. Here are some suggestions that I hope you will find useful.👇

      • Your website design is too simple and bland. It does not reflect your brand personality and value proposition. You should use more colors, fonts, images, and animations to make your website more appealing and engaging.🎨

      • Your website copy is too vague and generic. It does not explain clearly what your service does and how it benefits your users. You should use more specific and compelling words to describe your features and benefits. You should also include some testimonials and social proof to build trust and credibility.📝

      • Slashpage does not offer much variety and creativity in its web page designs. All the pages look similar and bland, and they do not stand out from the crowd. The design elements are limited and basic, and they do not reflect the personality and style of the page creators. Slashpage does not allow users to customize their pages to their liking, and it does not provide any templates or components to choose from. The best way to solve these faults is to switch to UIHUT B2B Design Platform, where you get the access of reselling and using and your users can access over 23000+ designs for various niches and purposes. I believe it will help you 20X growth at least buy may in a very low cost like 6-7k USD.🔥

      • Your website navigation is too confusing and inconsistent. It does not follow the best practices of web design and usability. You should use a clear and consistent menu that guides your users to the most important pages and actions. You should also use clear and consistent labels and buttons that tell your users what to do next.🔗

      These are some of the things that I think you can improve on your website and your service. I hope you will take them into consideration and make the necessary changes to make your website and your service better.

    1. 2

      Hi andrewtan,

      I'm a user of your app and I think you have a great solution for organizing your life using Org mode files. I like how you respect my privacy and freedom by using free and open-source software and allowing me to choose my own storage provider.

      However, I also think there are some areas where you can improve your website and your service. Here are some suggestions that I hope you will find useful.👇

      Your website homepage does not have a clear and catchy value proposition that tells me what your app does and why I should use it. You should use a short and memorable headline that summarizes your main benefit and differentiator. You should also use a sub-headline that explains more details about your app and how it works.📝

      Your website homepage does not showcase your features and benefits with screenshots or videos. You should use visual elements to demonstrate how your app looks and feels, and how it can help me organize my life. You should also use bullet points or icons to highlight your key features and benefits.🎨

      Your website homepage does not have a clear call to action or a sign-up button that invites me to try your app. You should use a prominent and persuasive button that tells me what to do next and why I should do it. You should also use social proof such as testimonials, ratings, or logos to build trust and credibility.🔗

      These are some of the things that I think you can improve on your website and your service. I hope you will take them into consideration and make the necessary changes to make your website and your service better.

      What do you think of this feedback? Do you think it's helpful?

  38. 1

    Burn ittt "infinitdesign .co"

        1. 1

          Hey man! I hope you've been able to implement some of the changes I recommended. If you like some more help, I just launched https://roasti.co to continue providing design support to the community.

      1. 2

        Thanks a lot for your rcm. I'll improve it

        1. 2

          No problem, I'm glad you found my feedback helpful! If you like some more help, I just launched https://roasti.co to continue providing design support to the community.

      1. 1

        Thank you so much @bradkins , for your really constructive review ! working on changes!

  39. 1

    Health and fitness

  40. 1

    Roast away and add your initiative so I can help you get the word out about your roasts 😂 https://buildinpublic-streak.web.app/

      1. 2

        thanks -- updated and markup.io is slick

        1. 1

          No problem! If you like some more help, I just launched https://roasti.co to continue providing design support to the community.

  41. 1

    Please do - SaaSHub. And many thanks.

    • a contra offer: If you verify Designfly and list a few competitors, I will feature it on our newsletter - The SaaS Tribune. Cheers!
      1. 2

        Hey @bradkins, many thanks for your feedback/review. It was actually helpful. I've also regarded most of the highlighted issues. Cheers! And good luck with Designfly.

        1. 2

          No problem, I'm glad you found my feedback helpful! If you like some more help, I just launched https://roasti.co to continue providing design support to the community.

          1. 1

            Ah, I love the homepage of roasti.co! It's soooo good. Amazing job.

            1. 1

              I appreciate that! It's been a fun project.

    1. 1

      Hey! I noticed you made some changes that I recommended and they look great! I'd love to showcase ayaiq.com on Roasti.co, I added a before and after shot of your landing page along with a link, you're the second review, you can check out what it will look like here: https://roasti.webflow.io/

      All I need is to gather a review and headshot to feature on the site, you can submit it here: https://form.typeform.com/to/eXRcP7px

      Thanks so much!

      1. 2

        Thanks Brad for the roast! I've filled the form in, happy to be featured. Goodluck with your venture, it's a great idea.

    2. 1

      Link isn't working

      1. 1

        Thanks for letting me know, fixed

  42. 1

    This comment was deleted 3 years ago.

  43. 1

    This comment was deleted 3 years ago.

Trending on Indie Hackers
I've been building for months and made $0. Here's the honest psychological reason — and it's not what I expected. User Avatar 170 comments This system tells you what’s working in your startup — every week User Avatar 52 comments 11 Weeks Ago I Had 0 Users. Now VIDI Has Reviewed $10M+ in Contracts - and I’m Opening a Small SAFE Round User Avatar 46 comments 7 years in agency, 200+ B2B campaigns, now building Outbound Glow User Avatar 17 comments Show IH: WeProcess. Integrated platform or another all-in-one stretched too thin? User Avatar 9 comments Most teams think they have a detection problem. They don't. User Avatar 8 comments