3
7 Comments

Web App or Mobile?

I find myself going back and forth on this question a lot when starting a new product. What are some of the factors that you consider?

posted to Icon for group Product Development
Product Development
on March 1, 2020
  1. 2

    Mostly to prove an idea is enough to create a web-app. And it is much and much cheaper.
    When you have this MVP working and clear for your first audience, you can take interviews with them and understand if they really need a mobile app.

    And even when they say "Yes" it is not always true. But we have an option to make at least 1 mobile app (Android or iOs) and based on hybrid technology. It is much easier to make it with Turbolinks if you have a web-app. Then you'll see if they really use it or not.
    This is the leanest approach from my point of view.

    As far as I know from my experience people don't like to install more and more mobile apps. They better consider using a chat-bot instead.

    1. 2

      I really like this approach. Starting with a web app and trying to build an audience and then getting feedback on if they would actually want a different way of interacting with the product. Thanks for your help!

    2. 1

      And to make a right interviews try to see this book http://momtestbook.com/
      Only indirect questions could be working.

  2. 2

    Well the real answer is, it depends. We need more context to really know.

    But some general rule of thumb..

    1. Start with frameworks that you know. You will get to validating your product a lot quicker.
    2. Where are your users at? Mobile or web?
    3. Is your product better tailored that someone is using at home or on the go?

    And then some of my reasons for why I personally bias towards web and never mobile.

    1. People don't want to pay much for mobile apps so its hard to make money.
    2. In my opinion, most indie hackers should be doing B2B, so mobile ussually doesn't make sense there.
    3. Way faster to iterate on the web because there are no app store (mainly apple) that you have to get acceptance through.
    4. You don't have to build for 2 platforms (iOS and Android). Even if you choose a hybrid approach (React-native) there are headaches added.

    And if you can, I would focus on one or the other. It's a lot of work for one developer to handle an iOS, android, and web app for their product. I made this mistake before. I had two mobile apps and 1 web app that I had to keep up with when I built coffeepass.io

    1. 2

      Thanks for the great insight! I’d answer your questions but after a couple hours on IH I’m now questioning everything about my current direction haha.

      Really curious, do you mind expanding on why most indie hackers should focus on B2B? I haven’t heard anyone give an opinion on that and it sounds really interesting.

      Thanks again for your help!

      1. 3

        Yeah sure!

        Mainly because of this chart.

        Anatomy of a 10k MRR business:
        $5/month - 2,000 customers
        $25/month - 400 customers
        $100/month - 100 customers
        $250/month - 40 customers
        $500/month - 20 customers

        It's a lot harder to get 2,000 customers than 400 or 100 when you are one person.

        Also, Consumers are usually not going to pay as much for software services. They are more used to things being free that they use. If you can make something that helps a business do their job and helps them make money it will be worth it to them because it helps them make more money. Consumers on the other hand are not usually making money from their products so its harder to charge them a good price for it.

        Jason Cohen, a big leader in the bootstrapped space and runs the company WPEngine is where I first heard this opinion from.

        There are probably some software consumer businesses that could work. But a lot of those you have to end up charging by ads, sponsorships, or some other means. Which means you need a lot of eye balls. Again hard to get a lot of eye balls unless you are an influencer or something like that.

        1. 2

          That’s fantastic insight, thank you!

Trending on Indie Hackers
Most founders don't have a product problem. They have a visibility problem User Avatar 97 comments Day 4: Why I Built a $199 Workspace Nobody Asked For User Avatar 51 comments How to automatically turn customer feedback into high-converting testimonials User Avatar 39 comments Spent months building LazyEats AI. Spent 1 day realizing I have no idea how to get users. User Avatar 32 comments Why Claude Skills Are Becoming Important for Tech Careers User Avatar 25 comments I kept rewriting the same quiz + spaced-repetition code. So I packaged it into an API User Avatar 21 comments