2
13 Comments

Roast my (AI-generated) landing page

Think you're better than AI? Here's your chance to roast my landing page:

https://livingjournal.pro

Background:

I've just launched my AI-powered journaling app. All the functionality was designed and architected by me, but coded by AI. I also got AI to generate the landing page.

Personally, I know I can do better than the generated AI, but what's "better"? The right metric should be conversion. So I'm letting my AI-generated version prove itself before I go in and manually redo it.

on July 6, 2025
  1. 1

    The feedback about clarifying the output is the key one. 'How it works' sections usually describe the process, not the result - and visitors are asking 'what will I see or feel after using this for a week?' not 'how does the AI work'. A simple fix: add one concrete before-and-after example. Here's a journal entry. Here's what the advisor surfaced from it. That single comparison does more work than 3 feature bullets. Showing the output makes it real in a way that describing it doesn't.

  2. 1

    Nice work shipping this — the visual design feels calm and credible. Biggest conversion lever now is outcome clarity: in the hero, say the exact result users get (e.g., “Turn daily journal entries into weekly mood patterns + action plans”). Then make “How it works” 3 quick steps and include one real output screenshot (insight card, summary, or checklist). Right now the mechanism is interesting, but the output is what sells. I’d also add a low-friction CTA above the fold (“See sample insight”) before sign-up. If useful, I can share a deeper teardown here: https://roastmysite.io/go.php?src=ih_aijournal_20260330_1753_hv

  3. 1

    One more practical test: show a concrete example of what the AI gives back after someone journals — one insight card, one summary, or one action prompt. Right now the mechanism is interesting, but the output is what closes the loop.

    That single example would probably do more for conversion than adding more feature copy.

  4. 1

    Fast trust stack for your first CTA section:

    1. “Trusted by” logos (even 3–5 is enough to start)
    2. One-line privacy/risk reducer (e.g., no card required / cancel anytime)
    3. One short testimonial with role/company

    People don’t just buy the offer — they buy certainty.
    Move trust signals right next to the CTA and watch clickthrough lift.

  5. 2

    Hey Farez,

    It's always interesting what AI can come up with, so I had a peek. For me, it was easy to read, the space is not cluttered, so I could focus on what the product does. The "How it works" section could be highlighted more. After I saw your hero page I was quickly looking for how this works.

    From the hero section I understood it is a journaling app for mobile, and there is an AI advisor involved which had me intrigued, but from your "how it works" i still don't really get how this works. I'm creating journal entries, and the advisor in the background is analyzing what I'm writing, but then what is the result? Is the advisor giving me text reports at the end of the day? Is the advisor creates visual insights of my moods and goals and habits I write about? Is the advisor creates me a checklist I need to follow (since it mentions converting goals into actionable steps)? It's fine if the app is just organizing my thoughts, but I immediately have these expectations from how you present the app, and I'm not sure if this is what it's about.
    So definitely needs to be clarified further.

    The overall landing page has a professional and calm look, I really like it, goes well with a journaling app. It's great to know what the advisor is capable of, very detailed, just consider adding the output as well.

    Good point for highlighting privacy!

    I hope you find my feedback useful, and good luck with your product!

    1. 1

      Thank you Krisztina. That's detailed. Good recommendation there about adding output from advisor!

  6. 1

    Here are some thoughts on your landing page copy:

    • Pre-headline. It might make sense to add a pre-headline that says "Free AI-Assisted Journaling App" so that the product category would be clear immediately.

    • Headline. Emphasize the main benefit that the user will get from using your product. If you are targeting people who are already using ChatGPT for this, consider emphasizing how your product is better than ChatGPT.

    • Subheadline. Explain how the product works in 1-3 short sentences. At the moment it's not clear, at least to me.

    • Call to action. I would change the wording to "Start Journaling for FREE!" or something similar.

    • Bullets. You might want to add three horizontal bullets below the call to action that address potential objections. Something like "No credit card required. Works on both iOS and Android. Privacy-focused."

    I can rewrite your landing page copy in exchange for an honest testimonial. There's no catch — I'm just looking to build my copywriting portfolio.

    Let me know if you're interested!

    1. 1

      Thanks for the detailed feedback. Those are really good actually!

      Ok, I'll take you up on your offer. Pls email me: [email protected]

  7. 1

    The hero is clean, professional.

    The phone screens of the app are not good.
    Explain how you differentiate from other journaling app (Value Proposition).
    Too much text, not enough visuals.

    1. 1

      Thank you Mouad.

      That phone image was rushed. It's useless, I agree.

      Great point about comparing with other journaling apps!

      Also agree with more visuals and less text. I found it hard to do this but need to find a way. Maybe more demos.

    2. 1

      Agreed on phone screenshots.

      Can't read them on my laptop because the font is too small. Annoying!

Trending on Indie Hackers
I built a tool that shows what a contract could cost you before signing User Avatar 120 comments The coordination tax: six years watching a one-day feature take four months User Avatar 80 comments I launched on Product Hunt today with 0 followers, 0 network, and 0 users. Here's what I learned in 12 hours. User Avatar 69 comments My users are making my product better without knowing it. Here's how I designed that. User Avatar 66 comments A simple LinkedIn prospecting trick that improved our lead quality User Avatar 60 comments I changed AIagent2 from dashboard-first to chat-first. Does this feel clearer? User Avatar 39 comments