23
51 Comments

Your Newsletter Has 0 Subscribers? Let's Change That!

Yo Newsletter Crew!
If you have 0 subscribers, comment

  1. Who should subscribe?
  2. Link to subscribe.

I'll go through your subscribe process.

Worst case scenario, I can't subscribe and will share with you why.
Best case scenario, I can suggest ways to get your first subscribers.
At least: you'll get 1 subscriber.

posted to Icon for group Newsletter Crew
Newsletter Crew
on May 9, 2020
  1. 2

    Just launched mine.

    1. Founders/founders-to-be who want to see how pre-internet era companies succeeded
    2. https://before90s.substack.com

    Have already published 2 posts

    1. 1

      Hi Leo, looks cool.
      I'd change your subtitles to reflect the lessons learned.
      Nice articles. I'll share one in Influence Weekly this week.
      substack makes it easy to sign up. so I did.
      And the welcome email left me wanting more. put in some more stories there. a gift for when I look in my email. leave me wanting more every time.

      No need to tell me you don't have a plan, in your email. Just don't have a plan or have one. I'd recommend sending weekly.

      1. 1

        Thanks for the nice words Andrew. Yes, for the next ones the subtitles will reflect the lessons learned.

        One more article to come this week. And yes, weekly looks good.

        Thanks for sharing in InfluenceWeekly!

  2. 1

    Product management newsletter where I skim 30+ publication & shares one best PM article thrice a week for free along with a 60 words summary.

    itsrabbithole.substack.com

  3. 1

    Get a New Startup Idea Every Week. Startup from Zero in 2020

    https://requeststartup.substack.com/

    1. 1

      Hey Logan, thanks for commenting here. Who is this for?

      I also don't think you have 0 subscribers now. How many subscribers do you have?

      I really liked your first edition about VAs. it's deep and full of resources.

      You can do a lot of work on the about page. I'd focus on re-writing that for about an hour on some afternoon, when you have the time.

      And you definitely also need to spend some time writing your welcome email.

      1 suggestion: copy/paste your VA article into a google doc, make it a PDF. and call it a "Virtual Assistant Report" Or something similar that sounds "official". Put a link to it i in your welcome email, and mention that people can download a report in their first email. Give them something. Yes it's super thing value, but also I think you can figure out more to put in it.

      1. 1

        Thank you for looking over my newsletter, and giving me good advice. I know i need to work on my about page, welcome, etc..

        Right now i have ten subscribers. 22% of my visitors subscribed to my newsletter. Which i think is outstanding.

  4. 1

    Hi, Andrew, I would love to get your feedback on my stock market newsletter Bullish. Thank you.

    1. 1

      this line is way more interesting that the top line "Get insights on the Stock Market directly into your email daily."

      You don't really need this line "Zero spam. Unsubscribe at any time."
      It breeds negative thoughts and doesn't really benefit the user in any way. It's like a box of pancake mix powder saying "no arsenic, you can throw any leftovers out"

      And I would add a few Frequently Asked Questions, and the answers to them to give people more reasons to subscribe.

      1. Why can't I do this with email updates from Schwab?
      2. Why do I need to get daily updates, I'm investing for the long term?
      3. My dad invests in stocks, I invest in opportunities!

      Those are examples. You'll know the questions people should have and the answers you want to share.

  5. 1

    Hello again,

    1. People who liked the idea behind Bee Informed and interested in seeing it in action
    2. https://www.beeinformed.app
    1. 2

      I think you can widen the net and provide more value than milestones in your newsletter.

      what are your customers trying to solve for? Can you give them tips or something more?

      A newsletter should provide value every time I open it and you should send it frequently. Otherwise it's just email marketing and I'd rather not sign up for that.

      you went from 0 to 1.
      I'm not sure how your signup for works or where it goes. but it worked fast. I entered and it did a transformation that I haven't seen any other sign up form do. I thought it was sorta cool...I'd like to see it happen again.

      Maybe put share buttons there. you got me signed up. so let me share it at that moment , perhaps.

      1. 1

        Thanks for the direction.

        As for the signup form, it's a convertkit embedded form. What was different that left you amazed?

        Share buttons are good idea too.

        1. 2

          It just did a cool animation that I hadn't seen anywhere.

  6. 1

    Hello everyone! I just launched this yesterday.

    1. I make a summary of my weekly entrepreneurial activities, briefs of my blog posts, quotes, books I’ve finished. Entrepreneurs and would-be entrepreneurs might be interested.

    2. https://buildersreport.substack.com/

    1. 2

      You really need to nail down who this is for. Who should be reading this and why. Sales and marketing are vastly different.

      While personal blogs and newsletters are fine. To gain subscribers and gain an audience, you need to bring them value every week.

      What are you doing that others can get, via your newsletter?

