promised to come back with PH results. here they are.
5 days ago I posted my pre-launch numbers here. got 6 comments with solid advice. promised to report back. so here it is.
Product Hunt results:
- not featured
- 30 visitors on launch day (8 from PH directly)
- 2 signups on D-day
- 66 total visitors over 3 days
- 4 people actually used the product
- 2 full evaluations completed
the person who used it spent 9+ minutes reading a report that took 47 seconds to generate. so the core product works. distribution doesn't.
what I got wrong:
- 2 weeks of community building wasn't enough. multiple people here told me 2-6 months. they were right.
- not being featured = invisible. most visitors came from links I shared myself.
- had 5 early signups from pre-launch. none showed up on PH day.
what I got right:
- the product held attention when people actually found it
- radical transparency in my D-2 post here got more engagement than any "launching soon!" hype post would have
- treating PH as one channel, not THE channel — already shifting to reddit and direct community participation
what's next:
- daily community participation (giving feedback, not promoting)
- SEO content around idea validation
- finding 10 beta testers who'll actually use it regularly
if you launched on PH and didn't get featured — what worked for you after? genuinely curious about the post-launch playbook when the launch itself doesn't hit.
building ideadose — ai that evaluates startup ideas with GO/RISKY/KILL verdicts. ideadose.dev
Trending on Indie Hackers
love the transparency. most people share PH launches but never follow up with real numbers. what was your biggest takeaway — was the traffic spike worth the prep time? i've been debating whether to launch my outreach tool on PH or keep grinding cold email. the honest results posts like this help me decide.
And to me...that time that it takes to have a "successful" PH Launch...is much better spent elsewhere. Just another captured platform.
hard agree. "captured platform" is the right framing. if you're not featured, PH is basically a landing page you don't control. 10 out of 82 sessions from PH, the rest were self-generated traffic. shifting focus to channels where i own the relationship — reddit communities, indie hackers, and eventually SEO content.