2
1 Comment

Looking for feedback: how would you present open-ended rankings without losing clarity?

I’m building a small experiment called Rankiwiki, a site where every input becomes a ranking item.
The core rule is intentionally simple:
Anyone can type any word
That word instantly joins the ranking
No predefined options, no forms, no signup

This has been interesting, but it created a UX issue I didn’t fully anticipate.
As more people participate, long-tail entries (one-off words, spelling variants, synonyms) slowly dilute the percentages.Nothing is wrong with the data, but the top ranks start to feel weaker than they actually are.

I don’t want to delete or ignore minority inputs, openness is kind of the point,but I also want the rankings to feel meaningful at a glance.

Right now I’m considering a few approaches:

  • Show Top N, group the rest as “Others” (expandable)
  • Hide ultra-small entries by default (never delete, just collapse)
  • Normalize obvious duplicates (plural/singular, spacing, common synonyms)
  • Show vote count + %, not just percentages

Before I implement anything, I’d really appreciate outside perspective:
If you were a user, what would make an open, free-text ranking feel clear and trustworthy, without killing the “anyone can say anything” spirit?
Happy to share more details if helpful. Thanks!

posted to Icon for group Feedback
Feedback
on December 21, 2025
  1. 1

    First you have to do your best to correct at the time of entry. So if for Best Anime I enter "Frieren: Beyond Journey's End" and someone has already entered "Frieren" then you have to ask me if I meant "Frieren" and if so it's just like I clicked "Frieren" to begin with.

    So that way the duplicate simply never gets entered - which is your best outcome.

Trending on Indie Hackers
I built a tool that shows what a contract could cost you before signing User Avatar 120 comments The coordination tax: six years watching a one-day feature take four months User Avatar 80 comments My users are making my product better without knowing it. Here's how I designed that. User Avatar 66 comments A simple LinkedIn prospecting trick that improved our lead quality User Avatar 60 comments I launched on Product Hunt today with 0 followers, 0 network, and 0 users. Here's what I learned in 12 hours. User Avatar 57 comments I changed AIagent2 from dashboard-first to chat-first. Does this feel clearer? User Avatar 39 comments