      What if you went through a new sales course every week and tried the tactics. Kept records of the sales you attempted, the course you learned the tactics from and the results. That alone, following you do that, giving me key take-aways would be amazing.

      And you don't have to pay for all the courses. There's a ton of udemy and youtube videos and courses on sales.

      If you watched 52 sales courses, and tried them out each week, in 1 year you'd be a god of a salesman. You would save thousands of people time from watching these courses as well.

      IF sales isn't your thing. Then replace the above with "Marketing".

      Try a new marketing tactic every week.

      1. Email (you started that first issue already)
      2. Reddit Marketing (how many posts, what were the results?)
      3. Facebook Groups ( how many posts, what were the results?)
      4. Influencer Marketing (interview 3 ppl who will share your newsletter)
      5. Content Marketing (put out a pdf lead magnet summarizing the last 4 weeks)
        ...
      6. Start a podcast interviewing marketers
        ...
      7. Start a referral program for your newsletter.
        ...

      ... and just keep going. returning to some when you want to try a new angle on it.

      1. 1

        Hi Andrew,
        Thanks for the detailed suggestions. I'm going to dig into how I can provide solid value.

        Thanks

  7. 1
    1. If you enjoy political cartoons and keeping up with the news.
    2. https://weeklycartoon.news

    You'll be first to receive the first edition @AndrewKamphey !

    1. 1

      signed up. you really need to show some examples there.
      The text isn't going to help you much.

  8. 1

    Just launched www.scalecuts.com

    1. Anyone who's interested in finding out how successful companies really scaled. As well as other scale tactics that I come across.
    2. www.scalecuts.com
    1. 1

      Everything about your site is nice. Really warm and seems super useful.
      Then the moment I tried to signup for your email

      I see I'll get "a case study every once in a while"
      It was very off-putting.
      At that moment I had my cursor on it and I realized oh.. do I really want this.. if I'm not going to get it often?

      and then when I signed up. it says "Your request has been sent."
      Did I signup? Did I get in?

      if you have something for me to get in my email. tell me.
      Oh and you should definitely send a case study in the first email. Not "once in a while"

      1. 1

        Interesting & thanks for feedback.

        Re: the once in a while, I guess its not going to be weekly or bi-weekly thing, I'm aiming for monthly max so timing is a bit up in the air. Take your point this could be fine-tuned. I also think though that some people don't want a super regular email newsletter cluttering their inbox. So that could appeal to people. Will make it tighter though.

        You should also get a confirmation email once signed up - can see that this is paused though so have amended.

        Thanks for review :)

  9. 1

    I've finally made the leap of faith and started my own side project 3 weeks ago!

    It's a blog + catalogue of personal finance calculators/spreadsheets. My intention is to share educational content and more calculators with subscribers. I'm building my audience right now, I've never share my project publicly with anyone.

    https://personalfinancetemplates.com/blog/ - subscribe button is on the right.

    1. 1

      Looks really useful.

      I would package up all the templates and have ppl give you their email address to get all the templates in one.
      You're giving them away for free?
      If not, then package 2-3 great ones and give them away for an email sub.

      The CTA needs to strong for you to get subs. Right now on the right side is only "subscribe".

      1. 1

        Yeah I need to work on CTA a bit more. Currently I'm giving all the templates/calculators for free, but I'm asking users to sign up, so I don't distribute the template links completely open.

        I want to have a least 5-10 useful calculators before I start sharing my content a bit more aggressive. My plan is to send emails to subscribers whenever I publish blogs or templates - if it's more than few times a week I'll be sending weekly summary of new content.

  10. 1

    If you're interested in working at a foreigner-friendly tech company in Japan :)

    https://japan-dev.com/

    1. 1

      This seems like a super useful site for someone who really needs this.

      On a popup signup form: You have 4 bullet points and only one of them actually make me want to sign up. The bottom three literally have no value to me as a subscriber. You don't have to tell me who unsubs. You want me to subscribe!

      On your home page, as I scroll, I see 2 text lines and then a signup form and then 2 text lines. I'd cut that down to 1. Keep it super simple.

      Get Jobs In Your Inbox.

      And I'd think about making a lead magnet to entice people to signup and get something in their email right away. You're working with ppl who are looking to upskill, get new jobs, get first jobs, get higher paying jobs.
      Perhaps you can put together 5 interviews with developers on Interviewing for a foreign job. Put it in a PDF and give it away when ppl apply.

      I tried to signup on your home page. nothing happened when I clicked the button.

      when I tried to sign up on your popup, after I clicked, the popup just went away.

      you should say "Go check your email". and have something in there to get!

      Hope this helps. and hope I signed up.

      1. 1

        Wow thanks so much for the detailed info! I was definitely unsure about the number of unsubs thing (got it from marketingexamples.com) but I hadn't considered the fact that the other two weren't really giving people reasons to sign up. I'll re-think them.

