9
38 Comments

What if another indie dev launches a product similar to the one you are building?

Others: please comment your opinion

What if another indie dev launches a product similar to the one you are building?
  1. Build and Launch anyways
  2. Abandon
Vote
posted to Icon for group Ideas and Validation
Ideas and Validation
on September 12, 2023
  1. 7

    There are lots of bread at the grocery store

  2. 2

    I would say keep going. If their product is similar, find ways that your product stands out. Make sure to push that aspect and what makes you stand out!

  3. 2

    Depends on your strategy of execution.

    For eg. I am building a habit tracker and there are tons of them already in the market which were launched years ago and are doing their best at the moment.

    Now breaking into such a market is surely tough but there is gotta be something that you have unique that others don't. You need to capitalize on that small fragment of the entire app that is unique, be it even design.

    Next comes user acquisition and marketing. You need feedback from your customers or users to understand what is working and what is not.

    Next comes customer conversion, you need to have paying customers to sustain and provide validation of your idea and business.

    All in all, I would say there are a lot of steps responsible for the success of a product. Beat your competition in any of the steps and you would take the lead.

    1. 1

      To add to this, find out if there's a user group for your competition that you can join. This way, you can see where people are having problems, find out what they like about the existing solution and what they don't like. Reddit is a good place to look for these communities.

    2. 1

      That's a very good take and i like it.

  4. 2

    Keep building imo, most people will quit after a few months

  5. 2

    Actually it is very common. If you have good ideas people will copy you and you will have competition. If you idea is bad then nobody will copy you.

    As hard as making private rocket, spacex have blue origin to copy them . It all about how you out compete them. I would say if you know how to learn and copy what your competitor is doing it will benefit you.

    You can learn from their mistake and make better move.

    You just need to learn how to do it. Maybe you can checkout this article : Copy other people business is the easiest way for success

    1. 1

      Build, improvise and market, got it. Thanks for the article, it's a good read.

  6. 2

    Doesn't matter if someone does the same. World is huge and there are 8 billion people on our planet. Screw It, Let's Do It ( c) Branson. Let's get as an example vehicle's produce companies. How many brands do you know? And all of them run businesses and generate income ( let's not deep into the details :) ). So you will always get a piece of pie, the question is how seriously you consider your own project and are you ready for fight?

    1. 1

      That's a good perspective, Same thing with to-do and project management apps. Everyone gets a pie, and it's easy to see that market requirement because problem exists and so does multiple solutions

    1. 2

      I'm always curious why people don't consider this the first option over abandoning their idea. If anything, you can build a better product and get to market faster.

      1. 1

        Right! I've never tried/managed to do that though. Maybe because when you got nothing except idea it's hard to dilute it in favor of other's. There is a lot of ego to sacrifice and work to merge.
        But from the pure business perspective it is a great move, because one ~doubles the production preserving general vision which is a win-win.

    2. 2

      Difficult, because usually people who have launched as solo tends to never team up with another dev

  7. 1

    Contact him and launch together

  8. 1

    Keep going, it’s a big world, you never know what’s going to happen.

    Netflix was terrified of Blockbuster’s online movie streaming service which was later killed off by their management not understanding the power of streaming.

  9. 1

    I realized people customers aren't as aware of the similar tools as you are. Why do your competitors a favor?

  10. 1

    I also struggle with that idea before. But I think it doesn't matter. Anyway, the world is a very big place.

  11. 1

    Wait...you're building a todo list app too? ;)

  12. 1

    I've thought about this a lot as well. Today I found an app on Twitter that answers questions with any document and I thought: I came up with this idea a long time ago! It's the classic problem with "I thought up an idea and someone else did it".

    A few months ago, I presented my demo to a prospect who told me she's using another product that Google developed, and I was crushed by it, but then I realized I forgot to show her another feature that I didn't see any other competitor did, so it made me feel a bit less bad.

    With that said, I tend to agree with the other comments below. See how yours can be different, and identify the exact audience if need be. If there's something you could do better that the other competitor doesn't, implement and market it. That could be a part of your USP

    1. 1

      Same thing is happening to me right now, I have this idea, which I started building, and I saw someone made an app already. Will build it anyway now and maybe add something different

    1. 1

      haha direct competitor

  13. 1

    I think you can analyse his app, Identifying disadvantages and make yours better

  14. 1

    big question is it better? basically the same?

    different use cases? how are you marketing. is it different from them?

    if your plan is to put it on product hunt and that's it then you probably should find something else.

    if your doing cold email out reach or some other sustainable marketing method and you know you can build something useful I say go for it.

    1. 1

      Some core features mostly be same but design wise, it may be different. Take a to-do list app as an example and see its market. Core feature is same but executed differently in design aspect and marketed as an alternative may be?

    1. 1

      it may be funny but a common problem among indies

  15. 1

    Continue to build.

    1. 1

      build and not launch?

  16. 1

    This comment was deleted 2 years ago.

Trending on Indie Hackers
Why Most Startup Product Descriptions Fail (And How to Fix Yours) User Avatar 98 comments We just hit our first 35 users in week one of our beta User Avatar 44 comments From Ideas to a Content Factory: The Rise of SuperMaker AI User Avatar 27 comments AIgenerationtool — replacing hiring writers with 1 AI dashboard User Avatar 25 comments Why Early-Stage Founders Should Consider Skipping Prior Art Searches for Their Patent Applications User Avatar 20 comments NanoBanana or Seedream4.0? Why Choose When You Can Have Both User Avatar 20 comments