Spent way too long optimizing metadata for an app that was never going to rank. Not because my ASO was bad, but because I picked a niche that was already owned by apps with 50k+ ratings. Lesson learned the hard way.
Here's what actually changed things for me:
Niche selection is your ASO foundation, not an afterthought.
You can write perfect title copy, nail your keyword field, A/B test screenshots until you're blue in the face... and still get buried if the category is a warzone. The apps sitting on page one got there years ago and have review counts you can't realistically compete with on a normal timeline.
The move is to find gaps BEFORE you build. Lower competition niches where ranking is actually achievable. This is where I started using Niches Hunter, which tracks 40k+ apps daily and surfaces opportunities before they get crowded. The revenue estimator alone saved me from building something with basically zero monetization ceiling.
The other thing nobody talks about enough: Apple and Google Play are completely different games.
Apple indexes your title, subtitle, and a 100-character keyword field. That's it. Every character counts, no spaces between comma-separated terms, and don't repeat words already in your title.
Google Play indexes your full description. Totally different approach. Treating both platforms the same is probably the most common expensive mistake I see.
Quick framework that actually works:
Week 1: Audit keyword rankings, note what dropped or climbed
Week 2: Refresh metadata based on what the data's telling you
Week 3: Analyze screenshot/icon conversion data, queue A/B tests
Week 4: Review ratings trends, respond to negatives publicly, check retention signals
The whole thing takes 1-2 hours a week if your tooling is solid. Retention and uninstall rates are behavioral signals that affect rankings now too, so shipping something people actually keep using is genuinely part of the strategy.
Wrote up a full breakdown with the keyword tactics, visual asset stuff, and launch timing details here: https://nicheshunter.app