1
10 Comments

What is the best forum software ? in 2018

i cant decide between nodebb and discourse and flarum.

they all looks great

  1. 2

    your own software.

    1. 1

      bad idea

      1. 1

        Why? That worked well for Reddit, IH, PH, Laracasts, HN, etc, etc, etc...

        1. 1

          Because you spend all your time adding basic little features that people expect on a forum instead of building the community. You will probably also make a bunch of stupid mistakes that cause security problems.

          I've just written a new forum package to use across a few of my new sites and there is so much to consider to make it not feel like a cheap blog comment system. I really wish I could have used discourse or something and still regret NIHing it. I'll probably continue to regret it for a long time lol.

        2. 1

          waste of time, reinvent the wheel is useless when you have no competitor.

          Actually IH is a direct competitor of BlackhatWorld/Reddit.
          Since those two are here since long time the only strategy
          is to propose a new UI so it was a good decision to code it.

          the others that you are talking about are made by teams, i'm solo and i dont have that time.

          and the real question is does it worth to take that amount of time to code while you can use a modulable framework who is re-usable who has already a documentation.

          1. 1

            the others that you are talking about are made by teams

            That's not true.

            All of Laracasts, including its forum, was created by Jeffrey Way. He did this on the side, while recording lessons, editing them and running the company.

            HN was written by Paul Graham, by himself, while he was also doing all kinds of work building YC. Not only that, but HN was written in a programming language called Arc that he was in the process of designing at the time!

  2. 1

    I just migrated from myBB to NodeBB. its like night and day. NodeBB just looks sooo much better

  3. 1

    I like the look of flarum and personally I am more of a PHP guy so that is another plus. Discourse is pretty good too but it requires Ruby which for me is a no go. So I guess it comes down to choice of tech. as well. Flarum btw is still in beta and they have been very slow to get to a stable release (I have been watching them for a couple of years)

    1. 1

      yeah same, those little tags on the right side. definitly a killer UX/UI!!

      i feel like i'm gonna install Discourse or Nodebb and make a theme similar as Flarum LOL

  4. 1

    This comment was deleted 7 years ago

  5. 1

    This comment was deleted 7 years ago

  6. 3

    This comment was deleted 6 years ago

    1. 1

      at the end of the month im launching the french version of kanytothe