3
8 Comments

Research: How often do you use mockup generators and why do you use them?

Hey IndieHackers!

Currently I do a bit a research about mockup creating software and I would like to know, how often do you use such generators?
Also I'd like to know, which one do you use and why do you use them?

on October 21, 2019
  1. 1

    I don’t, at all. I have tried dozens over the years but have always found that:

    • I can design a flat mockup in Photoshop 5x faster
    • I can just start building the interface in HTML/CSS and probably get it done just as fast
    • I hate doing work 2x, and that is what most mockup generators feel like.
    1. 1

      Ah, I get your point.
      Maybe we dont talk about the same topic.

      Look at https://screely.com.

      That is what I'm talking about.
      Maybe I wasn't clear enough.
      Sorry for that.

      1. 1

        Ah, I get it. So basically a wrapper for a system UI?

        It looks cool, but I probably would never use this since it can be done more realistically in PS in a couple minutes (just screenshot my own desktop and paste a mockup inside?

        1. 1

          I would say this website could do it faster. Also, you dont need photoshop if you use this. I did a bit of keyword research and a lot of people search for something like that.

          1. 1

            That makes sense. However I would venture to guess everyone doing UI mockups like this has PS already, so it's not like they'd buy it just to put a wrapper around it.

            My instinct is that something like this would not be very valuable to me personally (and I would never pay for this) but that is just my personal reaction and may very well not be the opinion of the majority.

            1. 1

              Yeah, you're right. I thought or think the same way. For a product that's free, it is okay but you don't save a lot of time. If you do more mockups, you may have photoshop in the first place.

              Only automation would make sense somehow I think.
              Automatic screenshots of changed websites or something like that. But who would use that?

              Some other opinions would we perfect.

              1. 1

                The only way I would see this being truly valuable is in an API form for an app comparison/review type website. A website like alternative.to or something, where it can automatically generate thumbnails from websites etc.

                1. 1

                  Hmmm, hard to decide...