6
20 Comments

Privacy-first analytics - what do you use & do you get the data you need?

Working as a full-time software developer, I sometimes get a peek at the kinds of data that "big platforms" who specialize in extracting as much as possible out of every site visitor can collect. It's mind boggling how easy it is to cross a line privacy-wise that I'm not personally comfortable with, so in my own projects I want to make sure I'm getting the data I need while also respecting users privacy.

Some questions:

  • What privacy-first analytics platform(s) do you use/recommend?
  • Do you get the data you need or have you come across limitations in the effectiveness of that data?
on December 17, 2022
  1. 2

    I switched to Plausible more than a year ago and I love it, it provides me with anything I need. I wrote this about privacy-conscious alternatives:

    https://rocketvalidator.com/blog/privacy-conscious

    1. 1

      Did you swap from Google Analytics?

      Great and succinct article, nice rundown at the end of other products too. I hadn't heard of Commento before, will need to check that out for my own blog too.

  2. 2

    Shynet, a self hosted stats app using Django framework.

    1. 1

      Oh now that's a new one for me, confirming it's https://github.com/milesmcc/shynet right?

      1. 2

        Yes it's that one.

  3. 2

    I put together a good list of options:
    https://nts.strzibny.name/privacy-oriented-alternatives-to-google-analytics/

    I use Plausible but some new ones look good too.

    1. 1

      Hey this is a great list, thanks for sharing! Love seeing articles posted years ago getting updated over time too, I should be more mindful of doing that too.

  4. 2

    I was just in the process of writing a blog post about this when I saw your question (https://andypi.co.uk/2022/12/18/best-privacy-first-wordpress-analytics-gdpr/). I use both Matomo and Countly. As far as I can work out, apart from Offen.dev, these are the only (self-hosted) analytics solutions that allow you to track Personally Identifiable Information etc in a GPPR compliant way. One of my clients wants to track rentention & returning visits as an organisational objective, and so I use Matomo for them since it is has a fuller set of features that include this - of course this requires consent inside the EU and other locations too. If you are looking for anonymous (and without using consent popups), then I've tried https://counter.dev/, it's ok but would not recommend as its feature set is too limited. I'm also looking for an anonymous analytics software without needing consent, so I'm going to checkout plausible.io as other commenters have mentioned. I think simpleanalytics.com is similar as well.

    1. 1

      Hi Andy,

      Would you be kind enough to review and add https://usermaven.com to your blog as well?

  5. 2

    I also vote Plausible! Two things worth noting: 1) Can't track retention (see https://plausible.io/data-policy) and 2) Ad blockers will block it even though it's one of the "privacy-focused" analytics tools. Still love the tool though :)

    I tried Posthog but wasn't a fan personally, because the dashboard was a bit cluttered and the analytics out of the box was wrong for my project (more DAUs than WAUs somehow).

    I haven't tried it, but https://pirsch.io/ also seems interesting. Much cheaper than Plausible's cloud-hosted offering, and the UI looks clean.

    1. 2

      I fixed the adblockers issue by using their npm package https://www.npmjs.com/package/plausible-tracker

    2. 1

      Can't track retention

      I think no retention tracking is a reasonable tradeoff to using something with privacy in mind, sounds like you'd agree with that? Have you had situations where it would have been really helpful to see retention?

      Ad blockers will block it even though it's one of the "privacy-focused" analytics tools.

      How'd you find out that it's blocked by ad blockers? Self-tested?

      I haven't tried it, but https://pirsch.io/ also seems interesting. Much cheaper than Plausible's cloud-hosted offering, and the UI looks clean.

      Thanks for the lead on a second option too! I agree this UI is among my favorites.

      Wanted to also share I found https://matomo.org/ in my research too, seems like they've been around a long time. The UI isn't the best but they have a self-hosted option too and seems to offer a ton of features.

  6. 2

    I mainly use a self-hosted plausible.io setup. It's almost free and I like that. It's doesn't store data that can be considered identifying information so that's really good privacy-wise. You can signup for a subscription via GitHub sponsors and get customer support like a normal paying customer while still using the self-hosted version.

    One main thing to know, your analytics will almost certainly be blocked by ad blockers so your analytics are always going to be wrong.

    The downside of plausible is that it's by design very simple. So you're goal conversion data is rather simple. They are working on adding funnel stuff which is cool. If you're self hosted your geo data is limited by what version of the data library you're willing to get. The free is good enough. But considering all I really care about is, what page did they enter from, what pages did they exit from and what are the referrers the data is good enough.

    1. 1

      Wow another vote for Plausible! Thanks for the heads up on the Github sponsors support option, I could see that being useful during setup for sure. Sounds like it's "good enough" and getting better, basically all I could ask for really.

      I did a bit more research on Plausible after basically everyone in the comments recommended it, tried comparing to other products and found this one from Matomo - https://matomo.org/plausible-vs-matomo/ that does mention user flows. Reminded me of your note about Plausible working on adding funnel stuff, Matomo has a self hosted option too if you were interested in alternatives too.

  7. 1

    I use https://umami.is/ free and privacy focus, easy to start with and I can host on a myriad of platforms.

  8. 1

    We are an SMTP email service provider. We offer email delivery via various SMTP email services such as MS Exchange, Postfix, and Courier. Let us help you increase your email response rate!Use our smtp mail services,especially developed for small & medium businesses.
    sources-https://smtpget.com/smtp-service-provider/

  9. 1

    Hi Steve,

    I'd like you to have a look at my product https://usermaven.com. There's a generous free plan (upto 1 million monthly events) so you can test-drive it by yourself.

    I am confident, you'd love the simplicity and ease of use because we autocapture events so you don't need to write code everytime you want to track something.

    And, it's far more advanced in powers than Plausible, Pirsch or any other privacy-friednly analytics out in the market.

    Looking forward to hearing from you!

    • Waqar
  10. 1

    This comment was deleted 3 years ago.

Trending on Indie Hackers
I'm a lawyer who launched an AI contract tool on Product Hunt today — here's what building it as a non-technical founder actually felt like User Avatar 150 comments A simple way to keep AI automations from making bad decisions User Avatar 65 comments Never hire an SEO Agency for your Saas Startup User Avatar 62 comments “This contract looked normal - but could cost millions” User Avatar 54 comments 👉 The most expensive contract mistakes don’t feel risky User Avatar 41 comments We automated our business vetting with OpenClaw User Avatar 31 comments