1
3 Comments

My experience with AppSumo marketplace

I was skeptical at first, thinking that offering a low-cost lifetime deal on AppSumo marketplace for my SaaS might jeopardize my usual sales generated on my website, so I was delaying this decision for few years already.

Then I received a message inviting me to add my product to AppSumo. I decided to give it a try and I am very happy about the results.

I have Auto Affiliate Links WordPress plugin that I previously sold only on my website and was making about $1k/month in sales.

I launched on AppSumo in 2022, and I made about 30k in 3 years, basically doubling the revenue generated by the SaaS. My fear that it would affect my usual users was not realistic. There was no effect on conversions on my site.

It looks like AppSumo have it's own user base that are looking for good deals, and my product benefited by making it available in their marketplace. I have reached customers that I would not have reached otherwise.

I read that a lot of people said that the revenue was low while they had to provide lifetime customer support. I have to mention that I was not on AppSumo select, instead I was on self-listing marketplace, which gave me about $55 from a $79 sale.

I also read that most AppSumo sellers are profiting from upselling other versions. I did not to this yet, because I am not working full time at this product and I never had the time to create something else.

However, these days I have integrated AI in Auto Affiliate Links, and since it is using API that cost money, probably I have to offer a version where I charge for API usage.

on February 8, 2026
  1. 1

    The "no cannibalization" finding is reassuring — the common fear is LTD buyers would have been regular subscribers anyway, but your data suggests AppSumo genuinely reaches a different audience.

    $55 from $79 on self-listing is a surprisingly good take rate. AppSumo Select takes a much bigger cut, right?

    Curious about the AI integration economics: are you thinking usage-based pricing on top of the LTD, or limiting AI features to a separate tier? The challenge with LTD + API costs is that your heaviest users become your most expensive ones.

    1. 1

      I don't know yet how it would be in the end. I think that it is fair to have AI usage based pricing on top of LTD. But I still want to give to LTD users some of it, maybe providing a limited usage to LTD buyers.

      1. 1

        That's a fair approach — "limited free usage for LTD, then pay-as-you-go" gives them value without making your heaviest users your costliest ones.

        Framing matters too: calling it "AI credits" rather than "limited access" feels more like a bonus than a restriction.

        Curious how your current LTD users respond once you roll it out — will you announce it proactively or just add it quietly?

Trending on Indie Hackers
I built a tool that shows what a contract could cost you before signing User Avatar 111 comments The coordination tax: six years watching a one-day feature take four months User Avatar 73 comments My users are making my product better without knowing it. Here's how I designed that. User Avatar 63 comments A simple LinkedIn prospecting trick that improved our lead quality User Avatar 50 comments I changed AIagent2 from dashboard-first to chat-first. Does this feel clearer? User Avatar 39 comments Why I built a SaaS for online front-end projects that need more than a playground User Avatar 15 comments