        I do also have lots of data I could theoretically repackage as a PDF so I might try the "lead magnet" idea too (or I could probably convince some people to do interviews as you mentioned).

        I tried to signup on your home page. nothing happened when I clicked the button.

        That's odd. It's working for me but I'll look into this a bit more deeply (it's supposed to close the modal and show a flash message banner at the top saying thanks).

        Thanks again for the ideas, I'll rework it.

        1. 2

          There are two signup forms. 1 modal and 1 form midway down the site. the midway form is what I'm talking about. enter email click and then it just moves the screen up to the top.

  11. 1

    Nice one, Andrew. :-)

    For crypto and blockchain interested people: https://double-edge.net/

    1. 1

      YOu only have a signup form as a popup when I first get on the site. Kill the popup and put a big signup form front and center.

      Get the email address to get your whitepaper.

      when I refreshed, the popup didn't come back.

      I had to reload the site in incognito in order to sign up. Then you say "thank you".
      you really need to entice the subscriber to go to their email. Get something interesting.

      1. 1

        Andrew, many thanks for the feedback and the suggestion, it´s highly appreciated! I especially like the idea of email adress in exchange for whitepaper. Gonna work something out now...

  12. 1

    Hey Andrew. Nice initiative. What would you say about it:

    1. Nocode builders, who are going to make some automation or create own product
    2. https://tabbli.com
    1. 2

      I went to the site looking for a newsletter. Almost didn't find it. It was on the very very bottom on the left. And the only "persuasion" is Get latest news! Never spam.

      1. You don't need to tell people what you won't send them.
      2. latest news on what? You might assume it's no-code. but what does that mean "News on no-code". you are app. so are you sending me new apps to try? are you sending me no-code theory? whitepapers? studies? reports? tweets?

      A few ideas
      You could send people a weekly use case of no code.

      No Code Apps tested weekly.

      Interviews with No-Code makers talking about their projects.

      1. 1

        Thank you, Andrew. Nice points. Yes, you are right. I very appreciate your points of view. And even going now to make changes on the site.
        Subscription is not the general Call-To-Action of course. But I will place it also somewhere in the middle of the landing page.
        Interesting to see how are you thinking about what kind of news is expected. Sure, I have to be more specific and more attractive.
        Thank you once again.
        And interesting to read your other replies to other questions.
        My best wishes, Alex

  13. 1

    Nice! A little while ago there was a ListChat for Bloggers to connect with each other.

    In case it's helpful, I've created one to match Newsletter owners to connect and follow each other, too!
    https://list.chat/subscribe/newsletter-crew/hmK51QsryTwqs3O24TrQ

    1. 1

      Tried to go to the link. doesn't seem to be working. let me know if it's just me.

      1. 1

        Whoops! Fixed!

        1. 1

          Sorry I think I broke your service. I signed up with [email protected]. and I can't send from that email so I can't reply to emails.

        2. 0

          To be honest, I write a newsletter and I don't know why I should subscribe to this. Tell me on that landing page more of the benefits. Tell me some use cases. Give me some testimonials.

          This line seems to stop short:
          " When we do, we'll send along your answers to the following questions."

          were there supposed to be questions listed?

          And what about if I have multiple newsletters? Because I do and I just signed up. Will I be matched with myself?

  14. 1

    Hey ho,

    I've added a mailchimp subscription button to sidebar of my blogpost. Haven't actively optimised it nor approached that topic. Plan to do in near future. So, let's give it a try

    1. People who are beginning the indie hacker (or bootstrap startup) journey, so that they can have the first impressions how it looks like
    2. its' on https://brunoraljic.com (I won't tell you where it is exactly)
    1. 2

      Did you get 1 sub?
      I entered my info into the "are you indie hacker too?" and never got a welcome email or a confirmation email.

      IF you have any welcome email I'd suggest not saying "Thanks for your subscription"

      and I think the header should say "are you an indie hacker too?"

      IF you don't have a welcome email. Write one. Now.

      1. 1

        Yeah, I got it. And no, I don't have welcome mail, obviously.

        Are you referring to that feedback label that pops up after submitting? It comes with that default widget, I can probably embed it differently to remove those defaults.

        About the header and the whole newsletter, I'm thinking to niche it a bit, it wouldn't be for ALL indie hackers in general, more like for people that are entering this world, fresh indie hackers. I'm thinking about the header to be "Launching your first idea?" or "Are you a fresh indie hacker?" and in the body to explain that I'll send my experiences so that they might avoid some mistakes.

        You're totally right about the welcome mail. I wasn't even paying attention to that, since I didn't see it as a promotion channel. Still learning.

        Thanks

        1. 1

          you should send a welcome email :)

          I'm not a fan of questions as headers here. Because you're not solving a problem. You're actually guessing that they self-identify as that problem and will take any solution what-so-ever.

