October 21, 2019

Research: How often do you use mockup generators and why do you use them?

Hey IndieHackers!

Currently I do a bit a research about mockup creating software and I would like to know, how often do you use such generators?
Also I'd like to know, which one do you use and why do you use them?

  1. 1

    I don’t, at all. I have tried dozens over the years but have always found that:

    • I can design a flat mockup in Photoshop 5x faster

    • I can just start building the interface in HTML/CSS and probably get it done just as fast

    • I hate doing work 2x, and that is what most mockup generators feel like.

    1. 1

      Ah, I get your point.

      Maybe we dont talk about the same topic.

      Look at https://screely.com.

      That is what I'm talking about.

      Maybe I wasn't clear enough.

      Sorry for that.

      1. 1

        Ah, I get it. So basically a wrapper for a system UI?

        It looks cool, but I probably would never use this since it can be done more realistically in PS in a couple minutes (just screenshot my own desktop and paste a mockup inside?

        1. 1

          I would say this website could do it faster. Also, you dont need photoshop if you use this. I did a bit of keyword research and a lot of people search for something like that.

          1. 1

            That makes sense. However I would venture to guess everyone doing UI mockups like this has PS already, so it's not like they'd buy it just to put a wrapper around it.

            My instinct is that something like this would not be very valuable to me personally (and I would never pay for this) but that is just my personal reaction and may very well not be the opinion of the majority.

            1. 1

              Yeah, you're right. I thought or think the same way. For a product that's free, it is okay but you don't save a lot of time. If you do more mockups, you may have photoshop in the first place.

              Only automation would make sense somehow I think.

              Automatic screenshots of changed websites or something like that. But who would use that?

              Some other opinions would we perfect.

              1. 1

                The only way I would see this being truly valuable is in an API form for an app comparison/review type website. A website like alternative.to or something, where it can automatically generate thumbnails from websites etc.

                1. 1

                  Hmmm, hard to decide...