Random idea I had, looking for honest feedback, I'm not attached to this idea.
PITCH: Schedule gifts for your loved ones now, and we'll take care of sending it on time when their special day arrives. This won't replace all your gift-giving (mom deserves something more intentional), but this can allow you to forget about your little nephew's birthday but still let him know you're thinking of him.
I quickly copy/pasted together a barebones landing page just to give you an idea of what I'm thinking of: https://giftomatic.surge.sh
Where are your gifts coming from? Different retailers?
Trying to figure that out myself, because they probably informs what kind of business model I'd adopt. I'm thinking if I sell in-house products, I can get a bigger margin. Selling goods from different retailers would necessitate that I add some kind of fee for this service to charge on top of the price of the gift
First reaction is that it's a neat idea.
Second reaction was that it might not connect with people giving gifts to friends or family because there's nothing thoughtful about auto gift-giving. When you give a gift to a friend or family member, it's about being truly thoughtful (most of the time).
Even if the recipient doesn't know, the sender will, and will eventually they'll feel bad that they didn't take the time to pick out a gift for someone they love.
But, the service could work for companies looking to give customers, employees, suppliers, or partners gifts.
Just my 2 cents :)
Great point about it being impersonal and how it might work better for non-family, thanks!
Wow interesting idea. I love the ease of it and considering the difficulty of using the postal service to post a gift (getting a gift, going to post office, packaging, sending it).. this would be so much simpler. I would love to set one day a year to simply go through my close friends lists and send something small and meaningful to supply them. Loved the example of the high school friend - that's exactly who I think it would be perfect for.
My wishes - worldwide shipping, possibility to change address, maybe a notification a week in advance before shipping to ensure that the address is correct; no need to worry about customs taxation for the receiver..
Budget: 20 euros.
Currently solving this issue by: using other gift delivery services that are more country specific such as https://www.godisboxen.se/
(budget based on that)
All the best!
oh cool thanks for sharing that godisboxen site, very interesting!
I am obviously bias, since I built https://joyful.gifts/ - But I think it's a great idea!
P.S. There are so many angles of this - If you decide to pursue it, the end product will end up differently
Woah, awesome! As they say, great minds... lol. Definitely wouldn't try to clone what you have going on now. Right now I'm almost thinking of making a Shopify app instead that allows any store to offer to offer delayed-delivery, which might be another way to solve the problem of wanting to get Christmas/Birthday shopping done early.
Curious to know how things have been going in general? What's been working for you guys?
As someone pointed out in the comments, the biggest challenge in that space is customer acquisition. There are no one place where that customer hangs out. No immediate problems that need to be solved either. So, it’s a bit of a vitamin instead of a pain killer.
It’s basically 100% word of mouth growth (and obviously exposure stuff by me). Definitely not for someone in a rush or growth at all costs approach. But, it fits us, given what we are trying to do! (The blog on the website has info on our culture/approach).
Lovely that your idea already exists! I wish your website was designed a bit like this: https://www.godisboxen.se/ so that I could easily get an overview of all available gifts. But maybe you are considering a different audience? :)
I like the idea as well.
I'd love a product where I can specify things specific people in my life like. Every time I learn about some new hobby or interest, I would input it into the service. Maybe I'll also add birthdays and other important dates. And then when this date is close, the service reminds me of it and gives me a choice of three gift ideas. Maybe I can reshuffle / get new ideas if I don't like them.
It's an idea that could really develop in interesting ways. Good luck!
I like it! I don't like gift shopping. I feel like I suck at it and I end up gifting weird items. Would be great to select from a curated list or "groupings" like candles, flowers, serving dishes, etc.
Also, I feel like I'll get bonus points for remembering everyone's birthday! Haha. This would be great to have pre-set for holidays as well.
I definitely can think of a couple people that would appreciate this service.
My one note would be to make sure it's "white labeled". Wouldn't want the receiver to know its from x company rather than me.
And wrapping! I'm horrible at that.
Sounds like you would be a potential user for https://joyful.gifts/ - Exactly what you described. Would love if you give it a try and let me know what do you think.
I think this could be helpful for not that close friends, but close friends and family, I would not use that. For example, I would never auto gift my daughter her bday present, I have to physically take her and let her choose it. For close friends, I would need to choose something specifically and I would be only comfortable doing so myself. But let's say my work colleague which I am not that close to, I could do that. Overall, I feel it's a good idea but needs some tweaking, what would that be you say? I have no idea :D
lol definitely needs tweaking, appreciate you giving feedback about how this would/wouldn't work for certain friends in your life
Funny thing is, I saw some project here on IH that was almost exactly the same. Sending gifts automatically to people you define for occasions you define. You just set a budget and that's it.
Another interesting thing is that I'm building an app that could be complementary to such a service (see post on my profile). I'm also looking for a co-founder :)
Final thought regarding @iammike's comment is: I feel the same, but you could make it work for family. Maybe the user can make lists of things he needs as presents for certain occasions for certain people. The service will procure the items, pre-package them as gifts, and send them to the user. Maybe the user can enter some special preferences of the person who will receive the gift and the service could somehow try to get a more personalized version of the item (for example if the person who receives the gift likes a certain color, a certain food, has a certain hobby and so forth). The user will receive a personalized version of the gift he wanted and personally delivers the gift. I also think the personal delivery is key, so if you can build something helpful around that, the service might stick.
You were probably thinking of https://www.indiehackers.com/product/joyful-gifts
Yep!
Woah, neat! There are no original ideas under the sun lol
Appreciate the suggestion for making it more personalized/personal!
Yeah I like the idea.
Would be nice to have a total autopilot mode too so I don't have to choose the gifts, perhaps have product groups or ranges people can choose from?
I would 100% add my top tier clients list to this and have you guys distribute gifts to them at certain times.
Interesting idea, yeah I haven't thought much about how the products would be grouped, but you definitely have me thinking about it now. Thanks!
I think in this case, the part of the idea that you most need to validate is whether you can get in front of people who want to use this. There's no single group of people that have a community for wanting to give gifts automatically - nobody hangs out on internet forums dedicated to this. So the key question is whether you can tell yourself a story about who wants this, when they think they need this, and can you get in front of them at this moment?
For what it's worth, the site also renders oddly in Firefox:
Good luck!
I wonder if trying to focus on "niche" products (like handmade products or environmentally friendly products) might help me find a forum to pitch to
Etsy?
That's an idea!
Good point about thinking about how to get this in front of customers. And yikes thanks for the screenshot!
This comment was deleted 6 years ago