13
16 Comments

The niche you would never target with your startup and why.

There are a lot of discussions about niches. Which one to target. This is the opposite question.
What is the niche/area you would never target with your startup and why?

My two are probably:

ToDo List (oversaturated in my opinion)
Project management tool (oversaturated in my opinion)

  1. 8

    Indiehackers 🙂

    • Typically avoid spending money on software
    • Usually, we (Indiehackers) think we can hack it together ourselves
    • Churn rate would be huge due to the overwhelming failure rate of startups with Indiehackers

    Of course, I have an open mind and would love to see a product that could go against the grain here and prove those points to be wrong.

    1. 1

      Very interesting point :) I'm looking at this as a niche.
      Does everyone agree with this? Am I in the wrong place :)))?

    2. 1

      Hah, you're probably right. But it depends. In my experience, about 80% of my friends think as you said. The rest is able to pay even for something that can be hacked together in 5 minutes :)

  2. 6

    I will stay out of any niche where I:

    • don't personally know people who work in it / use tools in it
    • don't understand the dynamics of the market
    • don't know at least a bit of history about
    • don't know who makes the purchasing decisions

    The great thing: all of these things can be overcome by research or just talking to people.

    1. 1

      The last point is huge - thanks for that

    2. 1

      I can just agree with you.

  3. 4

    Any niche that's resistant to technology and would require a lot of B2B sales to close. No thank you... Ideally, my target customer should already work on a computer for a living, pay for various SaaS software, and are tech-savvy enough to navigate and use any standard SaaS web app with minimal hand-holding.

    1. 1

      my target customer should already work on a computer for a living

      Oh boy. I remember with my first startup having to educate customers about the difference between a double click and a single click (mostly noticed as they double clicked their way through our webapp). 🤦🏻‍♂️

    2. 2

      This comment was deleted a year ago.

      1. 2

        Yeah, seems like a recipe for a lifestyle business.

        I almost thought you meant it as an insult. Lol.

        But yes, it's a recipe for a lifestyle business.

        I don't believe in working for a business, but in a business working for me. I think there's way too much propaganda out there for entrepreneurs to kill themselves and sacrifice everything to chase the biggest ideas or markets, no matter how ill-equipped or ill-suited they are for such grand pursuits. Propaganda mostly perpetuated by people with vested interests, such as investors who hope to profit handsomely off founders...

        "Lifestyle business" was quite a dirty word in the startup world just a few years ago. Now, at least to me, it seems to make perfect sense. Life is too short to do something you don't want to do.

        1. 2

          This comment was deleted a year ago.

  4. 2

    "Local events" because Paul Graham said it's a "Perennial tarpit" in terms of startup ideas lol

    1. 1

      Pretty much any idea that starts with "wouldn't it be cool if ... ??"

      (Disclaimer: I started a local events company after college. Very hard to focus on a niche and too tempted to make it for everyone and therefore, no one)

  5. 2

    it's not about niches, it's about problems. If I'm not having the problem, I'm not going to solve it. I solve for myself first before anyone.

  6. 2

    Anything that is seasonal (no constant business), hype of the month/year/century (looking at you crypto :), rips people off (payday loans etc) and any other predatory niches.

  7. 2

    Niches are great because they’re fractal: when they get too big, smaller ones appear inside them :)

    ToDo lists are definitely commonplace (and making one would bore me) , but I can see a todo list geared toward a small subset of the population (young veterinarians, middle class single moms, amateur plane pilots, whatever....) working.

    But to answer the question, restaurant owners scare me a bit so wouldn’t do anything with them I guess

    1. 1

      I did 2 projects for restaurants and the biggest problem was the lack of knowledge on their side to describe me what they actually need. But this was like an agency project not a startup.

    2. 2

      This comment was deleted a year ago.

  8. 1

    100% agree on both... especially the PM tool... I've been a PM for over 15 years and have used pretty much every PM tool out there and find they are all nothing but a complete waste of time and money... always end up back in excel...lol

Trending on Indie Hackers
After 10M+ Views, 13k+ Upvotes: The Reddit Strategy That Worked for Me! 27 comments 🔥Roast my one-man design agency website 18 comments Launch on Product Hunt after 5 months of work! 16 comments Getting first 908 Paid Signups by Spending $353 ONLY. 13 comments Started as a Goodreads alternative, now it's taking a life of its own 12 comments I Sold My AI Startup for $1,500 and I'm Really Happy About It 11 comments