1
0 Comments

Why Our Website Redesign Didn’t Fix Our Conversion Problem (And What We Missed)

Have you ever gone through a full website redesign...
and still saw no real lift in conversions?

Last year, after months of work (and a decent budget), we launched a brand-new SaaS website.

It looked beautiful.
The messaging felt cleaner.
The UX was buttery smooth.

But guess what?
Our trial signups barely moved.

What we realized later was:
✅ Visuals don’t fix unclear value propositions
✅ Pretty pages don’t guide users toward action
✅ Without understanding behavior, redesigns are just hope

We thought “new design = better conversions” — but in reality, flow, clarity, and user insight were the real missing pieces.

Curious to hear — what’s been your biggest lesson (or frustration) from a redesign? Always learning from other founders too.

If you've redesigned your site before, what was the biggest challenge?
  1. Looked great, but no conversion boost
  2. Hard to align marketing and product
  3. No clear user journey
  4. Traffic improved, but signups didn't
Vote
on April 9, 2025
Trending on Indie Hackers
Agencies charge $5,000 for a 60-second product demo video. I make mine for $0. Here's the exact workflow. User Avatar 147 comments I've been building for months and made $0. Here's the honest psychological reason — and it's not what I expected. User Avatar 140 comments This system tells you what’s working in your startup — every week User Avatar 40 comments 11 Weeks Ago I Had 0 Users. Now VIDI Has Reviewed $10M+ in Contracts - and I’m Opening a Small SAFE Round User Avatar 19 comments I built a health platform for my family because nobody has a clue what is going on User Avatar 15 comments Why Direction Matters More Than Motivation in Exam Preparation User Avatar 14 comments