          Your header and CTA should make the reader a better person.

          • Learn all the mistakes I went through building a $100M business.
          • Tips and Tricks on building an independently wealthy business.
          • For new hackers to learn from an older, wiser, developer.
          1. 1

            Cristal clear :)

            I also like the advice on CTA, I got the point

  15. 1

    Is it fair to post if I already have a whopping (drum roll, please) - 32 subscribers..?

    You should subscribe if you are interested in SEO, affiliate marketing, building website, and digital businesses AND you want to follow my journey of me building something from nothing. Challenges and experiments are a big part of this.

    https://benasdigital.com/ (the subscribe form is very obvious - difficult to miss)

    1. 2

      Totally fine!
      Here are a few things you can change.

      1. You mention in your first full sentence: "I", "my", "me" before you get to the first you. And the "you" is about seeing behind the scenes. And then you say "no BS attached" but that whole sentence I read was about you.. not me getting better. Write copy about how reading this and getting these updates makes your readers better.

      2. You have seemingly 4 things to do for a viewer: "Read more here", "enter your email below", "your best email address", and "sign up, it's free"

      • The 2nd one is underlined text, not a link.
      • The first is the most compelling. I clicked that first.
      • above the fold: limit your CTA to signup. Move the "read more here" down below and actually give the reader the tips or tactics you're doing. Link to your editions. Give them the 5 best things you've shared so far. or the 5 challenges you faced and got through. links to the exact edition. BELOW THE FOLD.
      1. Give me something to get in your first email. don't say "welcome" . Maybe it's a breakdown of your first 10 days. Maybe its a "First 10 Days of Every Business Ever" and make me download it from your welcome email. Tell me to go get it on the signup page. Make sure the subject makes me want to open. and then give it to me. You'll get ppl opening your first email and every email after!

      Hopefully this helps get you to 100 subscribers.
      At least you're at 33 now ;)

      1. 1

        Oh, wow.. thank you! Were not expecting such an in-depth review. Some really great points for me to work on. Again, thank you :)

  16. 1

    Hey Andrew,

    I would love to hear your opinion.

    1. People working digital marketing who could use improvement of the process of designing their social media posts
    2. https://iamlori.app/
    1. 2

      The reason I should subscribe is to get updated that you'll launch. Very little to compel me to sign up.
      What I would do is 2 things.

      1. Create a downloadable PDF. "100 of the best tweet images ever" or "10 Elements that Make or Break a Brand on Social Media"

      2. Create a weekly tips email. Learn how the best businesses use Social Media every week. <==== I'd sign up for that! Give value now, and then you can update them on your launch anytime you're ready. And you can write 10 "blog posts" probably now about what brands should do. Schedule those as emails for the next 10 weeks so you don't have to worry about content. and then if you don't launch within 10 weeks write 10 more. Should be a fun sunday afternoon.

      And when i signed up there's no confirmation email?

      1. 1

        Hello Andrew,

        This is some really constructive feedback. I thank you for that.
        I haven't thought on creating useful content in this phase, but after release phase. I will definitely go for creating it as early as possible.

        Cheers! 🍺

  17. 1

    This comment was deleted 5 years ago.

    1. 2

      What's your time on site like? Because it did take a while for the page to load for me. Wondering if ppl thought the site wasn't loading.

      To be honest the words or wording is a bit confusing. So you're not getting me a job. You're not sending me jobs. you're sending me tools that will help me get a job.

      the CTAs were very weak. If i were job hunting. I'd either want leads (jobs) or Advice. Not sure how a tool helps me. You need to go above and beyond in explaining that connection. A person who lands here who wants a job needs to be told exactly what they are getting.

      Everyone wants to be faster, wealthier, better. Tell them how every part of your site and newsletter helps them.

      UX Hunting Kit: For Your Next Job Hunt.

      • Job Boards to speed up your job search
      • Portfolio Inspiration to make a better first impression.
      • Aggregated Salary Info to increase your salary.

      And for your CTA for your newsletter: Subscribe for the latest news + exclusive discounts to power-up your job hunt

      I'd put together a 10 page guide to something. and put that behind the sign up. put it in the first email they get. They have to open that email. your #1 goal is to get your signups to open their first email!

      1. 1

        This comment was deleted 5 years ago.

Trending on Indie Hackers
I spent $0 on marketing and got 1,200 website visitors - Here's my exact playbook User Avatar 70 comments Veo 3.1 vs Sora 2: AI Video Generation in 2025 🎬🤖 User Avatar 31 comments I built eSIMKitStore — helping travelers stay online with instant QR-based eSIMs 🌍 User Avatar 21 comments 🚀 Get Your Brand Featured on FaceSeek User Avatar 20 comments Solo SaaS Founders Don’t Need More Hours....They Need This User Avatar 16 comments Day 6 - Slow days as a solo founder User Avatar 16 comments