1
3 Comments

Nobody posts their reply rates by channel. Here are mine.

Everyone loves to declare a channel dead. Cold email's dead. LinkedIn's dead. Nobody posts real numbers, so it stays a vibes argument.

Here are mine. Same product, same offer — just sent in different places. Across 27,178 conversations:

Reddit — 20.6%
LinkedIn — ~14%
X — ~9%
YouTube — ~6%
Cold email — ~1%

The top channel replies twenty times more than the one most people pour budget into. One reason: on the top four, the person already typed the problem out loud in public. Cold email is you guessing they have it and interrupting on a random Tuesday.

Here's the free part — how I'd mine each one by hand, today, no tool:

Reddit — search your buyer's pain phrases, sort by New, stick to niche subs. the "anyone know a tool for X" posts with 2 comments convert better than the 200-comment ones.

LinkedIn — same phrases in the search bar, set to Latest. comment in public first, DM second. the comment is what makes the DM land.

X — save 3-4 phrase searches, reply in the open. on X the reply is the funnel, not the DM.

YouTube — read the comments on tutorials next to your product. people literally type the feature they wish existed.

Notice the pattern: you're not blasting anyone. You're finding the one person who described your product in their own words and replying like a human. That's the whole reason the top of that list beats the bottom.

I got tired of running all four by hand, so LeadSynth watches them for me — catches the person the moment they post, drafts in my voice, books the call. First leads are free, no card: https://www.leadsynthai.app — but the phrase-search trick costs nothing and works on its own.

Real question for the room: what's your highest-reply channel right now, and your worst? Wondering if the cold-email gap holds across niches.

on June 20, 2026
  1. 1

    This is one of those posts where you read it and realize you've been operating on vibes instead of data. The cold email gap is brutal. and I think it's worse than the % suggests because even a reply from cold email is often "not interested" or "stop emailing me," while a reply from Reddit/LinkedIn/X tends to be someone who actually wants to talk.

    One thing I'd add: reply rate is the wrong north star if you're selling higher-ticket. Cold email's 1% can still be your highest-revenue channel if those 1% book $5K deals. Reddit's 20% might all be $50 customers. Worth segmenting by deal size too.

    Curious ! on YouTube comments, are you replying to threads on tutorials for complementary tools, or searching for specific pain phrases in the comments? I've found the comment sections on "how to automate X" videos are goldmines if you filter right.

    1. 1

      the deal-size point is the one i keep relearning. you're right that reply rate on its own is vanity if the channels skew different price points. i started tracking reply -> booked call -> closed by channel instead of just the top-line %, and cold email's "bad" 1% looks a lot better once you weight by deal size. reddit brings the volume + warmth, but the bigger contracts have actually come from linkedin.

      on youtube it's the second one. not tutorials for our own tool, but searching pain phrases in comments under adjacent "how to automate X" / outbound videos. exactly like you said those sections are full of "i tried 3 tools and they all break at Y" people describing the problem in their own words. the only hard part is filtering past the "great vid!" noise, which is most of it.

      how are you handling the deal-size vs reply-rate thing rn, actually tracking revenue per channel or still gut?

      1. 1

        Tracking per channel with a lightweight CRM tag per lead source. Not full pipeline attribution yet but enough to know cold email sends the highest average deal size even if the raw reply rate looks bad. LinkedIn is a surprise for me too - lower volume than Reddit but the conversations tend to be more serious.

        The YouTube filtering problem is real. I've been using a simple heuristic: ignore any comment under 30 words or that compliments the video. The signal is almost always in the 50+ word complaints about specific tools breaking.

Trending on Indie Hackers
Priorities for launching a SaaS solo, with no budget User Avatar 205 comments I built a tool directory that doesn't pretend every founder has the same needs User Avatar 40 comments Why founder-led outbound breaks the moment you try to delegate it User Avatar 7 comments I built a browser-based photo geotagging tool. What should I lead with? User Avatar 6 comments AI helped me ship faster. Then I forgot what my product actually does. User Avatar 5 comments I recently launched on product hunt and here is how i went from #94 to #20 User Avatar 3 comments