"TBD" is a conversion killer (and why founders get defensive about it)
I spent my weekend auditing landing pages, and I found a massive "Trust Leak" that I see everywhere: The "TBD" Trap.
I told a founder that showing a "TBD" prize pool while their stream was "Offline" was scaring users away. Their response? They told me to "GTFO."
It’s hard to hear your "baby" is ugly, but logic doesn't care about feelings. If you ask for a user's trust (or their money) before you show the value, your conversion rate will stay at 0%.
I’m currently at 4 sales for my logic auditor tool, RoastMyLanding, and I’m hunting for Sale #5 today.
I’ll do 3 manual logic roasts in the comments for free. >
Drop your link if you’re brave enough to hear why people aren't clicking your CTA.
Trending on Indie Hackers
The TBD trap is real but it's the visible tip of a bigger pattern — landing pages shipped before the product is real enough to talk about specifically. "TBD" is just the most obvious artifact. Same trap shows up as "coming soon" badges, placeholder testimonials, vague "trusted by teams everywhere" claims, fake user counts dressed up as social proof.
The pattern we see at Hivemind across landing page audits: founders ship the page when the product exists, then spend 6 months wondering why traffic doesn't convert. The fix isn't fewer TBDs, it's waiting until you have one real customer story, one real result, one real screenshot. A landing page built around one real proof point outconverts a polished page built around imagined ones every time.
The founder telling you to GTFO is the tell, by the way. Defensive reaction to a logic critique usually means the founder already knew and didn't want to fix it.