4
5 Comments

Need a Indie hackers slack channel?

Hey, so a friend and I are in a couple of different product communities and all of them have a slack workspace, it often results in us not engaging with this community because its on a completely different platform. Do you guys think Indie hackers should have a slack channel?

on June 6, 2020
  1. 5

    In my entirely personal opinion, Absolutely not.

    The best things about IH is that people share their stories and insight publicly, it's searchable through Google and shareable with just a link. If the discussion and advise is now behind a super secret (due to the fact that not every IH user will join it) inner group, moreover it's non searchable, non indexable, all older discussions are practically hidden. If that turns out to be the case I'd much rather go somewhere else.

    Chat groups always become the echo chamber of the active 1% (that's an unrefined way of putting it, but you can see every other discord and slack group to see the truth in that). I'm against chat groups in massive communities because majority of users are lurkers who like to read rather than write. Chat mechanics work against it by flushing away everything apart from the ongoing discussion (sometimes even that). Yes, channels, threads and topics (a neat feature in Zulip) does mitigate it to some extent. That helps a group of 150 guys in a corporate office, not 45k people whose scale of activity is so massive, it's no better than WhatsApp or telegram styled chats.

    1. 5

      Bingo. These are just a few of the many reasons there isn't (and probably never will be) an official IH Slack/Discord/Telegram/etc. The dynamics just aren't the best for growing a large community imo.

      1. 3

        I don't agree fully. There should be a place for synchronous (chat) and asynchronous (forum) conversation. Independent of the place the conversation takes place, all content should be universally accessible. There are ways to make this work in Slack. Just requires diligent moderation powered with automation tricks.

      2. 1

        i'd say this statement is true as it relates to Slack/Discord/Telegram and many others:

        The dynamics just aren't the best for growing a large community imo.

        ... but, i think that IH will be challenged just like other large(r) communities: as things get bigger, they must get smaller.

        i can see smaller, affinity-based groups coming together in IH without taking from the core experience. but, i can also see things evolving and changing... which is a good thing too.

        im watching, listening, and thinking through all of these things! so fun.

    2. 2

      This makes a lot of sense Mayank, the mechanics are completely different.. I definitely hadn't noticed that. This becomes more content-oriented than discussion-oriented, you're absolutely right.

    3. 1

      This comment was deleted 6 years ago