Hi everyone,
Currently working on a new design of an app and I was wondering, which UI is better?
Which do you think would benefit the end user more?
All suggestions are welcome.
The first one is so confusing to look at with the text. I thought it was an unsplash or pexels client. There is no clear purpose to the images you have shown and pretty random.
However, I would think about your UX, even with the images in number 2, they are still confusing. Consider going with icons.
Hey there all. The voted No. 2 design moved to a live product. Looking for honest feedback as well. If you are interested to see how it turned out, check the post here - https://www.indiehackers.com/post/fc3d7adae3
Thank you all for such good feedback. It is really appreciated.
I had a thought about creating icons which would have meaning, like in the No 1, without computer frame and without photo background, just with the rotate icon or other, but I thought that if I put a lot of icons in the same place, it would look a bit dull in the end.
Therefore, in No 2, I tried to find really beautiful images, which would have similar meaning between the action hidden behind it. For example "Image Flip" - a skier doing a flip, "Image rotate" - rotating carousel, "Image Exif Remover" - an anonymous guy and so on.
I say 2. The images are visually pleasing and i read the text, unlike no 1, i kinda of glanced over everything without reading anything really. I think its because all the thumbnails in no 1 are very similar and dull. I think the one that most benefits the end user is the one they are going to pay more attention to, so no 2.
Oh definitely, 2 out of these.
The first one is so confusing to look at with the text. I thought it was an unsplash or pexels client. There is no clear purpose to the images you have shown and pretty random.
However, I would think about your UX, even with the images in number 2, they are still confusing. Consider going with icons.
Hey there all. The voted No. 2 design moved to a live product. Looking for honest feedback as well. If you are interested to see how it turned out, check the post here - https://www.indiehackers.com/post/fc3d7adae3
#2 for sure. There's a clear call to action (i.e. click on the red plus sign).
2 is good :)
Thank you all for such good feedback. It is really appreciated.
I had a thought about creating icons which would have meaning, like in the No 1, without computer frame and without photo background, just with the rotate icon or other, but I thought that if I put a lot of icons in the same place, it would look a bit dull in the end.
Therefore, in No 2, I tried to find really beautiful images, which would have similar meaning between the action hidden behind it. For example "Image Flip" - a skier doing a flip, "Image rotate" - rotating carousel, "Image Exif Remover" - an anonymous guy and so on.
2 is better
In terms of aesthetics, the #2. In terms of content / presentation, the #1.
I say 2. The images are visually pleasing and i read the text, unlike no 1, i kinda of glanced over everything without reading anything really. I think its because all the thumbnails in no 1 are very similar and dull. I think the one that most benefits the end user is the one they are going to pay more attention to, so no 2.